The art market is the marketplace of buyers and sellers trading in commodities, services, and works of art .
59-618: Artnet.com is an art market website. It is operated by Artnet Worldwide Corporation, which has headquarters in New York City . It is owned by Artnet AG , a German publicly-traded company based in Berlin that is listed on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange . The company increased revenues by 25.3% to €17.3 million in 2015 compared with a year before. The company was founded as Centrox Corporation in 1989 by Pierre Sernet,
118-581: A French art collector who developed database software which allowed images of artworks to be associated with market prices. Hans Neuendorf , a German art dealer , began to invest in the company in the 1990s; he became chairman in 1992 and chief executive officer in 1995. That same year, the name was changed to Artnet Worldwide Corporation. It was taken over by Artnet AG in 1998. Neuendorf's son, Jacob Pabst, became chief executive officer in July 2012. Artnet operates an international research and trading platform for
177-409: A disparately large market impact, for instance, Spear's reported in 2015 that British Rail began investing in art for its pension fund beginning in 1974 (prior to privatization ), spending about £40M or approximately 3% of its funds on art, before selling those assets between 1987–1999. British Rail Pension realized an annualized return of 11.3% because of a number of factors particular to
236-799: A former Daily Telegraph journalist and Daily Mail gossip columnist, was appointed editor of Spear's in January 2017. Marsh, who is also the author of the Drabble and Harris adventure novels, took over from Christopher Silvester, who was editor in 2016. Silvester took over from longtime former Spear's editor, Josh Spero , who left to join the Financial Times at the end of 2015. Topics covered in Spear's WMS include 'Asset Management' with articles on investments in bonds versus equities, quantitative easing, impact of Mark Carney 's appointment on
295-452: A guaranteed minimum; similar arrangements followed in 1972 and 1973 for the Ritter and Scull collections. A guaranteed amount is generally close to the lower estimate, with the seller and the auction house sharing any amount exceeding the guaranteed minimum. In autumn 2008 when the market turned sour, Christie's and Sotheby's had to pay out at least million on works for which they guaranteed
354-567: A huge domestic market and ended the duopoly held by London and New York for over 50 years. Christie's and Sotheby's are the leading auction venues. In 2002, LVMH acquired Swiss art advisory firm de Pury & Luxembourg and merged it with Phillips to form Phillips de Pury & Company , with the aim of breaking the duopoly at the top of the market. Fine art auctions are generally held separately for Impressionist and Modern art as well as for Post-war and Contemporary Art . Pablo Picasso 's works remain highly coveted. In 2008 Damien Hirst set
413-411: A microcosm: it lists its collectors in the hundreds, as opposed to the securities market which has millions of participants. One art writer answered the question: "Do you see the art world as a microcosm of other broader, power communities?" with the following observation: "I'm not sure if it's a microcosm or the shape of things to come. Its manic internationalism." Corporate collectors, however, can have
472-413: A minimum price but which failed to sell. In order to reduce their exposure to such losses, boost the market, and reduce volatility, the main auction houses now prefer that third parties take on this financial risk via "third-party guarantees" or "irrevocable bids": using this practice the auction houses sell a work to a third party for a minimum price prior to the auction and this selling price then becomes
531-437: A much lower level than for established artists. This selectivity may also be practiced on the buy side, in terms of gallerists being selective about which buyers to sell to. As another form of gatekeeping , this is done primarily to protect price points from the potential dangers of speculation , or what Velthuis calls "control of the biography" of the artwork. In 2009, a debate occurred between valuation-setting members of
590-631: A notable increase in numbers of lots sold. A French version of the site, artnet.fr, was launched in October 2008. It included a French-language magazine which offers a critical overview of the art market in France. In February 2014, the company launched a website, Artnet News. Benjamin Genocchio , former editorial director of Louise Blouin Media , was appointed editor-in-chief. Artnet's primary service
649-501: A practice designed to give sellers confidence to consign works and to give potential bidders reassurance that there are others willing to buy an item. Auction houses have offered guarantees since the early 1970s to encourage collectors to sell their artworks: The Art Newspaper reported that guarantees were first introduced in 1971 at Sotheby's, when 47 Kandinskys and other works from the Guggenheim Museum were offered with
SECTION 10
#1732797244516708-423: A secret reserve, illegal cartels of bidders would know in advance information that could facilitate their manipulation of the market and corruption of final valuation by selling price at auction. With the art market's weaknesses (especially lack of transparency and conflicts of interests) becoming better known, serious external conversations about market regulation have begun among major market players; for example,
767-544: A series of interviews with high-profile figures including Prince Albert II of Monaco , the former Irish president Mary Robinson , the former Cabinet minister Rory Stewart and Nigel Farage , in which he talked about being hated and his return to politics before the launch of the Brexit party in 2019. In 2017, David Miliband , president of the International Rescue Committee, told Spear's that
826-610: A tax liability, and bulletproof cars . Spear's publishes their Indices in each issue in which they rank and rate the top individuals in each wealth management sector. Indexes include: London's top UHNW wealth managers, Spear's Family Lawyers, Spear's Hotel Index, Spear's Security Index, Education Index, UHNW Wealth Management and Family Office Index, Legal Index, Accountancy Index, Philanthropy Index, Reputation Management Index, Property Index, Artan Collecting Index, International Financial Centres Index (IFCs), Security Index, Private Equity Index, Business Angels Index and Hotels Index. In
885-402: A work is sold on the primary market it enters the secondary market, and the prices for which it sold in the primary market have a direct bearing on the work's value in the secondary market. Supply and demand affect the secondary market more than the primary market because works new to the market, mainly contemporary art, have no market history for predictive analysis and thus valuation of such work
944-572: A world beyond our means and comprehension", in The Spectator . Its subscribers include over 30,000 of Europe's decision-makers and wealthy. William Cash, editor-at-large of Spear's , has twice won Editor of the Year at the PPA Awards (2007 and 2008). Spear's is now published by Progressive Digital Media . The launch in 2006 included publicity from The Independent , The Guardian ,
1003-432: A world record for auction sales by a living artist; however in 2009, Hirst's annual auction sales had shrunk by 93%. "Estimates" often reflect the consignor 's ambitions as much as the auction specialist's considered opinion. They do not reflect commissions. To secure consignments, auction houses concede high estimates to suit the requirements of art owners. Before an auction, interested buyers typically turn for advice to
1062-521: A year later, of four works in the fall auctions at Christie's and Sotheby's in New York, only two of his pieces sold well and one failed to sell entirely. In 2011, Christie's sold Koons' Balloon Flower sculpture for $ 16.9 million. The art market as a whole is affected by its two main parts: the primary art market, where new art comes to the market for the first time, and the secondary market, for existing art that has been sold at least once before. Once
1121-471: Is a market where art is bought and sold for values based not only on a work's perceived cultural value, but on both its past monetary value as well as its predicted future value. The market has been described as one where producers don't make work primarily for sale, where buyers often have no idea of the value of what they buy, and where middlemen routinely claim reimbursement for sales of things they have never seen to buyers they have never dealt with. Moreover,
1180-508: Is more difficult, and more speculative. Gallery, dealer, consultant, and agent promotion as well as collectors acting as alpha consumers (trend-setters) are the forces at work in valuing primary market works. As with blue-chip stocks, works by "blue-chip" or well-known artists are generally valued more highly than works by unknown artists since it is hard to predict how an unknown artist's work will sell, or whether it will sell at all. High barriers to entry for artists create scarcity in
1239-405: Is of lesser artistic diversity negatively impacting the size of the buyer pool. For this reason, gallerists and art dealers consider what types of works are currently in vogue before deciding to represent a new artist and are highly selective in those choices in order to maintain a level of quality that is saleable. All these concerns are in play when gallerists set prices for emerging artists at
SECTION 20
#17327972445161298-584: Is online auctions. The Artnet Fine Art and Design Price Database and the Artnet Decorative Art Price Database contain over 10 million auction sale results dating back to 1985 from over 1700 international auction houses . Market value and long-term price developments of artworks can be researched online. An additional product is the Artnet online Gallery Network, an online platform that connects galleries and collectors from around
1357-411: Is the rankings of private client services primarily focused around lifestyle, alternative investment and luxury. Spear's 500 Travel is a rankings of luxury hotels, resorts, holiday rentals and tour operators in the world, including private aviation and yachts. Spear's Book Awards were awarded in a number of categories between 2009 and 2014. In 2009, the awards jury picked books which went on to win
1416-495: The Financial Times noted that in early 2015, participants at the January World Economic Forum meeting attended a lunch seminar where the speaker warned that the global art market needs to be regulated because of systemic weaknesses which enable inside information trading, tax evasion, and money laundering. The emergence of advanced technologies and data-driven analysis introduces new participants in
1475-466: The Luxist and The Times . Spear's Indices are surveys of key people in the high net worth world. Spear's Salon is Spear's blogging forum which hosts a number of regular contributors. Spear's 500 are rankings of consultants and service providers in several wealth and luxury related industries. They also publish the Spear's 500 Travel. Under Alec Marsh's editorship the magazine has run
1534-401: The supply and demand of the market, in turn driving up prices and raising questions of efficiency in the art market transactions. While a high market entry barrier may result in having a smaller pool of artwork producers in the auction-level portion of the market, and in greater market predictability by virtue of that smaller pool and thus more reliable valuation measures, its axiomatic effect
1593-401: The "reserve" below which the artwork will not be sold. If bidding for specified works stops at the minimum price, which remains undisclosed, the "third party" acquires the lot; if bidding exceeds the reserve, the third party splits any profit from its sale with the consignor and with the auction house, the percentage going to each party varying with the deal. These proportions, never disclosed to
1652-565: The HNW individuals, Risks and Rewards of Rare Earths Investments; 'Art & Collecting' with articles on the art market boom, gallery etiquette and collectors who only want top names; 'The Good Life' with articles on owning your own island, airports becoming more luxurious, Aston Martin , Lamborghini and Porsche competitions; 'Property' with articles on the repossession of a £5.25 million property in One Hyde Park , social investment and
1711-472: The November/December 2019 edition Spear's published its first Luxury Index featuring 100 of the leading individuals in luxury today, from hoteliers to horologists, to tailors, interior designers and jewellers. Spear's publishes this annual rankings in two categories. "Band One" is the rankings of top private client professionals focused on wealth management, law and advisory services. "Band 2"
1770-431: The art market on the proposition that "the art market is less ethical than the stock market". The art market faced criticism for its lack of transparency, its Byzantine valuation methods, and a perceived lack of ethical behavior enabled by structural inadequacies in the market itself. At the end of the debate, the audience determined that those debating in agreement with the proposition won the debate. Of particular note in
1829-460: The art market's participants are far more limited in number than the securities or commodities markets, because artworks are not fungible, and because art valuation relies to a great extent on the advice and enthusiasm of a variety of specialized market analysts, these limitations each in turn dictate the size of the market and increase the risk that some items may be over or undervalued. The art market moves in cycles with activity generally peaking in
Artnet - Misplaced Pages Continue
1888-436: The art market, including works of fine art , decorative arts and design . Its services allow users to research art, contact galleries directly, and attain price transparency in the art market. The platform caters to art dealers as well as buyers. In 2008, Artnet launched the first online auctions platform exclusively for works of art. In 2015, the site saw a 120% increase in new registrations, rising sell-through rates, and
1947-611: The auction house specialist who quotes the estimate and often recommends going beyond in order to secure the item. Auction houses operate contractually on behalf of sellers of goods, charging sellers a fixed commission (fee) amounting to a percentage of the "hammer price" for which a lot is sold. Christie's published its commissions in September 1995, with its fees ranging from 20% on the least expensive lots to 2% on lots sold for over m; Sotheby's followed suit. For Phillips de Pury & Company, final prices include commission of 25% of
2006-504: The auction houses keep secret from bidders a seller's reserve price . In 2011, also in response to criticism on the lack of market transparency and counterarguments that more transparency would ruin the market, The Art Newspaper in association with the Art Dealers Association of America convened an Art Industry Summit panel discussion between major art market decision makers, where panelists discussed whether there
2065-480: The debate was the identification of "chandelier bidding" as a practice perceived as ethically questionable. The debaters described "chandelier bidding" as bids from the chandelier, or bids from an unknown source, meaning both the bidding by the auction houses on behalf of the sellers whose items the houses are auctioning (a conflict of interest ), and bidding by unidentified bidders having no intention of buying but bidding in order to drive prices up, all practiced because
2124-400: The field of art market transparency. In terms of academic research, there is work on the opacity of price formation in finance and economics, while critical accounting work highlights the extreme difficulties in calculating the current value of an artwork using the auction sales prices of comparable artworks. The late 1980s were a boom period for art auction houses. However, in early 1990,
2183-414: The field. Because demand for art objects is high, and security in many parts of the world is low, a thriving trade in illicit antiquities acquired through looting also exists. Although the art community nearly universally condemns looting because it results in destruction of archeological sites , looted art paradoxically remains omnipresent. Warfare is correlated with such looting, as is demonstrated by
2242-433: The financial field where millions of people and firms participate in buying and selling financial interests, or economic goods and consumer good markets where products are usually exchanged using more standardized contracts, art market activity largely follows the demands of a more limited array of private collectors, museums , and large corporate interests as the principal market participants. The art market sees itself as
2301-417: The financial market might be sold for substantially more or substantially less than its last hammer price at auction. In the late 1980s during the stock-market boom, the art market expanded in turn with prices soaring to new heights, and investment firms took a greater interest in the art market and began to study it in-depth. Concurrently, the previously non-transparent art market became more accessible via
2360-408: The financial markets during one season can affect the art market in the following season, and equity markets do significantly impact the art market. Volatility in the financial markets often causes volatility in the art market as happened in the contraction of the art market during the 2008-2009 recession when sales at Sotheby's , Christie's , and Phillips de Pury & Company were less than half
2419-403: The first 20% of the next to million, and 12% of the rest, with estimates not reflecting commissions. Objects sold are also subject to a further fee called the " buyer's premium ", 15% being typical, with the term implying that by virtue of selling an object, the auction house performs a service for the buyer subject to remuneration. Thus, both the seller and the buyer of an object or lot sold by
Artnet - Misplaced Pages Continue
2478-496: The global fine art market turnover was estimated at almost billion. Art auction sales reached a record billion in 2007, fueled by speculative bidding for artists such as Damien Hirst , Jeff Koons , and Richard Prince . The recent rise of the Chinese art market, both in terms of the size of its domestic sales and the international significance of its buyers, has, combined with a rich cultural heritage of art and antiques, produced
2537-478: The housing crisis and leaseholds in London; 'Legal' and 'Taxation" with articles on challenging the notion that companies must minimise the tax they pay, that tax avoidance is not a fiduciary duty, how US laws impact tax evasion by use of Swiss banks and G20 take action against tax-avoiding multinationals. They also deal with topics such as how to manage profits on the sale of hobby thoroughbreds without incurring
2596-436: The increasing availability of indices and online data, although researchers discovered biased price estimates in the auction houses. Art sometimes has transient fashionability that also can affect its value: what sells well for a time may be supplanted in the market by new styles and ideas in short order. For instance, in the spring of 2008 a collector offered over $ 80 million for Jeff Koons ' stainless-steel Rabbit , and yet
2655-404: The internet. As of 2018 it was noted that online sales accounted for about 8% ($ 5.4 billion) of the global art market. In addition to upstanding practices, a black market exists for great art, which is closely tied to art theft and art forgery . No auction houses or dealers admit openly to participating in the black market because of its illegality, but exposés suggest widespread problems in
2714-433: The major auction houses pay a fee. First implemented in 1975 by Christie's, the assessment of a buyer's premium is one of several auction-house practices to which art dealers object. Beginning in 2014, Christie's charged 2 percent of the hammer price of a work that meets or exceeds its high estimate. The fee does not apply to online only sales. An auction house may offer a guaranteed selling price, or "guaranteed minimum",
2773-519: The market at the time. British Rail's efforts realized profits, particularly due to the Impressionist portfolio, but the collection was liquidated because it came to be seen as an illegitimate investment area, particularly as alternative investments became available. Also, because original artworks are not fungible , they have valuation challenges not similarly affecting securities, with dynamics of what Karpik calls singularities. Thus, because
2832-642: The market collapsed. The US overtook the EU as the world's largest art market with a global share of 47 per cent by 2001. Ranking second, the UK's world market share hovers around 25 per cent. In continental Europe, France was the market leader while in Asia, Hong Kong continues its dominance. France's share of the art market has been progressively eroded since the 1950s, when it was the dominant location and sales at Drouot surpassed those of Sotheby's and Christie's combined. In 2004,
2891-399: The market is not transparent; private sales data is not systematically available, and private sales represent about half of market transactions. In 2018, Robert Norton, a CEO and co-founder of Verisart, noted that "Art is the second-largest unregulated market after illicit drugs and it's significantly overshadowed by fraudulent activity." Unlike the volumes in some international markets in
2950-651: The pilot edition of Spear's as a supplement. At that time there was competition for advertisements from "fashion houses and luxury brands" upon which the magazine depended. Cash launched Spear's Wealth Management Survey in April 2006 with a targeted audience of "the 30,000 wealthiest, most successful and influential people in the UK: from Rich Listers to royalty; hedge fund managers to serial entrepreneurs; oligarchs to internet moguls; cabinet ministers to Sir Alex Ferguson ." In February 2003, Cash married Ilaria Bulgari, whose father
3009-475: The previous year: November 2008, $ 803.3 million compared to November 2007, $ 1.75 billion; and between 2000 and 2003 when the annual volume of art works sold at auction dropped 36%. In other instances, the art market can fare reasonably well despite volatility in the stock market such as happened from January 1997 through May 2004 when the average quarterly fluctuation in the Artprice Global Index
SECTION 50
#17327972445163068-508: The public, are negotiated before an auction and specified in the contract signed by the auction house and the third party. In May 1999, Teo Spiller sold a web art project Megatronix to Ljubljana Municipal Museum, which was announced by the New York Times as the first sale of an Internet art net.art . In 2003, Sotheby's abandoned its partnership with eBay after it lost millions through its various attempts to sell fine art over
3127-626: The recent archaeological looting in Iraq . Spear%27s Wealth Management Survey Spear's (formerly known as Spear's WMS or Spear's Wealth Management Survey ), founded in 2006 by William Cash , is a bimonthly British magazine for high-net-worth individuals and those in the financial service industries . It has been called "the Bible of the banking fraternity" by GQ and "a European rival to Forbes " by The Evening Standard . Nick Cohen called it "The best portrait I have seen of
3186-426: The spring and autumn when the major auction houses traditionally schedule auctions, and results in the market being seasonal rather than ongoing. While private sales take place all year, those sales are often not publicized as auctions are and thus do not affect the market until they become known. Art valuations made for an autumn auction may be unrealistic for the following spring auction season because fortunes in
3245-503: The world's rich needed to give more money to charity and good causes in an exclusive interview widely followed elsewhere. In June 2020, Alec Marsh stepped down as editor, becoming editor-at-large, and was succeeded by his deputy editor Edwin Smith. William Cash, a magazine writer who has also been a foreign correspondent for The Times and The Daily Telegraph , was Annabel's Magazine's contract publisher in 2005, when they published
3304-538: The world. With over 35,000 artists and 2,200 international galleries worldwide, it is the largest network of its kind, and generates inquiries from both collectors and first-time buyers. Subscribing galleries can list works for sale on the site. In 2004, Artnet and the international auction house Sotheby's began a collaboration. A collaboration with Art Basel/Art Basel Miami Beach was also launched in 2007. Art market The art market operates in an economic model that considers more than supply and demand ; it
3363-647: Was a need for more transparency. The panelists argued over whether auction houses have built-in conflicts of interest by representing sellers with secret reserves, while at the same time representing to buyers initial valuations on those works at auction time. The debate also included the issue of first and third-party guaranteed bids, and whether sellers' reserve prices should be disclosed so that participants no longer bid on an object they have no chance of buying. In response to criticisms regarding chandelier bidding and unidentified third-party guaranteed bids, Christie's International chairman Edward Dolman countered that, without
3422-542: Was the vice-chairman of Bulgari , the third largest jewellery company in the world. They divorced in 2007 and Cash sold the magazine for about £1.2 million to Luxury Publishing. Then in 2009 he bought a 67% holding back, with Nectar Capital holding the other shares. Cash is the owner of Upton Cressett Hall , a 16th-century Tudor manor in Shropshire. In 2015 Spear's became available at 250 outlets in London, as well as on subscription. Freelance writer Alec Marsh,
3481-536: Was two to three times smaller than the same statistic for the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the S&;P 500 . As art market participants' fortunes wax and wane in the financial markets, buying power evolves and affects participants' ability to afford highly valued works, resulting in new buyers and sellers entering, leaving, or re-entering the market, and an artwork sold to offset losses in
#515484