Misplaced Pages

#660339

61-420: The 2008 NIMH Strategic Plan calls for NIMH to "Develop, for research purposes, new ways of classifying mental disorders based on dimensions of observable behavior and neurobiological measures." The strategic plan continues: Currently, the diagnosis of mental disorders is based on clinical observation—identifying symptoms that tend to cluster together, determining when the symptoms appear, and determining whether

122-645: A brain disease (or degeneration ) model that had emerged during the 19th century, as well as some ideas from Darwin 's theory of evolution and/or Freud 's psychoanalytic theories. Psychoanalytic theory did not rest on classification of distinct disorders, but pursued analyses of unconscious conflicts and their manifestations within an individual's life. It dealt with neurosis, psychosis, and perversion. The concept of borderline personality disorder and other personality disorder diagnoses were later formalized from such psychoanalytic theories, though such ego psychology-based lines of development diverged substantially from

183-404: A broader term, or to refer only to milder or more transient issues. Confusion often surrounds the ways and contexts in which these terms are used. Mental disorders are generally classified separately to neurological disorders , learning disabilities or intellectual disabilities . The International Classification of Diseases (ICD) is an international standard diagnostic classification for

244-838: A classification scheme for the US army, called Medical 203, synthesizing ideas of the time into five major groups. This system was adopted by the Veterans Administration in the United States and strongly influenced the DSM . Transdiagnostic process A transdiagnostic process is a proposed psychological mechanism underlying and connecting a group of mental disorders . Over the last two centuries, western mental health science has focused on nosology whereby panels of experts identify hypothetical sets of signs and symptoms , label, and compile them into taxonomies such as

305-451: A clear distinction between insanity (including mania and dementia) as opposed to mental retardation (including idiocy and imbecility). Esquirol developed a concept of monomania —a periodic delusional fixation or undesirable disposition on one theme—that became a broad and common diagnosis and a part of popular culture for much of the 19th century. The diagnosis of " moral insanity " coined by James Prichard also became popular; those with

366-718: A continuum ranging from normal to extreme. Co-occurrence of multiple mental disorders might reflect different patterns of symptoms that result from shared risk factors and perhaps the same underlying disease processes. To clarify the underlying causes of mental disorders, it will be necessary to define, measure, and link basic biological and behavioral components of normal and abnormal functioning. This effort will require integration of genetic, neuroscience, imaging, behavioral, and clinical studies. By linking basic biological and behavioral components, it will become possible to construct valid, reliable phenotypes (measurable traits or characteristics) for mental disorders. This will help us elucidate

427-644: A form of mental disorders in one taxonomy. Classification schemes may not apply to all cultures. The DSM is based on predominantly American research studies and has been said to have a decidedly American outlook, meaning that differing disorders or concepts of illness from other cultures (including personalistic rather than naturalistic explanations) may be neglected or misrepresented, while Western cultural phenomena may be taken as universal. Culture-bound syndromes are those hypothesized to be specific to certain cultures (typically taken to mean non-Western or non-mainstream cultures); while some are listed in an appendix of

488-545: A lack of interest and faith on behalf of NIMH for the DSM process and an investment in alternative diagnostic systems." A NIMH description of RDoC explained: Currently, diagnosis in mental disorders is based on clinical observation and patients' phenomenological symptom reports ... However, in antedating contemporary neuroscience research, the current diagnostic system is not informed by recent breakthroughs in genetics; and molecular, cellular and systems neuroscience. The RDoC matrix

549-548: A more central "unitary" cause . French and German psychiatric nosology was in the ascendency. The term "psychiatry" ("Psychiatrie") was coined by German physician Johann Christian Reil in 1808, from the Greek "ψυχή" ( psychē : "soul or mind") and "ιατρός" ( iatros : "healer or doctor"). The term "alienation" took on a psychiatric meaning in France, later adopted into medical English. The terms psychosis and neurosis came into use,

610-495: A periodic course and better outcome were grouped together under the category of manic-depressive insanity (mood disorder). He also proposed a third category of psychosis, called paranoia, involving delusions but not the more general deficits and poor course attributed to dementia praecox. In all he proposed 15 categories, also including psychogenic neurosis, psychopathic personality, and syndromes of defective mental development (mental retardation). He eventually included homosexuality in

671-431: A range of related categorical diagnoses and nonthreshold symptom patterns. Some approaches go further and propose continuously varying dimensions that are not grouped into spectra or categories; each individual simply has a profile of scores across different dimensions. DSM-5 planning committees are currently seeking to establish a research basis for a hybrid dimensional classification of personality disorders. However,

SECTION 10

#1732782756661

732-595: A significantly increased risk of suffering" but that "...no definition adequately specifies precise boundaries for the concept of 'mental disorder'...different situations call for different definitions" (APA, 1994 and 2000). The DSM also states that "there is no assumption that each category of mental disorder is a completely discrete entity with absolute boundaries dividing it from other mental disorders or no mental disorders." The DSM-IV-TR (Text Revision, 2000) consisted of five axes (domains) on which disorder could be assessed. The five axes were: The axis classification system

793-405: A single specific disorder. Transdiagnostic processes also suggest mechanisms through which delusions and cognitive biases may be understood. For example, the process of detecting covariation can lead to illusory correlations between unrelated stimuli, and the process of hypothesis testing and data gathering is generally subject to confirmation bias , meaning existing beliefs are not updated in

854-577: A specific syndrome now known as somatization disorder were first developed by the French physician, Paul Briquet in 1859. An American physician, Beard, described " neurasthenia " in 1869. German neurologist Westphal , coined the term " obsessional neurosis " now termed obsessive-compulsive disorder , and agoraphobia . Alienists created a whole new series of diagnoses that highlighted single, impulsive behavior, such as kleptomania , dipsomania , pyromania , and nymphomania . The diagnosis of drapetomania

915-485: A wide variety of health conditions. The ICD-10 states that mental disorder is "not an exact term", although is generally used "...to imply the existence of a clinically recognisable set of symptoms or behaviours associated in most cases with distress and with interference with personal functions." Chapter V focuses on "mental and behavioural disorders" and consists of 10 main groups: Within each group there are more specific subcategories. The WHO has revised ICD-10 to produce

976-542: A wider context of awareness, rather than as expressions of external reality, may enable someone to step back from those thoughts and to see them as ideas to be tested rather than unchangeable facts. If research can identity a relatively limited number of transdiagnostic processes, people facing a wide range of mental difficulties might be helped by practitioners trained to master a relatively limited number of techniques corresponding to those underlying processes, rather than requiring many specialists who are each expert in treating

1037-413: Is agnostic about current disorder categories." Official documents explain this feature, writing: "Rather than starting with an illness definition and seeking its neurobiological underpinnings, RDoC begins with current understandings of behavior-brain relationships and links them to clinical phenomena." Unlike conventional diagnostic systems, which typically rely on self-report and behavioral measures alone,

1098-823: Is central to the practice of psychiatry and other mental health professions . The two most widely used psychiatric classification systems are chapter V of the International Classification of Diseases , 10th edition ( ICD-10 ), produced by the World Health Organization (WHO); and the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders , 5th edition (DSM-5), produced by the American Psychiatric Association (APA). Both systems list disorders thought to be distinct types, and in recent revisions

1159-477: Is no single consensus on the definition of mental disorder, and that the phrasing used depends on the social, cultural, economic and legal context in different contexts and in different societies. The WHO reports that there is intense debate about which conditions should be included under the concept of mental disorder; a broad definition can cover mental illness, intellectual disability, personality disorder and substance dependence, but inclusion varies by country and

1220-530: Is one way of organizing the concepts involved, with domains as tables, constructs as rows, sub-constructs as subrows and units of analysis often presented as columns. The domains are tentative: "It is important to emphasize that these particular domains and constructs are simply starting points that are not definitive or set in concrete." Also, subconstructs have been added to some constructs. For example, Visual Perception, Auditory Perception, and Olfactory/Somatosensory/Multimodal perception as subconstructs of

1281-418: Is reported to be a complex and debated issue. There may be a criterion that a condition should not be expected to occur as part of a person's usual culture or religion. However, despite the term "mental", there is not necessarily a clear distinction drawn between mental (dys)functioning and brain (dys)functioning, or indeed between the brain and the rest of the body. Most international clinical documents avoid

SECTION 20

#1732782756661

1342-543: Is the classification of reference for French child psychiatrists. The ICD and DSM classification schemes have achieved widespread acceptance in psychiatry. A survey of 205 psychiatrists, from 66 countries across all continents, found that ICD-10 was more frequently used and more valued in clinical practice and training, while the DSM-IV was more frequently used in clinical practice in the United States and Canada, and

1403-410: The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders . While this is one of the approaches that has historically driven progress in medicine , such taxonomies have long been controversial on grounds including bias , diagnostic reliability and potential conflicts of interest amongst their promoters. Over-reliance on taxonomy may have created a situation where its benefits are now outweighed by

1464-498: The Canon of Medicine listed a number of mental disorders, including "passive male homosexuality". Laws generally distinguished between "idiots" and "lunatics". Thomas Sydenham (1624–1689), the "English Hippocrates", emphasized careful clinical observation and diagnosis and developed the concept of a syndrome , a group of associated symptoms having a common course, which would later influence psychiatric classification. Evolution in

1525-497: The DSM and 3,106 to the ICD. In Japan , most university hospitals use either the ICD or DSM. ICD appears to be the somewhat more used for research or academic purposes, while both were used equally for clinical purposes. Other traditional psychiatric schemes may also be used. The classification schemes in common usage are based on separate (but may be overlapping) categories of disorder schemes sometimes termed "neo-Kraepelinian" (after

1586-472: The DSM diagnoses are based on a consensus about clusters of clinical symptoms, not any objective laboratory measure. In that post, Insel wrote: "Patients with mental disorders deserve better." He would later elaborate on this point, saying "I look at the data and I'm concerned. ... I don't see a reduction in the rate of suicide or prevalence of mental illness or any measure of morbidity. I see it in other areas of medicine and I don't see it for mental illness. That

1647-820: The DSM-IV they are not detailed and there remain open questions about the relationship between Western and non-Western diagnostic categories and sociocultural factors, which are addressed from different directions by, for example, cross-cultural psychiatry or anthropology . In Ancient Greece, Hippocrates and his followers are generally credited with the first classification system for mental illnesses, including mania , melancholia , paranoia , phobias and Scythian disease ( transvestism ). They held that they were due to different kinds of imbalance in four humors . The Persian physicians 'Ali ibn al-'Abbas al-Majusi and Najib ad-Din Samarqandi elaborated upon Hippocrates' system of classification. Avicenna (980−1037 CE) in

1708-473: The Perception construct. The RDoC methodology distinguishes itself from traditional systems of diagnostic criteria. Unlike conventional diagnostic systems (e.g. DSM) which use categorization, RDoC is a "dimensional system" — it relies on dimensions that "span the range from normal to abnormal." Whereas conventional diagnostic systems incrementally revise and build upon their pre-existing paradigms, "RDoC

1769-764: The RDoC framework has the "explicit goal" of allowing investigators access to a wider range of data. In addition to self-report measures or measure of behavior, RDoC also incorporates units of analysis beyond those found in the DSM — allowing RDoC to be informed by insights into genes, molecules, cells, circuits, physiology, and large-scale paradigms. Early data driven approaches to RDoC based continuous transdiagnostic psychiatric phenotypes predict clinical prognosis across diagnosis and have genetic correlates that in not only clinical populations. Classification of mental disorders The classification of mental disorders , also known as psychiatric nosology or psychiatric taxonomy ,

1830-534: The biological taxonomy of Carl Linnaeus . It was only part of his classification of 2400 medical diseases. These were divided into 10 "classes", one of which comprised the bulk of the mental diseases, divided into four "orders" and 23 "genera". One genus, melancholia , was subdivided into 14 "species". William Cullen advanced an influential medical nosology which included four classes of neuroses: coma, adynamias , spasms, and vesanias . The vesanias included amentia , melancholia, mania, and oneirodynia . Towards

1891-530: The category of "mental conditions of constitutional origin". The neuroses were later split into anxiety disorders and other disorders. Freud wrote extensively on hysteria and also coined the term, "anxiety neurosis", which appeared in DSM-I and DSM-II. Checklist criteria for this led to studies that were to define panic disorder for DSM-III. Early 20th century schemes in Europe and the United States reflected

Research Domain Criteria - Misplaced Pages Continue

1952-457: The causes of the disorder, while clarifying the boundaries and overlap between mental disorders. In order to understand mental disorders in terms of dimensions and/or components of neurobiology and behaviors, it will be important to: On April 29, 2013, a few weeks before the publication of the DSM-5 , NIMH director Thomas Insel published a blog post critical of the DSM methodology and highlighting

2013-500: The claim that, "symptom-based diagnosis, once common in other areas of medicine, has been largely replaced in the past half century as we have understood that symptoms alone rarely indicate the best choice of treatment." As a result of this position, the NIMH is no longer using the DSM as the criteria upon which they will evaluate funding of future clinic trials. DSM researcher Eric Hollander was quoted as saying "I do think it does represent

2074-437: The condition did not seem delusional or intellectually impaired but seemed to have disordered emotions or behavior. The botanical taxonomic approach was abandoned in the 19th century, in favor of an anatomical-clinical approach that became increasingly descriptive. There was a focus on identifying the particular psychological faculty involved in particular forms of insanity, including through phrenology , although some argued for

2135-724: The context of mental problems, it has been structured largely as an adjunct to the categories of the DSM. Moreover, dimensionality approach was criticized for its reliance on independent dimensions whereas all systems of behavioral regulations show strong inter-dependence, feedback and contingent relationships Descriptive classifications are based almost exclusively on either descriptions of behavior as reported by various observers, such as parents, teachers, and medical personnel; or symptoms as reported by individuals themselves. As such, they are quite subjective, not amenable to verification by third parties, and not readily transferable across chronologic and/or cultural barriers. Somatic nosology, on

2196-404: The definition will always involve a mixture of scientific facts (e.g. that a natural or evolved function is not working properly) and value judgments (e.g. that it is harmful or undesired). Lay concepts of mental disorder vary considerably across different cultures and countries, and may refer to different sorts of individual and social problems. The WHO and national surveys report that there

2257-454: The end of the 18th century and into the 19th, Pinel , influenced by Cullen's scheme, developed his own, again employing the terminology of genera and species. His simplified revision of this reduced all mental illnesses to four basic types. He argued that mental disorders are not separate entities but stem from a single disease that he called "mental alienation". Attempts were made to merge the ancient concept of delirium with that of insanity,

2318-399: The face of facts we have to draw the line where none exists... A classification therefore has only provisional value. It is a fiction which will discharge its function if it proves to be the most apt for the time". Adolph Meyer advanced a mixed biosocial scheme that emphasized the reactions and adaptations of the whole organism to life experiences. In 1945, William C. Menninger advanced

2379-440: The first four years of life. It has been published in 9 languages. The Research Diagnostic criteria-Preschool Age ( RDC-PA ) was developed between 2000 and 2002 by a task force of independent investigators with the goal of developing clearly specified diagnostic criteria to facilitate research on psychopathology in this age group. The French Classification of Child and Adolescent Mental Disorders (CFTMEA), operational since 1983,

2440-614: The former viewed psychologically and the latter neurologically. In the second half of the century, Karl Kahlbaum and Ewald Hecker developed a descriptive categorizion of syndromes , employing terms such as dysthymia , cyclothymia , catatonia , paranoia and hebephrenia . Wilhelm Griesinger (1817–1869) advanced a unitary scheme based on a concept of brain pathology. French psychiatrists Jules Baillarger described "folie à double forme" and Jean-Pierre Falret described " la folie circulaire "—alternating mania and depression. The concept of adolescent insanity or developmental insanity

2501-1307: The fragmentation and constraints it has caused in the training of mental health practitioners, the range of treatments they can provide under insurance cover, and the scope of new research. To date, no biological marker or individual cognitive process has been associated with a unique mental diagnosis but rather such markers and processes seem implicated across many diagnostic categories. For these reasons, researchers have recently begun to investigate mechanisms through which environmental factors such as poverty , discrimination , loneliness , aversive parenting , and childhood trauma or maltreatment might act as causes of many disorders and which therefore might point towards interventions that could help many people affected by them. Research suggests that transdiagnostic processes may underlie multiple aspects of cognition including attention , memory /imagery, thinking , reasoning , and behavior . While an exhaustive, confirmed list of transdiagnostic processes does not yet exist, relatively strong evidence exists for processes including: Processes supported by growing evidence include: Transdiagnostic processes suggest interventions to help people suffering from mental disorders. For example, helping someone to view thoughts as mental events in

Research Domain Criteria - Misplaced Pages Continue

2562-450: The improvement offered by the RDoC project. Wrote Insel: While DSM has been described as a 'Bible' for the field, it is, at best, a dictionary, creating a set of labels and defining each. The strength of each of the editions of DSM has been " reliability " – each edition has ensured that clinicians use the same terms in the same ways. The weakness is its lack of validity . Unlike our definitions of ischemic heart disease, lymphoma, or AIDS,

2623-505: The inclusion of certain controversial categories, the influence of the pharmaceutical industry, or the stigmatizing effect of being categorized or labelled . Some approaches to classification do not use categories with single cut-offs separating the ill from the healthy or the abnormal from the normal (a practice sometimes termed "threshold psychiatry" or " dichotomous classification" ). Classification may instead be based on broader underlying " spectra ", where each spectrum links together

2684-464: The late 19th century, Koch referred to "psychopathic inferiority" as a new term for moral insanity. In the 20th century the term became known as "psychopathy" or "sociopathy", related specifically to antisocial behavior. Related studies led to the DSM-III category of antisocial personality disorder . Influenced by the approach of Kahlbaum and others, and developing his concepts in publications spanning

2745-485: The latest version of the ICD, ICD-11 adopted by the 72nd World Health Assembly in 2019 and came into effect on 1 January 2022. The DSM -IV was originally published in 1994 and listed more than 250 mental disorders. It was produced by the American Psychiatric Association and it characterizes mental disorder as "a clinically significant behavioral or psychological syndrome or pattern that occurs in an individual,...is associated with present distress...or disability...or with

2806-440: The latter sometimes described as delirium without fever. On the other hand, Pinel had started a trend for diagnosing forms of insanity 'without delirium' (meaning hallucinations or delusions) – a concept of partial insanity . Attempts were made to distinguish this from total insanity by criteria such as intensity, content or generalization of delusions. Pinel's successor, Esquirol , extended Pinel's categories to five. Both made

2867-599: The other hand, is based almost exclusively on the objective histologic and chemical abnormalities which are characteristic of various diseases and can be identified by appropriately trained pathologists. While not all pathologists will agree in all cases, the degree of uniformity allowed is orders of magnitude greater than that enabled by the constantly changing classification embraced by the DSM system. Some models, like Functional Ensemble of Temperament suggest to unify nosology of somatic, biologically based individual differences in healthy people (temperament) and their deviations in

2928-414: The paths taken elsewhere within psychoanalysis. The philosopher and psychiatrist Karl Jaspers made influential use of a "biographical method" and suggested ways to diagnose based on the form rather than content of beliefs or perceptions. In regard to classification in general he prophetically remarked that: "When we design a diagnostic schema, we can only do so if we forego something at the outset … and in

2989-513: The problem with entirely dimensional classifications is they are said to be of limited practical value in clinical practice where yes/no decisions often need to be made, for example whether a person requires treatment, and moreover the rest of medicine is firmly committed to categories, which are assumed to reflect discrete disease entities. While the Psychodynamic Diagnostic Manual has an emphasis on dimensionality and

3050-474: The psychiatrist Kraepelin ) which is intended to be atheoretical with regard to etiology (causation). These classification schemes have achieved some widespread acceptance in psychiatry and other fields, and have generally been found to have improved inter-rater reliability , although routine clinical usage is less clear. Questions of validity and utility have been raised, both scientifically and in terms of social, economic and political factors—notably over

3111-440: The scientific and academic literature on the definition or categorization of mental disorders, one extreme argues that it is entirely a matter of value judgments (including of what is normal ) while another proposes that it is or could be entirely objective and scientific (including by reference to statistical norms); other views argue that the concept refers to a "fuzzy prototype " that can never be precisely defined, or that

SECTION 50

#1732782756661

3172-504: The scientific concepts of psychopathology (literally referring to diseases of the mind) took hold in the late 18th and 19th centuries following the Renaissance and Enlightenment . Individual behaviors that had long been recognized came to be grouped into syndromes . Boissier de Sauvages developed an extremely extensive psychiatric classification in the mid-18th century, influenced by the medical nosology of Thomas Sydenham and

3233-572: The symptoms resolve, recur, or become chronic. However, the way that mental disorders are defined in the present diagnostic system does not incorporate current information from integrative neuroscience research, and thus is not optimal for making scientific gains through neuroscience approaches. It is difficult to deconstruct clusters of complex behaviors and attempt to link these to underlying neurobiological systems. Many mental disorders may be considered as falling along multiple dimensions (e.g., cognition, mood, social interactions), with traits that exist on

3294-479: The term "mental illness", preferring the term "mental disorder". However, some use "mental illness" as the main overarching term to encompass mental disorders. Some consumer/survivor movement organizations oppose use of the term "mental illness" on the grounds that it supports the dominance of a medical model . The term "serious mental impairment" (SMI) is sometimes used to refer to more severe and long-lasting disorders while " mental health problems" may be used as

3355-410: The turn of the century, German psychiatrist Emil Kraepelin advanced a new system. He grouped together a number of existing diagnoses that appeared to all have a deteriorating course over time—such as catatonia , hebephrenia and dementia paranoides —under another existing term " dementia praecox " (meaning "early senility ", later renamed schizophrenia). Another set of diagnoses that appeared to have

3416-599: The two systems have deliberately converged their codes so that their manuals are often broadly comparable, though differences remain. Both classifications employ operational definitions . Other classification schemes, used more locally, include the Chinese Classification of Mental Disorders . Manuals of limited use, by practitioners with alternative theoretical persuasions, include the Psychodynamic Diagnostic Manual . In

3477-502: Was advanced by Scottish Asylum Superintendent and Lecturer in Mental Diseases Thomas Clouston in 1873, describing a psychotic condition which generally impacts those aged 18–24 years, particularly males, and in 30% of cases proceeded to "a secondary dementia". The concept of hysteria (wandering womb) had long been used, perhaps since ancient Egyptian times, and was later adopted by Freud. Descriptions of

3538-486: Was also developed in the Southern United States to explain the perceived irrationality of black slaves trying to escape what was thought to be a suitable role. The scientific study of homosexuality began in the 19th century, informally viewed either as natural or as a disorder. Kraepelin included it as a disorder in his Compendium der Psychiatrie that he published in successive editions from 1883. In

3599-492: Was more valued for research, with accessibility to either being limited, and usage by other mental health professionals, policy makers, patients and families less clear. . A primary care (e.g. general or family physician) version of the mental disorder section of ICD-10 has been developed (ICD-10-PHC) which has also been used quite extensively internationally. A survey of journal articles indexed in various biomedical databases between 1980 and 2005 indicated that 15,743 referred to

3660-442: Was removed in the DSM-5 and is now mostly of historical significance. The main categories of disorder in the DSM are: Child and adolescent psychiatry sometimes uses specific manuals in addition to the DSM and ICD. The Diagnostic Classification of Mental Health and Developmental Disorders of Infancy and Early Childhood (DC:0-3) was first published in 1994 by Zero to Three to classify mental health and developmental disorders in

3721-493: Was the basis for my comment that people with mental illness deserve better." In their effort to resolve their issues with the new DSM, the NIMH launched the Research Domain Criteria Project (RDoC), based on four assumptions: Insel stressed that the RDoC is not designed as diagnostic criteria to replace the DSM, but rather as a research framework, for future development. His argument centers around

SECTION 60

#1732782756661
#660339