Misplaced Pages

#118881

100-750: According to its website, the Fiqh Council traces its origins back to the Religious Affairs Committee of the then Muslim Student Association of the United States and Canada established in the 1960s. In 1980, after the founding of the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA), the Religious Affairs Committee evolved into the Fiqh Committee of the Islamic Society of North America, and was eventually transformed into

200-477: A sophomore with second-year standing based on his academic achievements in high school. Roberts first roomed in Straus Hall before moving to Leverett House . Every summer, he returned home to work at the steel plant his father managed. Although he initially felt obscured among other students, Roberts distinguished himself with professors, meriting multiple distinctions for his scholarly writing. He gained

300-578: A "vacuum" in the other source of Islamic law, qada` (legal rulings by state appointed Islamic judges) after the fall of the last caliphate the Ottoman Empire. While the practice in Islam dates back to the time of Muhammad, according to at least one source (Muhammad El-Gamal), it is "modeled after the Roman system of responsa ," and gives the questioner "decisive primary-mover advantage in choosing

400-406: A 12-year-old girl who ate in violation of a zero tolerance policy against eating in a metro station. His opinions generally reflected a conservative judicial philosophy, including in areas of civil rights and executive power. The brevity of his tenure and his cautiousness in deciding cases left little for potential opponents to scrutinize while he made rulings as a circuit judge. By the time of

500-530: A central Pillar of Ijtihad . On the other hand; Zahirites , Ahmad ibn Hanbal , Al-Bukhari , early Hanbalites , etc. rejected Qiyas amongst the Sunnis. Similarly, the Shi’a jurists almost unanimously reject both pure reason and analogical reason; viewing both these methods as subjective. The Qur'an gives clear instructions on many issues, such as how to perform the ritual purification ( wudu ) before

600-702: A chronological path of: The commands and prohibitions chosen by God were revealed through the agency of the Prophet in both the Quran and the Sunnah (words, deeds, and examples of the Prophet passed down as hadith ). The first Muslims (the Sahabah or Companions) heard and obeyed, and passed this essence of Islam to succeeding generations ( Tabi'un and Tabi' al-Tabi'in or successors/followers and successors of successors), as Muslims and Islam spread from West Arabia to

700-478: A comprehensive jurisprudential philosophy and did "not think beginning with an all-encompassing approach to constitutional interpretation is the best way to faithfully construe the document." Roberts compared judges to baseball umpires: "[I]t's my job to call balls and strikes, and not to pitch or bat." Among the issues he discussed during the hearings were: In Senate hearings, Roberts said: Starting with McCulloch v. Maryland , Chief Justice John Marshall gave

800-698: A link between the king's reforms and the legal system of the Kingdom of Sicily . The island had previously been ruled by various Islamic dynasties. Several other fundamental common law institutions may have been adapted from similar legal institutions in Islamic law and jurisprudence, and introduced to England by the Normans after the Norman conquest of England and the Emirate of Sicily, and by Crusaders during

900-491: A much more flexible character, and some modern Muslim scholars believe that it should be renewed, and that the classical jurists should lose special status. This would require formulating a new fiqh suitable for the modern world, e.g. as proposed by advocates of the Islamization of knowledge , which would deal with the modern context. This modernization is opposed by most conservative ulema . Traditional scholars hold that

1000-583: A platform for Supreme Court nomination. On May 9, 2001, Bush nominated Roberts to a seat on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit to replace Judge James L. Buckley , who had retired. Unlike in 1992 when his first nomination stalled in the Democratic-majority Senate, Roberts's nomination came when Republicans had secured a one-vote Senate majority. But it soon lost that majority when Senator Jim Jeffords left

1100-622: A problem is if we pass a federal law, whether it is the Violence Against Women Act or anything else. The fact of the matter is conditions are different in different states, and state laws can be more—relevant is I think exactly the right term, more attuned to the different situations in New York, as opposed to Minnesota, and that is what the federal system is based on. At a Senate hearing, Roberts said: The Supreme Court has, throughout its history, on many occasions described

SECTION 10

#1732776281119

1200-504: A professor but also contemplated a legal career. One of Roberts's first papers, "Marxism and Bolshevism: Theory and Practice," won Harvard's William Scott Ferguson Prize for the most outstanding essay by a sophomore history major. An early interest in oral advocacy led him to study Daniel Webster , a prominent advocate before the Supreme Court. His senior year paper, "The Utopian Conservative: A Study of Continuity and Change in

1300-415: A reputation as a serious student who valued formalism. Every Sunday, he attended Catholic mass at St. Paul Church . Roberts focused on modern European history and maintained an interest in politics. As an undergraduate, he excelled academically. In his first year, he won the university's Edwards Whitaker Scholarship for outstanding scholastic achievement. He intended to pursue a Ph.D. in history to be

1400-650: A similar case. In the years proceeding Muhammad, the community in Madina continued to use the same rules. People were familiar with the practice of Muhammad and therefore continued to use the same rules. The scholars appearing in the diagram below were taught by Muhammad's companions , many of whom settled in Madina. Muwatta by Malik ibn Anas was written as a consensus of the opinion, of these scholars. Muwatta by Malik ibn Anas quotes 13 hadiths from Imam Jafar al-Sadiq . Aisha also taught her nephew Urwah ibn Zubayr . He then taught his son Hisham ibn Urwah , who

1500-529: A staff lawyer; I didn't have a position," Roberts said. As a lawyer in the George H. W. Bush administration , Roberts signed a legal brief urging the court to overturn Roe v. Wade . In private meetings with senators before his confirmation, Roberts testified that Roe was settled law, but added that it was subject to the legal principle of stare decisis , meaning that while the Court must give some weight to

1600-436: A very broad and expansive reading to the powers of the federal government and explained generally that if the ends be legitimate, then any means chosen to achieve them are within the power of the federal government, and cases interpreting that, throughout the years, have come down. Certainly, by the time Lopez was decided, many of us had learned in law school that it was just sort of a formality to say that interstate commerce

1700-477: A very important factor. It wasn't present in Lopez at all. I think the members of Congress had heard the same thing I had heard in law school, that this is unimportant—and they hadn't gone through the process of establishing a record in that case. Roberts said the following about federalism in a 1999 radio interview: We have gotten to the point these days where we think the only way we can show we're serious about

1800-474: A vote of 16 to 3, and the Senate confirmed him unanimously by voice vote on May 8, 2003. On June 2, he received his judicial commission. Even when Roberts had not yet fully assumed his role as a circuit judge, White House Counsel officers listed him on their shortlist of Supreme Court candidates. Roberts authored 49 opinions during his two-year service on the D.C. Circuit, many of which concerned decisions by

1900-501: Is an American jurist who has served since 2005 as the 17th chief justice of the United States . He has been described as having a moderate conservative judicial philosophy , though he is primarily an institutionalist. Regarded as a swing vote in some cases, Roberts has presided over an ideological shift toward conservative jurisprudence on the high court, in which he has authored key opinions. Born in Buffalo, New York , Roberts

2000-575: Is an exciting time to be at the Justice Department, when so much that has been taken for granted for so long is being seriously reconsidered." Among those he worked with were William Bradford Reynolds in the Civil Rights Division , former classmate Richard Lazarus , J. Harvie Wilkinson III , Theodore Olson , and fellow special assistant Carolyn Kuhl . In 1982, Reagan advisor Fred Fielding recruited Roberts to work at

2100-415: Is certainly the central dilemma of having an unelected, as you describe it correctly, undemocratic judiciary in a democratic republic. On the subject of stare decisis , referring to Brown v. Board of Education , the decision overturning school segregation , Roberts said: "the Court in that case, of course, overruled a prior decision. I don't think that constitutes judicial activism because obviously if

SECTION 20

#1732776281119

2200-625: Is considered fallible and changeable. Fiqh deals with the observance of rituals, morals and social legislation in Islam as well as economic and political system. In the modern era, there are four prominent schools ( madh'hab ) of fiqh within Sunni practice, plus two (or three) within Shi'a practice. A person trained in fiqh is known as a faqīh ( pl. : fuqaha ). Figuratively, fiqh means knowledge about Islamic legal rulings from their sources. Deriving religious rulings from their sources requires

2300-473: Is consistent amongst the jurists. In Modern Standard Arabic , fiqh has also come to mean Islamic jurisprudence. It is not thus possible to speak of Chief Justice John Roberts as an expert in the common law fiqh of the United States , or of Egyptian legal scholar Abd El-Razzak El-Sanhuri as an expert in the civil law fiqh of Egypt. According to Sunni Islamic history, Sunni law followed

2400-683: Is not regarded as sacred and the schools of thought have differing views on its details, without viewing other conclusions as sacrilegious . This division of interpretation in more detailed issues has resulted in different schools of thought ( madh'hab ). This wider concept of Islamic jurisprudence is the source of a range of laws in different topics that guide Muslims in everyday life. Islamic jurisprudence ( fiqh ) covers two main areas: These types of rules can also fall into two groups: Rules in relation to actions (' amaliyya — عملية) or " decision types " comprise: Rules in relation to circumstances ( wadia' ) comprise: The modus operandi of

2500-416: The mujtahid (an individual who exercises ijtihad ) to have a deep understanding in the different discussions of jurisprudence. The studies of fiqh , are traditionally divided into Uṣūl al-fiqh ( principles of Islamic jurisprudence , lit. the roots of fiqh, alternatively transliterated as Usool al-fiqh ), the methods of legal interpretation and analysis; and Furūʿ al-fiqh (lit. the branches of fiqh),

2600-445: The 2004 presidential election , Justice Rehnquist had been fatally ill and senior Bush administration advisors under Karl Rove began assessing the potential candidates to replace him. Among them, Roberts stood out for his experience as a Supreme Court advocate, which had brought him the favorable attention of not just conservatives but also liberals such as Ruth Bader Ginsburg . On July 19, 2005, President Bush nominated Roberts to

2700-591: The Affordable Care Act ), Shelby County v. Holder (limiting the Voting Rights Act of 1965 ), Trump v. Hawaii (expanding presidential powers over immigration), Carpenter v. United States (expanding digital privacy ), Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard (overruling race-based admission programs), and Trump v. United States (outlining the extent of presidential immunity from criminal prosecution). Roberts also presided over

2800-622: The Bethlehem Steel Corporation 's factory in Lackawanna . In 1965, ten-year-old Roberts and his family moved to Long Beach, Indiana , where his father became the manager of a new steel plant in nearby Burns Harbor . By age 13, Roberts "already had a clear plan for his life." He attended the parochial La Lumiere School , an academically rigorous Catholic boarding school in La Porte, Indiana , where he captained

2900-829: The Crusades . In particular, the "royal English contract protected by the action of debt is identified with the Islamic Aqd , the English assize of novel disseisin is identified with the Islamic Istihqaq , and the English jury is identified with the Islamic lafif ." John Makdisi speculated that English legal institutions such as "the scholastic method , the licence to teach ", the " law schools known as Inns of Court in England and Madrasas in Islam" and

3000-755: The Federal Communications Commission and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission . His opinions often employed a "characteristically crisp, clear writing style" that favored the use of imagery and idioms. Most of the disputes he reviewed concerned government regulation, union rights, and collective bargaining , but he also wrote on environmental law, criminal law, and procedural matters. One case, Hedgepeth ex rel Hedgepeth v. Washington Metropolitan Area Transit (2004), garnered media attention when Roberts found that Washington police properly detained

3100-468: The Middle East . In classical Islamic jurisprudence, litigants in court may obtain notarized statements from between three and twelve witnesses. When the statements of all witnesses are consistent, the notaries will certify their unanimous testimony in a legal document, which may be used to support the litigant's claim. The notaries serve to free the judge from the time-consuming task of hearing

Fiqh Council of North America - Misplaced Pages Continue

3200-461: The Quran and the sunnah (the teachings and practices of the Islamic prophet Muhammad and his companions). Fiqh expands and develops Shariah through interpretation ( ijtihad ) of the Quran and Sunnah by Islamic jurists ( ulama ) and is implemented by the rulings ( fatwa ) of jurists on questions presented to them. Thus, whereas sharia is considered immutable and infallible by Muslims, fiqh

3300-587: The Senate Judiciary Committee , to schedule a hearing despite an upcoming election year. Democratic lobbyists and progressive interest groups successfully encouraged Biden to stall the process. As Bill Clinton defeated Bush in the 1992 presidential election , Roberts's nomination lapsed with no Senate vote and expired at the end of the 102nd Congress . In January 1993, Roberts returned to Hogan and Hartson, where, finding great success as an advocate, he began to regularly appear again before

3400-489: The Texas Supreme Court , a close supporter of Bush, also emerged and had a chance to be the first Latino nominee. Roberts, who had not worked in government while Bill Clinton was in office, did not appear on lists compiled by Bush supporters, advocacy groups, or the media, but nonetheless remained a strong candidate for a Republican nomination and was poised to be re-nominated to the D.C. Circuit, often used as

3500-598: The White House . Fielding gathered a group of lawyers that also included J. Michael Luttig and Henry Garrett . From 1982 to 1986, Roberts was an associate with the White House Counsel . He then entered private practice in Washington, D.C. , as an associate at the law firm Hogan & Hartson (now Hogan Lovells ), working in corporate law . E. Barrett Prettyman , under whom he was first assigned,

3600-592: The first impeachment trial of President Donald Trump . Roberts was born on January 27, 1955, in Buffalo, New York , to Rosemary ( née Podrasky) and John Glover "Jack" Roberts Sr., both devout Catholics. His father had Irish and Welsh ancestry and his mother was a descendant of Slovak immigrants from Szepes , Hungary . He has two younger sisters, Margaret and Barbara, and an elder sister, Kathy. Roberts spent his early childhood years in Hamburg, New York , where his father worked as an electrical engineer for

3700-428: The principles of Islamic jurisprudence ) and the process of gaining knowledge of Islam through jurisprudence. The historian Ibn Khaldun describes fiqh as "knowledge of the rules of God which concern the actions of persons who own themselves connected to obey the law respecting what is required ( wajib ), sinful ( haraam ), recommended ( mandūb ), disapproved ( makrūh ), or neutral ( mubah )". This definition

3800-474: The standing case of Lujan v. National Wildlife Federation , which became a hallmark in the field. When Starr recused himself in Metro Broadcasting, Inc. v. FCC , Roberts took his place, arguing that the use of racial preferences by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) was unconstitutional. The position failed to convince the Court, which announced on June 27, 1990, that it had sided with

3900-448: The "European commenda " (Islamic Qirad ) may have also originated from Islamic law. The methodology of legal precedent and reasoning by analogy ( Qiyas ) are also similar in both the Islamic and common law systems. These influences have led some scholars to suggest that Islamic law may have laid the foundations for "the common law as an integrated whole". John Roberts John Glover Roberts Jr. (born January 27, 1955)

4000-536: The 7th–9th centuries, bears a notable resemblance to the trusts in the English trust law . For example, every Waqf was required to have a waqif (settlor), mutawillis (trustee), qadi (judge) and beneficiaries. The trust law developed in England at the time of the Crusades , during the 12th and 13th centuries, was introduced by Crusaders who may have been influenced by the Waqf institutions they came across in

4100-490: The Arabic language. Secondary sources of law were developed and refined over the subsequent centuries, consisting primarily of juristic preference ( istihsan ), laws of the previous prophets ( shara man qablana ), continuity ( istishab ), extended analogy ( maslaha mursala ), blocking the means ( sadd al-dhari'ah ), local customs ( urf ), and sayings of a companion of the Prophet ( qawl al-sahabi ). The Quran set

Fiqh Council of North America - Misplaced Pages Continue

4200-400: The D.C. Circuit to become U.S. Solicitor General under President George H. W. Bush . Needing a deputy, Starr chose Roberts to join the administration as Principal Deputy Solicitor General . "I felt that his experience was good for the political deputy position. [Roberts] was a steady hand, a wise hand. He came in as a person not of vast experience but of vast ability," Starr recalled. With

4300-579: The FCC. Government attorneys, surprised by Roberts's stance against the FCC, discussed whether it contributed to a politicization of the office, as the Solicitor General traditionally defended the government. Thomas Merrill , a deputy for the Solicitor General, described Roberts's candid position simply as: "This affirmative action program violated the Constitution, and we should present that to

4400-556: The Fiqh Council of North America in 1986. Its 20 members issue religious rulings, resolve disputes, and answer questions relating to the Islamic faith . As outlined in its by-laws, the Council's primary objectives include: "To consider, from a Shari'ah perspective, and offer advice on specific undertakings, transactions, contracts, projects, or proposals, guaranteeing thereby that the dealings of North American Muslims fall within

4500-527: The Islamic State and that assisted in the quick expansion of the Islamic State. The scholars in Madina were consulted on the more complex judicial issues. The Sharia and the official more centralized schools of fiqh developed later, during the time of the Abbasids. The sources of Sharia in order of importance are Primary sources Secondary sources Majority of Sunni Muslims view Qiyas as

4600-468: The Muslim jurist is known as usul al-fiqh ("principles of jurisprudence"). There are different approaches to the methodology used in jurisprudence to derive Islamic rulings from the primary sources of sharia (Islamic law). The main methodologies are those of the Sunni , Shi'a and Ibadi denominations. While both Sunni and Shi'ite (Shia) are divided into smaller sub-schools, the differences among

4700-413: The Quran "Say: Allah speaks the truth; so follow the religion of Abraham, the upright one. And he was not one of the polytheists" (Qur'an 3:95). Most of the differences are regarding Sharia laws devised through Ijtihad where there is no such ruling in the Quran or the hadiths of Islamic prophet Muhammad regarding a similar case. As these jurists went to new areas, they were pragmatic and continued to use

4800-456: The Quran and the Hadith, the example of Muhammad provided people with almost everything they needed. "This day I have perfected for you your religion and completed My favor upon you and have approved for you Islam as religion" (Qur'an 5:3). These scholars did not distinguish between each other. They were not Sunni or Shia. They felt that they were following the religion of Abraham as described in

4900-579: The Second Circuit in May, Roberts went to clerk for Justice (later Chief Justice) William Rehnquist at the U.S. Supreme Court from 1980 to 1981. At the end his clerkship with Rehnquist, Roberts worked to gain admission to the bar , studying with Michael W. McConnell , a law clerk of Justice William Brennan . After the 1980 presidential election , he resolved to work under the new Reagan administration . Rehnquist recommended him to Ken Starr , who

5000-452: The Shi'ite schools is considerably greater. Ibadites only follow a single school without divisions. While using court decisions as legal precedents and case law are central to Western law, the importance of the institution of fatawa (non-binding answers by Islamic legal scholars to legal questions) has been called "central to the development" of Islamic jurisprudence. This is in part because of

5100-524: The Sunni) schools of jurisprudence and the conflict between the unity of the Shariah and the diversity of the schools, was expressed by the 12th century Hanafi scholar Abu Hafs Umar al-Nasafi , who wrote: "Our school is correct with the possibility of error, and another school is in error with the possibility of being correct." A number of important legal institutions were developed by Muslim jurists during

SECTION 50

#1732776281119

5200-577: The Supreme Court overruled his previous loss of Metro Broadcasting, Inc. v. FCC in Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Peña , establishing that the government must treat people on an individual basis. The next year, his pro bono contributions included giving fundamental aid to gay rights activists in the landmark case of Romer v. Evans (1996). During the 2000 presidential election , Roberts went to Florida to assist George W. Bush , by which time Jeffrey Toobin identified him as "among

5300-474: The Supreme Court, he did not explicitly say whether he would vote to overturn either. Jeffrey Rosen said, "I wouldn't bet on Chief Justice Roberts's siding unequivocally with the anti- Roe forces." On September 22, 2005, the Senate Judiciary Committee approved Roberts's nomination by a vote of 13–5, with Senators Ted Kennedy , Richard Durbin , Charles Schumer , Joe Biden , and Dianne Feinstein opposed. The full Senate confirmed Roberts on September 29 by

5400-475: The Supreme Court, initially as an associate justice to fill the vacancy left by Justice Sandra Day O'Connor , but promoted him to chief justice after Rehnquist's death. Roberts was confirmed by a Senate vote of 78–22, becoming the youngest to serve in the position since John Marshall . As chief justice, Roberts has authored majority opinions in many landmark cases , including National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius (upholding most sections of

5500-450: The Supreme Court. With a reputation as the leading private Supreme Court litigator, Roberts often represented corporations that sued individuals or the government. He was Hogan and Hartson's most prominent partner , arguing 18 Supreme Court cases from 1993 to 2003 and 20 in nationwide appellate courts while also doing work pro bono , demonstrating expertise in a wide variety of different fields. In June 1995, to Roberts's satisfaction,

5600-480: The Supreme Court." When Clarence Thomas was confirmed to the Supreme Court in 1991, Roberts's proven experience in complex litigation for the Bush administration made him a leading candidate to fill Thomas's vacancy on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia . On January 27, 1992, Bush nominated Roberts, who had just turned 37 years old, to the D.C. Circuit, and Starr urged Senator Joe Biden , chair of

5700-592: The Thought of Daniel Webster," won a Bowdoin Prize . In 1976, Roberts obtained his Bachelor of Arts degree in history, summa cum laude , with membership in Phi Beta Kappa . A recent surplus of history graduate students convinced him to attend Harvard Law School for better career prospects, though he maintained his original goal to become a professor. His first-year performance in law school placed him in

5800-537: The U.S. Supreme Court to fill a vacancy to be created by the impending retirement of Justice Sandra Day O'Connor . Roberts's nomination was the first Supreme Court nomination since Stephen Breyer 's in 1994. On September 3, 2005, while Roberts's confirmation was pending before the Senate, Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist died. Two days later, Bush withdrew Roberts's nomination as O'Connor's successor and nominated Roberts to succeed Rehnquist as chief justice. During his confirmation hearings, Roberts said he did not have

5900-433: The century, of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit from 1979 to 1980. Friendly was impressed by Roberts's performance; they shared similar backgrounds, and co-clerk Reinier Kraakman recalled that "there was a bond between them." When Roberts became a federal judge years later, he identified with Friendly's nonpartisan approach to law and maintained a correspondence with him. After finishing his clerkship at

6000-532: The classical jurist who taught them. The Sunni schools (and where they are commonly found) are The schools of Shia Islam comprise: Entirely separate from both the Sunni and Shia traditions, Khawarij Islam has evolved its own distinct school. These schools share many of their rulings, but differ on the particular hadiths they accept as authentic and the weight they give to analogy or reason ( qiyas ) in deciding difficulties. The relationship between (at least

6100-684: The classical period of Islam, known as the Islamic Golden Age . One such institution was the Hawala , an early informal value transfer system , which is mentioned in texts of Islamic jurisprudence as early as the 8th century. Hawala itself later influenced the development of the agency in common law and in civil laws such as the aval in French law and the avallo in Italian law. The Waqf in Islamic law , which developed during

SECTION 60

#1732776281119

6200-470: The coming of the early Muslim jurist Muhammad ibn Idris ash-Shafi`i (767–820), who codified the basic principles of Islamic jurisprudence in his book ar-Risālah . The book details the four roots of law ( Qur'an , sunnah , ijma , and qiyas ) while specifying that the primary Islamic texts (the Qur'an and the hadith) be understood according to objective rules of interpretation derived from scientific study of

6300-407: The community ( Ijma ); a majority in the modern era also use analogy ( Qiyas ) and weigh the harms and benefits of new topics ( Istislah ), and a plurality utilizes juristic preference ( Istihsan ). The conclusions arrived at with the aid of these additional tools constitute a wide array of laws, and its application is called fiqh . Thus, in contrast to the sharia , fiqh

6400-453: The conquered lands north, east, and west, where it was systematized and elaborated. The history of Islamic jurisprudence is "customarily divided into eight periods": The formative period of Islamic jurisprudence stretches back to the time of the early Muslim communities. During this period, jurists were more concerned with issues of authority and teaching than with theory and methodology. Progress in theory and methodology happened with

6500-417: The constitutionality of acts of Congress, and when those acts are challenged, it is the obligation of the Court to say what the law is. The determination of when deference to legislative policy judgments goes too far and becomes abdication of the judicial responsibility, and when scrutiny of those judgments goes too far on the part of the judges and becomes what I think is properly called judicial activism —that

6600-431: The daughter of Abu Bakr the first caliph for advice. Asma' bint Abu Bakr replied to her son, she said: "You know better in your own self, that if you are upon the truth and you are calling towards the truth go forth, for people more honourable than you have been killed and if you are not upon the truth, then what an evil son you are and you have destroyed yourself and those who are with you. If you say, that if you are upon

6700-452: The decision is wrong, it should be overruled. That's not activism. That's applying the law correctly." As a lawyer for the Reagan administration, Roberts wrote legal memos defending administration policies on abortion . At his nomination hearing, he testified that the legal memos represented the views of the administration he was representing at the time and not necessarily his own. "I was

6800-414: The deference that is due to legislative judgments. Justice Holmes described assessing the constitutionality of an act of Congress as the gravest duty that the Supreme Court is called upon to perform. ... It's a principle that is easily stated and needs to be observed in practice, as well as in theory. Now, the Court, of course, has the obligation, and has been recognized since Marbury v. Madison , to assess

6900-456: The divergence, ash-Shafi'i proposed giving priority to the Qur'an and the Hadith (the practice of Muhammad) and only then look at the consensus of the Muslim jurists ( ijma ) and analogical reasoning ( qiyas ). This then resulted in jurists like Muhammad al-Bukhari dedicating their lives to the collection of the correct hadith, in books like Sahih al-Bukhari (Sahih translates as authentic or correct). They also felt that Muhammad's judgement

7000-414: The early Umayyad period, there was more community involvement. The Quran and Muhammad's example was the main source of law after which the community decided. If it worked for the community, was just and did not conflict with the Quran and the example of Muhammad, it was accepted. This made it easier for the different communities, with Roman, Persian, Central Asia and North African backgrounds to integrate into

7100-476: The elaboration of rulings on the basis of these principles. Furūʿ al-fiqh is the product of the application of Uṣūl al-fiqh and the total product of human efforts at understanding the divine will. A hukm ( pl. : aḥkām ) is a particular ruling in a given case. The word fiqh is an Arabic term meaning "deep understanding" or "full comprehension". Technically it refers to the body of Islamic law extracted from detailed Islamic sources (which are studied in

7200-454: The laws are contextual and consider circumstance such as time, place and culture, the principles they are based upon are universal such as justice, equality and respect. Many Muslim scholars argue that even though technology may have advanced, the fundamentals of human life have not. There are several schools of fiqh thought ( Arabic : مذهب maḏhab ; pl. مذاهب maḏāhib ) The schools of Sunni Islam are each named by students of

7300-722: The new appointment, Roberts, whose work had previously been confidential, became a prominent figure at the Supreme Court, leading the filings of the Bush administration and representing it in the media. As deputy solicitor general, Roberts frequently appeared before the Supreme Court. He argued for a number of conservative positions, including those against abortion, an extensive federal jurisdiction and policies that afforded special benefits to minority groups. In 1990, he successfully argued his first case in Atlantic Richfield Company v. USA Petroleum Company , which concerned anti-trust law, and then successfully argued

7400-480: The oath of allegiance to me but they themselves extended their hands towards me." But later as fate would have it ( Predestination in Islam ) when Yazid I , an Umayyad ruler took power, Husayn ibn Ali the grandson of Muhammad felt that it was a test from God for him and his duty to confront him. Then Abd Allah ibn al-Zubayr , Qasim ibn Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr's cousin confronted the Umayyad rulers after Husayn ibn Ali

7500-589: The obligatory daily prayers ( salat ). On other issues, for example, the Qur'an states one needs to engage in daily prayers ( salat ) and fast ( sawm ) during the month of Ramadan but further instructions and details on how to perform these duties can be found in the traditions of Muhammad, so Qur'an and Sunnah are in most cases the basis for ( Shariah ). Some topics are without precedent in Islam's early period. In those cases, Muslim jurists ( Fuqaha ) try to arrive at conclusions by other means. Sunni jurists use historical consensus of

7600-453: The parameters of what is permitted by the Shari'ah." The Council's opinions are not binding. Executive Members : Council Members : Fiqh Fiqh ( / f iː k / ; Arabic : فقه ) is Islamic jurisprudence . Fiqh is often described as the style of human understanding and practices of the sharia ; that is, human understanding of the divine Islamic law as revealed in

7700-754: The party to become an independent , jeopardizing Roberts's candidacy, which stalled once again when Senate Democrats refused to hold any nomination hearings. In 2002, Republicans regained control of the Senate and Roberts finally received a hearing by the Senate Judiciary Committee. Supported by a bipartisan letter of support signed by more than 150 members of the District of Columbia Bar —including White House counsels Lloyd Cutler , C. Boyden Gray , and Solicitor General Seth Waxman —the Judiciary Committee recommended Roberts by

7800-624: The precedent, it was not legally bound to uphold it. In his Senate testimony, Roberts said that, while sitting on the Appellate Court , he had an obligation to respect precedents established by the Supreme Court, including the right to abortion. He said: " Roe v. Wade is the settled law of the land. ... There is nothing in my personal views that would prevent me from fully and faithfully applying that precedent, as well as Casey ." Following nominees' traditional reluctance to indicate which way they might vote on an issue likely to come before

7900-497: The question and its wording." Each school ( madhhab ) reflects a unique urf or culture (a cultural practice that was influenced by traditions), that the classical jurists themselves lived in, when rulings were made. Some suggest that the discipline of isnad , which developed to validate hadith made it relatively easy to record and validate also the rulings of jurists. This, in turn, made them far easier to imitate ( taqlid ) than to challenge in new contexts. The argument is,

8000-419: The religious rulings he gave. They knew that they might have fallen into error in some of their judgements and stated this clearly. They never introduced their rulings by saying, "Here, this judgement is the judgement of God and His prophet." There is also very little text actually written down by Jafar al-Sadiq himself. They all give priority to the Qur'an and the hadith (the practice of Muhammad). They felt that

8100-448: The respect of John Paul Stevens and the Court's liberals. Democrats and Republicans alike widely viewed Roberts as one of the Supreme Court's most distinguished advocates. When George W. Bush won the contested 2000 presidential election , journalists speculated about whom he might consider as possible nominees for the Supreme Court. Luttig, Wilkinson, and other Reagan officials were leading candidates, but Judge Alberto Gonzales of

8200-435: The rights, responsibilities, and rules for people and societies to adhere to, such as dealing in interest . Muhammad then provided an example, which is recorded in the hadith books, showing people how he practically implemented these rules in a society. After the passing of Muhammad, there was a need for jurists, to decide on new legal matters where there is no such ruling in the Quran or the hadith, example of Muhammad regarding

8300-471: The same ruling as was given in that area during pre-Islamic times, if the population felt comfortable with it, it was just and they used Ijtihad to deduce that it did not conflict with the Quran or the Hadith. As explained in the Muwatta by Malik ibn Anas. This made it easier for the different communities to integrate into the Islamic State and assisted in the quick expansion of the Islamic State. To reduce

8400-522: The school's football team, participated in track and field , and was a regional champion in wrestling . He also participated in choir and drama , and was a co-editor of the school newspaper. He graduated in 1973 as class valedictorian , becoming the first graduate of the La Lumiere School to enroll at Harvard University . At Harvard College , Roberts dedicated himself to studying history, his academic major . He had entered Harvard as

8500-410: The schools have been more or less frozen for centuries, and reflect a culture that simply no longer exists. Traditional scholars hold that religion is there to regulate human behavior and nurture people's moral side and since human nature has not fundamentally changed since the beginning of Islam a call to modernize the religion is essentially one to relax all laws and institutions. Early shariah had

8600-412: The state and these rights were also applied. Ali, Hassan and Husayn ibn Ali gave their allegiance to the first three caliphs because they abided by these conditions. Later Ali the fourth caliph wrote in a letter "I did not approach the people to get their oath of allegiance but they came to me with their desire to make me their Amir (ruler). I did not extend my hands towards them so that they might swear

8700-453: The testimony of each eyewitness himself, and their documents serve to legally authenticate each oral testimony. The Maliki school requires two notaries to collect a minimum of twelve eyewitness statements in certain legal cases, including those involving unregistered marriages and land disputes. John Makdisi has compared this group of twelve witness statements, known as a lafif , to English Common Law jury trials under Henry II , surmising

8800-467: The top 15 students in a class of 550 and won him membership of the Harvard Law Review . The journal's president, David Leebron , chose Roberts as its managing editor , despite their differing political views. Classmate David Wilkins described Roberts as "more conservative than the typical Harvard Law student in the 1970s" but well-liked by fellow students. In 1979, Roberts graduated at

8900-416: The top advocates of his generation". According to biographer Joan Biskupic , he built a reputation "for his powers of persuasion and tireless preparation", and "his meticulous preparation and unflagging composure inspired confidence among his well-heeled clients." His arguments against government regulation often appealed to Rehnquist and the Court's conservatives while his style and skill in rhetoric won him

9000-407: The top of his class with a Juris Doctor , magna cum laude , despite having to admit himself to a local hospital for exhaustion. He later regretted that during his time at Harvard, he traveled into Boston on only a couple of occasions, being too preoccupied with his studies. After graduating from law school, Roberts was a law clerk for Judge Henry Friendly , one of the most influential judges of

9100-622: The truth and you will be killed at the hands of others, then you will not truly be free." Abd Allah ibn al-Zubayr left and was later also killed and crucified by the Syrian Roman Army now under the control of the Umayyads and led by Hajjaj. Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr the son of Abu Bakr the first caliph and raised by Ali the fourth caliph was also killed by the Umayyads. Aisha then raised and taught her son Qasim ibn Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr who later taught his grandson Jafar al-Sadiq. During

9200-486: Was Principal Deputy Solicitor General , after which he built a leading appellate practice and argued 39 cases before the Supreme Court. In 1992, President George H. W. Bush nominated Roberts to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit , but the Senate did not hold a vote on his confirmation. In 2003, President George W. Bush appointed Roberts to the D.C. Circuit. In 2005, Bush nominated Roberts to

9300-574: Was affected and that cases weren't going to be thrown out that way. Lopez certainly breathed new life into the Commerce Clause . I think it remains to be seen, in subsequent decisions, how rigorous a showing, and in many cases, it is just a showing. It's not a question of an abstract fact—does this affect interstate commerce or not—but has this body, the Congress, demonstrated the impact on interstate commerce that drove them to legislate? That's

9400-566: Was betrayed by the people of Kufa and killed by Syrian Roman Army now under the control of the Yazid I. Abd Allah ibn al-Zubayr then took on the Umayyads and expelled their forces from Hijaz and Iraq. But then his forces were depleted in Iraq, trying to stop the Khawarij. The Umayyads then moved in. After a lengthy campaign, in his last hour Abd Allah ibn al-Zubayr asked his mother Asma' bint Abu Bakr

9500-718: Was chief of staff to attorney general William French Smith , and Roberts was named a special assistant to the attorney general. After being admitted to the District of Columbia bar and arriving to the Department of Justice in August 1981, he helped Sandra Day O'Connor prepare for her confirmation hearings. As an assistant to the attorney general, Roberts concentrated on the scope of the Voting Rights Act of 1965 , especially Section 2 and Section 5 , both of which Roberts and other Reagan lawyers believed to have unnecessarily intruded on state regulations. He wrote to Friendly, "this

9600-463: Was more impartial and better than their own. These original jurists and scholars also acted as a counterbalance to the rulers. When they saw injustice, all these scholars spoke out against it. As the state expanded outside Madina, the rights of the different communities, as they were constituted in the Constitution of Medina still applied. The Quran also gave additional rights to the citizens of

9700-419: Was one of the most prominent advocates in the country along with Rex E. Lee . Roberts also built a successful practice as an appellate lawyer, heading the firm's division for appellate advocacy. He made his first appearance before the Supreme Court in United States v. Halper , arguing against the government, and the Court unanimously upheld his arguments. In 1989, Ken Starr relinquished his judgeship on

9800-577: Was raised Catholic in Northwest Indiana and studied at Harvard University with the initial intent to become a historian, graduating in three years with highest distinction, then attended Harvard Law School , where he was an editor of the Harvard Law Review . Before holding positions in the Reagan and senior Bush administration , Roberts served as a law clerk for Judge Henry Friendly and Justice William Rehnquist . From 1989 to 1993, he

9900-405: Was taught by Malik ibn Anas. Ahmad ibn Hanbal was taught by Al-Shafi‘i. Muhammad al-Bukhari travelled everywhere collecting hadith and his father Ismail ibn Ibrahim was a student of Malik ibn Anas. In the books actually written by these original jurists and scholars, there are very few theological and judicial differences between them. Imam Ahmad rejected the writing down and codifying of

10000-609: Was the main teacher of Malik ibn Anas whose views many Sunni follow and also taught by Jafar al-Sadiq. Qasim ibn Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr , Hisham ibn Urwah and Muhammad al-Baqir taught Zayd ibn Ali , Jafar al-Sadiq, Abu Hanifa , and Malik ibn Anas. Imam Jafar al-Sadiq, Imam Abu Hanifa and Malik ibn Anas worked together in Al-Masjid an-Nabawi in Medina. Along with Qasim ibn Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr, Muhammad al-Baqir, Zayd ibn Ali and over 70 other leading jurists and scholars. Al-Shafi‘i

#118881