Misplaced Pages

#609390

68-526: The fund's name stems from its original mandate in 1967: "the fund's mission was to take a contrarian view , investing in out-of-favor stocks or sectors." This strategy has changed since the 1990s to become a fund focused on growth investing in large companies , and the Contrafund's strong history of growth has led to its being "a stalwart of many 401(k) plans". In 2015, Danoff's 25-year solo management became an issue of concern as Fidelity had not named

136-493: A custodian or investment management firm, often lend out these securities to gain extra income, a process known as securities lending . The lender receives a fee for this service. Similarly, retail investors can sometimes make an extra fee when their broker wants to borrow their securities. This is only possible when the investor has full title of the security, so it cannot be used as collateral for margin buying . Time delayed short interest data (for legally shorted shares)

204-428: A large cap growth fund . Contrarians are attempting to exploit some of the principles of behavioral finance , and there is significant overlap between these fields. For example, studies in behavioral finance have demonstrated that investors as a group tend to overweight recent trends when predicting the future; a poorly performing stock will remain bad, and a strong performer will remain strong. This lends credence to

272-431: A buyer and seller. Each trade results in a "long" (buyer's position) and a "short" (seller's position). When trading futures contracts , being 'short' means having the legal obligation to deliver something at the expiration of the contract, although the holder of the short position may alternately buy back the contract prior to expiration instead of making delivery. Short futures transactions are often used by producers of

340-426: A co-manager for Contrafund. Should Danoff become incapacitated without a co-manager or succession plan, Contrafund might face major redemptions from shareholders and lose its position in many large retirement plans which typically require at least three years of manager tenure. This finance-related article is a stub . You can help Misplaced Pages by expanding it . Contrarian investing Contrarian investing

408-455: A commodity to fix the future price of goods they have not yet produced. Shorting a futures contract is sometimes also used by those holding the underlying asset (i.e. those with a long position) as a temporary hedge against price declines. Shorting futures may also be used for speculative trades, in which case the investor is looking to profit from any decline in the price of the futures contract prior to expiration. An investor can also purchase

476-414: A compilation eight days later. Some market data providers (like Data Explorers and SunGard Financial Systems ) believe that stock lending data provides a good proxy for short interest levels (excluding any naked short interest). SunGard provides daily data on short interest by tracking the proxy variables based on borrowing and lending data it collects. Days to Cover (DTC) is the relationship between

544-415: A decrease in the price of a security, a short seller can borrow the security and sell it, expecting that it will be cheaper to repurchase in the future. When the seller decides that the time is right (or when the lender recalls the securities), the seller buys the same number of equivalent securities and returns them to the lender. The act of buying back the securities that were sold short is called covering

612-399: A future date at a price stated in the contract. If the price of the asset falls below the contract price, the short seller can buy it at the lower market value and immediately sell it at the higher price specified in the contract. A short position can also be achieved through certain types of swap , such as a contract for difference . This is an agreements between two parties to pay each other

680-477: A locate. More stringent rules were put in place in September 2008, ostensibly to prevent the practice from exacerbating market declines. These rules were made permanent in 2009. When a broker facilitates the delivery of a client's short sale, the client is charged a fee for this service, usually a standard commission similar to that of purchasing a similar security. If the short position begins to move against

748-450: A loss. The short seller usually must pay a handling fee to borrow the asset (charged at a particular rate over time, similar to an interest payment ) and reimburse the lender for any cash return (such as a dividend ) that was paid on the asset while borrowed. A short position can also be created through a futures contract , forward contract , or option contract , by which the short seller assumes an obligation or right to sell an asset at

SECTION 10

#1732793465610

816-421: A permanent bear market view, while the majority of investors bet on the market going up. However, a contrarian does not necessarily have a negative view of the overall stock market, nor do they have to believe that it is always overvalued, or that the conventional wisdom is always wrong. Rather, a contrarian seeks opportunities to buy or sell specific investments when the majority of investors appear to be doing

884-610: A prevailing optimistic or confident investor outlook for the future, while a high number indicates a pessimistic outlook. By comparing the VIX to the major stock-indexes over longer periods of time, it is evident that peaks in this index generally present good buying opportunities. Another example of a simple contrarian strategy is Dogs of the Dow . When purchasing the stocks in the Dow Jones Industrial Average that have

952-448: A rise in the price of an instrument that appears undervalued. Alternatively, traders or fund managers may use offsetting short positions to hedge certain risks that exist in a long position or a portfolio. Research indicates that banning short selling is ineffective and has negative effects on markets. Nevertheless, short selling is subject to criticism and periodically faces hostility from society and policymakers. To profit from

1020-425: A short position. When a security's ex-dividend date passes, the dividend is deducted from the shortholder's account and paid to the person from whom the stock is borrowed. For some brokers, the short seller may not earn interest on the proceeds of the short sale or use it to reduce outstanding margin debt. These brokers may not pass this benefit on to the retail client unless the client is very large. The interest

1088-464: A start-up company could backfire since it could be taken over at a price higher than the price at which speculators shorted; short-sellers were forced to cover their positions at acquisition prices, while in many cases the firm often overpaid for the start-up. During the 2008 financial crisis , critics argued that investors taking large short positions in struggling financial firms like Lehman Brothers , HBOS and Morgan Stanley created instability in

1156-503: A strategy similar to, but developed independently of, the value investing paradigm of Benjamin Graham and Charles Dodd . Commonly used contrarian indicators for investor sentiment are Volatility Indexes (informally also referred to as "Fear indexes"), like VIX , which by tracking the prices of financial options , gives a numeric measure of how pessimistic or optimistic market actors at large are. A low number in this index indicates

1224-417: A way that the investor will profit if the market value of the asset falls. This is the opposite of the more common long position , where the investor will profit if the market value of the asset rises. An investor that sells an asset short is, as to that asset, a short seller . There are a number of ways of achieving a short position. The most basic is physical selling short or short-selling , by which

1292-483: Is a such thing as a "contrarian", seeing it as essentially synonymous with value investing. One possible distinction is that a value stock, in finance theory, can be identified by financial metrics such as the book value or P/E ratio . A contrarian investor may look at those metrics, but is also interested in measures of "sentiment" regarding the stock among other investors, such as sell-side analyst coverage and earnings forecasts, trading volume, and media commentary about

1360-511: Is an investment strategy that is characterized by purchasing and selling in contrast to the prevailing sentiment of the time. A contrarian believes that certain crowd behavior among investors can lead to exploitable mispricings in securities markets. For example, widespread pessimism about a stock can drive a price so low that it overstates the company's risks, and understates its prospects for returning to profitability. Identifying and purchasing such distressed stocks, and selling them after

1428-575: Is available in a number of countries, including the US, the UK, Hong Kong, and Spain. The number of stocks being shorted on a global basis has increased in recent years for various structural reasons (e.g., the growth of 130/30 type strategies, short or bear ETFs). The data is typically delayed; for example, the NASDAQ requires its broker-dealer member firms to report data on the 15th of each month, and then publishes

SECTION 20

#1732793465610

1496-639: Is detected by the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (in the US) as a " failure to deliver " or simply "fail." While many fails are settled in a short time, some have been allowed to linger in the system. In the US, arranging to borrow a security before a short sale is called a locate . In 2005, to prevent widespread failure to deliver securities, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) put in place Regulation SHO , intended to prevent speculators from selling some stocks short before doing

1564-453: Is more likely to exist when a stock has fallen a great deal, and that type of drop is usually accompanied by negative news and general pessimism. Along with this, although more dangerous, is shorting overvalued stocks. This requires 'deep pockets' in that an overvalued security may continue to rise, due to over-optimism, for quite some time. Eventually, the short-seller believes, the stock will 'crash and burn'. Economist John Maynard Keynes

1632-419: Is often split with the lender of the security. Where shares have been shorted and the company that issues the shares distributes a dividend, the question arises as to who receives the dividend. The new buyer of the shares, who is the holder of record and holds the shares outright, receives the dividend from the company. However, the lender, who may hold its shares in a margin account with a prime broker and

1700-402: Is sold, the seller is contractually obliged to deliver it to the buyer. If a seller sells a security short without owning it first, the seller must borrow the security from a third party to fulfill its obligation. Otherwise, the seller fails to deliver, the transaction does not settle , and the seller may be subject to a claim from its counterparty . Certain large holders of securities, such as

1768-426: Is unlikely to be aware that these particular shares are being lent out for shorting, also expects to receive a dividend. The short seller therefore pays the lender an amount equal to the dividend to compensate—though technically, as this payment does not come from the company, it is not a dividend. The short seller is therefore said to be short the dividend . A similar issue comes up with the voting rights attached to

1836-486: The Depression . A few years later, in 1949, Alfred Winslow Jones founded a fund (that was unregulated) that bought stocks while selling other stocks short, hence hedging some of the market risk , and the hedge fund was born. Negative news, such as litigation against a company, may also entice professional traders to sell the stock short in hope of the stock price going down. During the dot-com bubble , shorting

1904-576: The NYSE or the NASDAQ typically report the "short interest" of a stock, which gives the number of shares that have been legally sold short as a percent of the total float . Alternatively, these can also be expressed as the short interest ratio , which is the number of shares legally sold short as a multiple of the average daily volume. These can be useful tools to spot trends in stock price movements but for them to be reliable, investors must also ascertain

1972-599: The United Kingdom , Germany , France , Italy and other European countries in 2008 to minimal effect. Australia moved to ban naked short selling entirely in September 2008. Germany placed a ban on naked short selling of certain euro zone securities in 2010. Spain, Portugal and Italy introduced short selling bans in 2011 and again in 2012. During the COVID-19 pandemic , shorting was severely restricted or temporarily banned, with European market watchdogs tightening

2040-553: The U.S., the seller must arrange for a broker-dealer to confirm that it can deliver the shorted securities. This is referred to as a locate . Brokers have a variety of means to borrow stocks to facilitate locates and make good on delivery of the shorted security. The vast majority of stocks borrowed by U.S. brokers come from loans made by the leading custody banks and fund management companies (see list below). Institutions often lend out their shares to earn extra money on their investments. These institutional loans are usually arranged by

2108-474: The US.) This means that the buyer of such a short is buying the short-seller's promise to deliver a share, rather than buying the share itself. The short-seller's promise is known as a hypothecated share. When the holder of the underlying stock receives a dividend, the holder of the hypothecated share would receive an equal dividend from the short seller. Naked shorting has been made illegal except where allowed under limited circumstances by market makers . It

Fidelity Contrafund - Misplaced Pages Continue

2176-599: The United States in 1929 and in 1940. Political fallout from the 1929 crash led Congress to enact a law banning short sellers from selling shares during a downtick; this was known as the uptick rule and was in effect until 3 July 2007, when it was removed by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC Release No. 34-55970). President Herbert Hoover condemned short sellers and even J. Edgar Hoover said he would investigate short sellers for their role in prolonging

2244-582: The accounts of their own customers. Typical margin account agreements give brokerage firms the right to borrow customer shares without notifying the customer. In general, brokerage accounts are only allowed to lend shares from accounts for which customers have debit balances , meaning they have borrowed from the account. SEC Rule 15c3-3 imposes such severe restrictions on the lending of shares from cash accounts or excess margin (fully paid for) shares from margin accounts that most brokerage firms do not bother except in rare circumstances. (These restrictions include that

2312-533: The asset in question in order to hedge their position. The practice of short selling was likely invented in 1609 by Dutch businessman Isaac Le Maire , a sizeable shareholder of the Dutch East India Company ( Vereenigde Oostindische Compagnie or VOC in Dutch). Short selling can exert downward pressure on the underlying stock, driving down the price of shares of that security. This, combined with

2380-609: The bicycle does not change and the same bicycle must be returned, not merely one that is the same model. Because the price of a share is theoretically unlimited, the potential losses of a short-seller are also theoretically unlimited. Shares in ACME Inc. currently trade at $ 10 per share . Shares in ACME Inc. currently trade at $ 10 per share. "Shorting" or "going short" (and sometimes also "short selling") also refer more broadly to any transaction used by an investor to profit from

2448-430: The broker must have the express permission of the customer and provide collateral or a letter of credit.) Most brokers allow retail customers to borrow shares to short a stock only if one of their own customers has purchased the stock on margin . Brokers go through the "locate" process outside their own firm to obtain borrowed shares from other brokers only for their large institutional customers. Stock exchanges such as

2516-425: The company and its business prospects. In the example of a stock that has dropped because of excessive pessimism, one can see similarities to the "margin of safety" that value investor Benjamin Graham sought when purchasing stocks—essentially, being able to buy shares at a discount to their intrinsic value with an additional margin to adjust for possible errors in one's calculations. Arguably, that margin of safety

2584-497: The company recovers, can lead to above-average gains. Conversely, widespread optimism can result in unjustifiably high valuations that will eventually lead to drops, when those high expectations do not pan out. Avoiding (or short-selling) investments in over-hyped investments reduces the risk of such drops. These general principles can apply whether the investment in question is an individual stock, an industry sector, or an entire market or any other asset class . Some contrarians have

2652-558: The contrarian's belief that investments may drop "too low" during periods of negative news, due to incorrect assumptions by other investors, regarding the long-term prospects for the company. Furthermore, Foye and Mramor (2016) find that country-specific factors have a strong influence on measures of value (such as the book-to-market ratio). This leads them to conclude that the reasons why value stocks outperform are both country-specific and behavioral. Short (finance) In finance , being short in an asset means investing in such

2720-421: The cost to borrow (short) Krispy Kreme stock reached an annualized 55%, indicating that a short seller would need to pay the lender more than half the price of the stock over the course of the year, essentially as interest for borrowing a stock in limited supply. This has important implications for derivatives pricing and strategy, for the borrow cost itself can become a significant convenience yield for holding

2788-456: The criteria, the "Dogs" investor is systematically buying the least-loved of the Dow 30, and selling them when they become loved again eventually. When the Dot com bubble started to deflate, an investor would have profited by avoiding the technology stocks that were the subject of most investors' attention. Asset classes such as value stocks and real estate investment trusts were largely ignored by

Fidelity Contrafund - Misplaced Pages Continue

2856-419: The custodian who holds the securities for the institution. In an institutional stock loan, the borrower puts up cash collateral, typically 102% of the value of the stock. The cash collateral is then invested by the lender, who often rebates part of the interest to the borrower. The interest that is kept by the lender is the compensation to the lender for the stock loan. Brokerage firms can also borrow stocks from

2924-403: The decline in price of a borrowed asset or financial instrument. Derivatives contracts that can be used in this way include futures , options , and swaps . These contracts are typically cash-settled, meaning that no buying or selling of the asset in question is actually involved in the contract, although typically one side of the contract will be a broker that will effect a back-to-back sale of

2992-552: The difference if the price of an asset rises or falls, under which the party that will benefit if the price falls will have a short position. Because a short seller can incur a liability to the lender if the price rises, and because a short sale is normally done through a stockbroker , a short seller is typically required to post margin to its broker as collateral to ensure that any such liabilities can be met, and to post additional margin if losses begin to accrue. For analogous reasons, short positions in derivatives also usually involve

3060-427: The financial press at the time, despite their historically low valuations, and many mutual funds in those categories lost assets. These investments experienced strong gains amidst the large drops in the overall US stock market when the bubble unwound. The Fidelity Contrafund was founded in 1967 "to take a contrarian view, investing in out-of-favor stocks or sectors", but over time has abandoned this strategy to become

3128-406: The highest relative dividend yield , an investor is often buying many of the "distressed" companies among those 30 stocks. These "Dogs" have high yields not because dividends were raised, but rather because their share prices fell. The company is experiencing difficulties, or simply is at a low point in their business cycle . By repeatedly buying such stocks, and selling them when they no longer meet

3196-518: The holder of the short position (i.e., the price of the security begins to rise), money is removed from the holder's cash balance and moved to their margin balance . If short shares continue to rise in price, and the holder does not have sufficient funds in the cash account to cover the position, the holder begins to borrow on margin for this purpose, thereby accruing margin interest charges. These are computed and charged just as for any other margin debit. Therefore, only margin accounts can be used to open

3264-401: The market. In "The Art of Contrary Thinking" (1954) by Humphrey B. Neill; considered influential by some in contrarian thinking, he notes it is easy to find something to go contrary to, but difficult to discover when everybody believes it. He concludes "when everybody thinks alike, everybody is likely to be wrong." Some well-known value investors such as John Neff have questioned whether there

3332-401: The number of shares brought into existence by naked shorters. Speculators are cautioned to remember that for every share that has been shorted (owned by a new owner), a 'shadow owner' exists (i.e., the original owner) who also is part of the universe of owners of that stock, i.e., despite having no voting rights, he has not relinquished his interest and some rights in that stock. When a security

3400-504: The number of shares in a given equity that has been legally short-sold and the number of days of typical trading that it would require to 'cover' all legal short positions outstanding. For example, if there are ten million shares of XYZ Inc. that are currently legally short-sold and the average daily volume of XYZ shares traded each day is one million, it would require ten days of average trading for all legal short positions to be covered (10 million / 1 million). Short Interest relates

3468-577: The number of shares in a given equity that have been legally shorted divided by the total shares outstanding for the company, usually expressed as a percent. For example, if there are ten million shares of XYZ Inc. that are currently legally short-sold, and the total number of shares issued by the company is one hundred million, the Short Interest is 10% (10 million / 100 million). If, however, shares are being created through naked short selling, "fails" data must be accessed to assess accurately

SECTION 50

#1732793465610

3536-404: The number of votes cast is greater than the number of shares issued by the company. Transactions in financial derivatives such as options and futures have the same name but have different overlaps, one notable overlap is having an equal "negative" amount in the position. However, the practice of a short position in derivatives is completely different. Derivatives are contracts between two parties,

3604-438: The opposite, to the point where that investment has become mispriced. While more "buy" candidates are likely to be identified during market declines (and vice versa), these opportunities can occur during periods when the overall market is generally rising or falling. Contrarian investing is related to value investing in that the contrarian is also looking for mispriced investments and buying those that appear to be undervalued by

3672-400: The other assets being sold short) are fungible . An investor therefore "borrows" securities in the same sense as one borrows a $ 10 bill, where the legal ownership of the money is transferred to the borrower and it can be freely disposed of, and different bank notes or coins can be returned to the lender. This can be contrasted with the sense in which one borrows a bicycle, where the ownership of

3740-488: The posting of margin with the counterparty . Any failure to post margin promptly would prompt the broker or counterparty to close the position. Short selling is a common practice in public securities, futures, and currency markets that are fungible and reasonably liquid . A short sale may have a variety of objectives. Speculators may sell short hoping to realize a profit on an instrument that appears overvalued, just as long investors or speculators hope to profit from

3808-428: The rules on short selling "in an effort to stem the historic losses arising from the coronavirus pandemic". Worldwide, economic regulators seem inclined to restrict short selling to decrease potential downward price cascades. Investors continue to argue this only contributes to market inefficiency. A short seller typically borrows through a broker , who is usually holding the securities for another investor who owns

3876-511: The securities; the broker himself seldom purchases the securities to lend to the short seller. The lender does not lose the right to sell the securities while they have been lent, as the broker usually holds a large pool of such securities for a number of investors which, as such securities are fungible, can instead be transferred to any buyer. In most market conditions there is a ready supply of securities to be borrowed, held by pension funds, mutual funds and other investors. To sell stocks short in

3944-523: The seemingly complex and hard-to-follow tactics of the practice, has made short selling a historical target for criticism. At various times in history, governments have restricted or banned short selling. The London banking house of Neal, James, Fordyce and Down collapsed in June 1772, precipitating a major crisis that included the collapse of almost every private bank in Scotland, and a liquidity crisis in

4012-399: The short , covering the position or simply covering . A short position can be covered at any time before the securities are due to be returned. Once the position is covered, the short seller is not affected by subsequent rises or falls in the price of the securities, for it already holds the securities that it will return to the lender. The process relies on the fact that the securities (or

4080-400: The short seller borrows an asset (often a security such as a share of stock or a bond ) and quickly selling it. The short seller must later buy the same amount of the asset to return it to the lender. If the market value of the asset has fallen in the meantime, the short seller will have made a profit equal to the difference. Conversely, if the price has risen then the short seller will bear

4148-399: The shorted shares. Unlike a dividend, voting rights cannot legally be synthesized and so the buyer of the shorted share, as the holder of record, controls the voting rights. The owner of a margin account from which the shares were lent agreed in advance to relinquish voting rights to shares during the period of any short sale. As noted earlier, victims of naked shorting sometimes report that

SECTION 60

#1732793465610

4216-409: The stock (similar to additional dividend ) – for instance, put–call parity relationships are broken and the early exercise feature of American call options on non-dividend paying stocks can become rational to exercise early , which otherwise would not be economical. A naked short sale occurs when a security is sold short without borrowing the security within a set time (for example, three days in

4284-407: The stock market and placed additional downward pressure on prices. In response, a number of countries introduced restrictive regulations on short-selling in 2008 and 2009. Naked short selling is the practice of short-selling a tradable asset without first borrowing the security or ensuring that the security can be borrowed – it was this practice that was commonly restricted. Investors argued that it

4352-651: The true level of short interest. Borrow cost is the fee paid to a securities lender for borrowing the stock or other security. The cost of borrowing the stock is usually negligible compared to fees paid and interest accrued on the margin account – in 2002, 91% of stocks could be shorted for less than a 1% fee per annum, generally lower than interest rates earned on the margin account. However, certain stocks become "hard to borrow" as stockholders willing to lend their stock become more difficult to locate. The cost of borrowing these stocks can become significant – in February 2001,

4420-487: The two major banking centres of the world, London and Amsterdam. The bank had been speculating by shorting East India Company stock on a massive scale, and apparently using customer deposits to cover losses. In another well-referenced example, George Soros became notorious for "breaking the Bank of England " on Black Wednesday of 1992, when he sold short more than $ 10 billion worth of pounds sterling . The term short

4488-421: Was an early contrarian investor when he managed the endowment for King's College, Cambridge from the 1920s to '40s. While most university endowments of the time invested almost exclusively in land and fixed income assets, Keynes was perhaps the first institutional investor to invest heavily in common stocks and international stocks. On average, Keynes's investments out-performed the U.K. market by more than 6% with

4556-503: Was in use from at least the mid-nineteenth century. It is commonly understood that the word "short" (i.e. 'lacking') is used because the short seller is in a deficit position with his brokerage house . Jacob Little , known as The Great Bear of Wall Street , began shorting stocks in the United States in 1822. Short sellers were blamed for the Wall Street Crash of 1929 . Regulations governing short selling were implemented in

4624-532: Was the weakness of financial institutions, not short-selling, that drove stocks to fall. In September 2008, the Securities Exchange Commission in the United States abruptly banned short sales, primarily in financial stocks, to protect companies under siege in the stock market. That ban expired several weeks later as regulators determined the ban was not stabilizing the price of stocks. Temporary short-selling bans were also introduced in

#609390