Misplaced Pages

#717282

60-537: Ernst Heinrich Weber states that "the minimum increase of stimulus which will produce a perceptible increase of sensation is proportional to the pre-existent stimulus," while Gustav Fechner 's law is an inference from Weber's law (with additional assumptions) which states that the intensity of our sensation increases as the logarithm of an increase in energy rather than as rapidly as the increase. Both Weber's law and Fechner's law were formulated by Gustav Theodor Fechner (1801–1887). They were first published in 1860 in

120-450: A constant, and S {\displaystyle S} being the physical intensity of the stimulus. Weber's law always fails at low intensities, near and below the absolute detection threshold, and often also at high intensities, but may be approximately true across a wide middle range of intensities. Although Weber's law includes a statement of the proportionality of a perceived change to initial stimuli, Weber only refers to this as

180-560: A decrease in brightness by a factor of 100. Modern researchers have attempted to incorporate such perceptual effects into mathematical models of vision. Perception of Glass patterns and mirror symmetries in the presence of noise follows Weber's law in the middle range of regularity-to-noise ratios ( S ), but in both outer ranges, sensitivity to variations is disproportionally lower. As Maloney, Mitchison, & Barlow (1987) showed for Glass patterns, and as van der Helm (2010) showed for mirror symmetries, perception of these visual regularities in

240-411: A large purchase, but will shop around to save a large percentage on a small purchase which represents a much smaller absolute dollar amount. It has been hypothesized that dose-response relationships can follow Weber's Law which suggests this law – which is often applied at the sensory level – originates from underlying chemoreceptor responses to cellular signaling dose relationships within

300-399: A logarithmic scale can be helpful when the data: A slide rule has logarithmic scales, and nomograms often employ logarithmic scales. The geometric mean of two numbers is midway between the numbers. Before the advent of computer graphics, logarithmic graph paper was a commonly used scientific tool. If both the vertical and horizontal axes of a plot are scaled logarithmically, the plot

360-430: A logarithmic scale have exponents that increment uniformly. Examples of equally spaced values are 10, 100, 1000, 10000, and 100000 (i.e., 10 , 10 , 10 , 10 , 10 ) and 2, 4, 8, 16, and 32 (i.e., 2 , 2 , 2 , 2 , 2 ). Exponential growth curves are often depicted on a logarithmic scale graph . The markings on slide rules are arranged in a log scale for multiplying or dividing numbers by adding or subtracting lengths on

420-410: A moderate range and stellar magnitude is measured on a logarithmic scale. This magnitude scale was invented by the ancient Greek astronomer Hipparchus in about 150 B.C. He ranked the stars he could see in terms of their brightness, with 1 representing the brightest down to 6 representing the faintest, though now the scale has been extended beyond these limits; an increase in 5 magnitudes corresponds to

480-460: A popular therapy of the time. Ernst Weber died in 1878 in Leipzig, Germany. Weber described the just-noticeable difference or jnd as follows: “in observing the disparity between things that are compared, we perceive not the difference between the things, but the ratio of this difference to the magnitude of things compared.” In other words, we are able to distinguish the relative difference, not

540-698: A quantity ( physical or mathematical) on a logarithmic scale, that is, as being proportional to the value of a logarithm function applied to the ratio of the quantity and a reference quantity of the same type. The choice of unit generally indicates the type of quantity and the base of the logarithm. Examples of logarithmic units include units of information and information entropy ( nat , shannon , ban ) and of signal level ( decibel , bel, neper ). Frequency levels or logarithmic frequency quantities have various units are used in electronics ( decade , octave ) and for music pitch intervals ( octave , semitone , cent , etc.). Other logarithmic scale units include

600-427: A rule of thumb regarding human perception. It was Fechner who formulated this statement as a mathematical expression referred to as Weber contrast . d p = d S S {\displaystyle dp={\frac {dS}{S}}\,\!} Weber contrast is not part of Weber's law. Fechner noticed in his own studies that different individuals have different sensitivity to certain stimuli. For example,

660-474: A series of experiments on the physics of fluids with his younger brother Wilhelm. This research was the first detailed account of hydrodynamic principles in the circulation of blood. Weber continued his research on blood and in 1827, he made another significant finding. Weber explained the elasticity of blood vessels in the movement of blood in the aorta in a continuous flow to the capillaries and arterioles. This technique helped map sensitivity and touch acuity on

SECTION 10

#1732787371718

720-420: Is logarithmic . This logarithmic relationship means that if a stimulus varies as a geometric progression (i.e., multiplied by a fixed factor), the corresponding perception is altered in an arithmetic progression (i.e., in additive constant amounts). For example, if a stimulus is tripled in strength (i.e., 3 × 1 ), the corresponding perception may be two times as strong as its original value (i.e., 1 + 1 ). If

780-640: Is a constant of integration and ln is the natural logarithm . To solve for C {\displaystyle C} , assume that the perceived stimulus becomes zero at some threshold stimulus S 0 {\displaystyle S_{0}} . Using this as a constraint, set p = 0 {\displaystyle p=0} and S = S 0 {\displaystyle S=S_{0}} . This gives: C = − k ln ⁡ S 0 {\displaystyle C=-k\ln {S_{0}}} Substituting C {\displaystyle C} in

840-440: Is an "experience of divergence of two points when stimulation is moved over insensitive areas and convergence of two points when moved over sensitive areas". Weber’s use of multivariate experiment, precise measurements, and research on sensory psychology and sensory physiology laid the groundwork for accepting experimental psychology as a field and providing new ideas for fellow 19th century psychologists to expand. Weber's work on

900-684: Is completely inapplicable at low light levels ( scotopic vision ). This can be seen in data collected by Blackwell and plotted by Crumey , showing threshold increment log Δ B {\displaystyle \Delta B} versus background luminance log B {\displaystyle B} for various targets sizes. At daylight levels, the curves are approximately straight with slope 1, i.e. log Δ B {\displaystyle \Delta B} = log B + c o n s t . {\displaystyle B+const.} , implying C = Δ B / B {\displaystyle C=\Delta B/B}

960-481: Is constant. At the very darkest background levels ( B {\displaystyle B} ≲ 10 cd m, approximately 25 mag arcsec) the curves are flat - this is where the only visual perception is the observer's own neural noise ( 'dark light' ). In the intermediate range, a portion can be approximated by the De Vries - Rose law , related to Ricco's law . Activation of neurons by sensory stimuli in many parts of

1020-424: Is defined as C = Δ B / B {\displaystyle C=\Delta B/B} , and Weber's law says that C {\displaystyle C} should be constant for all B {\displaystyle B} . Human vision follows Weber's law closely at normal daylight levels (i.e. in the photopic range ) but begins to break down at twilight levels (the mesopic range) and

1080-403: Is inversely proportional to the size of the components of the difference; relative differential sensitivity remains the same regardless of size. What this means is that the perceived change in stimuli is inversely proportional to the initial stimuli. Weber's law also incorporates the just-noticeable difference (JND). This is the smallest change in stimuli that can be perceived. As stated above,

1140-434: Is needed in order to tell a difference. Weber’s Law, as labeled by Gustav Theodor Fechner , established that sensory events can be related mathematically to measurable relative changes in physical stimulus values. Weber’s law is invalid when the stimulus approaches the upper or lower limits of a sensory modality. Fechner took inspiration from Weber’s Law and developed what we know today as Fechner’s Law, claiming that there

1200-430: Is often cited as the pioneer or father of experimental psychology. He was the first to conduct true psychological experiments that held validity. While most psychologists of the time conducted work from behind a desk, Weber was actively conducting experiments, manipulating only one variable at a time in order to gain more accurate results. This paved the way for the field of psychology as an experimental science and opened

1260-412: Is referred to as a log–log plot . If only the ordinate or abscissa is scaled logarithmically, the plot is referred to as a semi-logarithmic plot. A modified log transform can be defined for negative input ( y < 0) to avoid the singularity for zero input ( y = 0), and so produce symmetric log plots: for a constant C =1/ln(10). A logarithmic unit is a unit that can be used to express

SECTION 20

#1732787371718

1320-513: The just noticeable difference (JND) between two weights was approximately proportional to the weights. Thus, if the weight of 105 g can (only just) be distinguished from that of 100 g, the JND (or differential threshold) is 5 g. If the mass is doubled, the differential threshold also doubles to 10 g, so that 210 g can be distinguished from 200 g. In this example, a weight (any weight) seems to have to increase by 5% for someone to be able to reliably detect

1380-458: The JND dS is proportional to the initial stimuli intensity S . Mathematically, it can be described as d S = K ⋅ S {\displaystyle dS=K\cdot S} where S {\displaystyle S} is the reference stimulus and K {\displaystyle K} is a constant. It may be written as Ψ = k log S , with Ψ being the sensation, k {\displaystyle k} being

1440-550: The University of Wittenberg in 1811. He went on to receive his MD in 1815 from the University of Halle. Weber spent his entire academic career at the University of Leipzig. He completed his Habilitation in 1817 and became an assistant in J.C. Clarus ’ medical clinic in the same year. He became professor of comparative anatomy in 1818 and chair of human anatomy at the university in 1821. Ernst Weber’s first direct contribution to psychology came in 1834 when trying to describe

1500-414: The ability to perceive differences in light intensity could be related to how good that individual's vision is. He also noted that how the human sensitivity to stimuli changes depends on which sense is affected. He used this to formulate another version of Weber's law that he named die Maßformel , the "measurement formula". Fechner's law states that the subjective sensation is proportional to the logarithm of

1560-462: The absolute difference between items. Or, we can distinguish between stimuli having a constant ratio, not a constant difference. This ratio is known as the Weber fraction. Weber’s first work with the jnd had to do with differences in weight. He stated that the jnd is the "minimum amount of difference between two weights necessary to tell them apart". He found that the finest discrimination between weights

1620-436: The body using compass technique. Points of a compass would be set at varying distances in order to see at what distance are the points of the compass perceived as two separate points instead of one single point. Weber also wrote about and tested other ideas on sensation including a terminal threshold, which is the highest intensity an individual could sense before the sensation could not be detected any longer. Weber’s Illusion

1680-506: The body. Dose response can be related to the Hill equation , which is closer to a power law. There is a new branch of the literature on public finance hypothesizing that the Weber–Fechner law can explain the increasing levels of public expenditures in mature democracies. Election after election, voters demand more public goods to be effectively impressed; therefore, politicians try to increase

1740-480: The brain is by a proportional law: neurons change their spike rate by about 10–30%, when a stimulus (e.g. a natural scene for vision ) has been applied. However, as Scheler (2017) showed, the population distribution of the intrinsic excitability or gain of a neuron is a heavy tail distribution , more precisely a lognormal shape, which is equivalent to a logarithmic coding scheme. Neurons may therefore spike with 5–10 fold different mean rates. Obviously, this increases

1800-399: The central nervous system, auditory system, anatomy and function of brain, circulation, etc., and a large portion of research on sensory physiology and psychology. The following items are part of Weber’s contributions the experimental psychology : Studied flow and movement of waves in liquids and elastic tubes. Weber discovered laws and applied them to circulation. In 1821, Weber launched

1860-440: The common sensibility") led E. B. Titchener to call the work "the foundation stone of experimental psychology". The book that described blood circulation research, Wellenlehre, auf Experimenten gegrϋndet (English: "Wave Theory, Founded on Experiments") became instantly recognized as very important to physics and physiology. This research lead the way for future investigating, although it was not formally published until 1850 with

Weber–Fechner law - Misplaced Pages Continue

1920-426: The culmination of the rest of his research on blood in a book entitled, Ueber die Anwendung der Wellenlehre auf die Lehre vom Kreislauf des Blutes und insbesondere auf die Pulslehre (English: "Concerning the application of the wave theory to the theory of the circulation of the blood and, in particular, on the pulse teaching"). Joint works with his brothers Wilhelm Eduard Weber and Eduard Friedrich Weber : Weber

1980-435: The current value to ensure human observers will reliably be able to detect that change. Fechner did not conduct any experiments on how perceived heaviness increased with the mass of the stimulus. Instead, he assumed that all JNDs are subjectively equal, and argued mathematically that this would produce a logarithmic relation between the stimulus intensity and the sensation. These assumptions have both been questioned. Following

2040-449: The dynamic range of a neuronal population, while stimulus-derived changes remain small and linear proportional. An analysis of the length of comments in internet discussion boards across several languages shows that comment lengths obey the lognormal distribution with great precision. The authors explain the distribution as a manifestation of the Weber–Fechner law. The Weber–Fechner law has been applied in other fields of research than just

2100-419: The human senses. Psychological studies show that it becomes increasingly difficult to discriminate between two numbers as the difference between them decreases. This is called the distance effect . This is important in areas of magnitude estimation, such as dealing with large scales and estimating distances. It may also play a role in explaining why consumers neglect to shop around to save a small percentage on

2160-415: The implications that his experiments would have on understanding of sensory stimulus and response. Logarithmic scale A logarithmic scale (or log scale ) is a method used to display numerical data that spans a broad range of values, especially when there are significant differences between the magnitudes of the numbers involved. Unlike a linear scale where each unit of distance corresponds to

2220-477: The increase, and this minimum required fractional increase (of 5/100 of the original weight) is referred to as the "Weber fraction" for detecting changes in weight. Other discrimination tasks, such as detecting changes in brightness, or in tone height (pure tone frequency), or in the length of a line shown on a screen, may have different Weber fractions, but they all obey Weber's law in that observed values need to change by at least some small but constant proportion of

2280-534: The integrated expression for Weber's law, the expression can be written as: p = k ln ⁡ S S 0 {\displaystyle p=k\ln {\frac {S}{S_{0}}}} The constant k is sense-specific and must be determined depending on the sense and type of stimulus. Weber and Fechner conducted research on differences in light intensity and the perceived difference in weight. Other sense modalities provide only mixed support for either Weber's law or Fechner's law. Weber found that

2340-536: The magnitude of this "signal" of competence – the size and composition of public expenditures – in order to collect more votes. Preliminary research has found that pleasant emotions adhere to Weber’s Law, with accuracy in judging their intensity decreasing as pleasantness increases. However, this pattern wasn't observed for unpleasant emotions, suggesting a survival-related need for accurately discerning high-intensity negative emotions. Ernst Heinrich Weber Ernst Heinrich Weber (24 June 1795 – 26 January 1878)

2400-578: The most natural display of numbers in some cultures. The top left graph is linear in the X- and Y-axes, and the Y-axis ranges from 0 to 10. A base-10 log scale is used for the Y-axis of the bottom left graph, and the Y-axis ranges from 0.1 to 1000. The top right graph uses a log-10 scale for just the X-axis, and the bottom right graph uses a log-10 scale for both the X axis and the Y-axis. Presentation of data on

2460-495: The near miss holds across all the frequencies, and that the intensity discrimination is not a function of frequency, and that the change in discrimination with level can be represented by a single function across all frequencies: Δ I / I = 0.463 ( I / I 0 ) − 0.072 {\displaystyle \Delta I/I=0.463{(I/I_{0})}^{-0.072}} . The eye senses brightness approximately logarithmically over

Weber–Fechner law - Misplaced Pages Continue

2520-564: The phenomena was presented by Riesz in 1928, in Physical Review. This deviation of the Weber's law is known as the "near miss" of the Weber's law. This term was coined by McGill and Goldberg in their paper of 1968 in Perception & Psychophysics. Their study consisted of intensity discrimination in pure tones. Further studies have shown that the near miss is observed in noise stimuli as well. Jesteadt et al. (1977) demonstrated that

2580-448: The same increment, on a logarithmic scale each unit of length is a multiple of some base value raised to a power, and corresponds to the multiplication of the previous value in the scale by the base value. In common use, logarithmic scales are in base 10 (unless otherwise specified). A logarithmic scale is nonlinear , and as such numbers with equal distance between them such as 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 are not equally spaced. Equally spaced values on

2640-622: The scales. The following are examples of commonly used logarithmic scales, where a larger quantity results in a higher value: The following are examples of commonly used logarithmic scales, where a larger quantity results in a lower (or negative) value: Some of our senses operate in a logarithmic fashion ( Weber–Fechner law ), which makes logarithmic scales for these input quantities especially appropriate. In particular, our sense of hearing perceives equal ratios of frequencies as equal differences in pitch. In addition, studies of young children in an isolated tribe have shown logarithmic scales to be

2700-559: The sensation of touch ( De Pulsu, Resorptione, Auditu et Tactu . Leipzig 1834). He was professor of physiology and anatomy from 1840 to 1866, and returned to the position of professor of anatomy from 1866 to 1871. In his later life, Weber became less involved in testing and experimenting, although he was still interested in sensory physiology. Ernst Heinrich Weber retired from the University of Leipzig in 1871. He continued to work with his brother, Eduard and their work with nerve stimulation and muscle suppression lead to inhibitory responses as

2760-427: The smallest distance between two points where a person determines that it is two points and not one, was Weber’s first discovery. Weber’s work made a significant impact on the field of experimental psychology , as he was one of the first scientist to test his ideas on humans. His meticulous notes and new ideas of testing subjects described in his book Der tastsinn und das gemeingefühl (English: "The sense of touch and

2820-421: The stimulus intensity. According to this law, human perceptions of sight and sound work as follows: Perceived loudness/brightness is proportional to logarithm of the actual intensity measured with an accurate nonhuman instrument. p = k ln ⁡ S S 0 {\displaystyle p=k\ln {\frac {S}{S_{0}}}\,\!} The relationship between stimulus and perception

2880-499: The stimulus is again tripled in strength (i.e., 3 × 3 × 1 ), the corresponding perception will be three times as strong as its original value (i.e., 1 + 1 + 1 ). Hence, for multiplications in stimulus strength, the strength of perception only adds. The mathematical derivations of the torques on a simple beam balance produce a description that is strictly compatible with Weber's law. Since Weber's law fails at low intensity, so does Fechner's law. An early reference to "Fechner's ... law"

2940-612: The tactile senses was published in Latin as De Subtilitate Tactus (1834), and in German as Der Tastsinn und das Gemeingefühl in 1846. Both works were translated into English by Ross and Murray as E.H.Weber: The Sense of Touch (Academic Press, 1978) and reprinted as E.H.Weber on the Tactile Senses (Erlbaum, Taylor & Francis, 1996). Weber proposed there was a threshold of sensation in each individual. The two-point threshold ,

3000-470: The way for the development of even more accurate and intense research methods. One of Weber’s greatest influences was on Gustav Fechner . Weber was appointed the Dozent of Psychology at the University of Leipzig the same year that Fechner enrolled. Weber’s work with sensation inspired Fechner to further the work and go on to develop Weber’s law. At the time of his sensation work, Weber did not fully realize

3060-516: The whole range of regularity-to-noise ratios follows the law p = g /(2+1/ S ) with parameter g to be estimated using experimental data. For vision, Weber's law implies constancy of luminance contrast . Suppose a target object is set against a background luminance B {\displaystyle B} . In order to be just visible, the target must be brighter or fainter than the background by some small amount Δ B {\displaystyle \Delta B} . The Weber contrast

SECTION 50

#1732787371718

3120-423: The work Elemente der Psychophysik ( Elements of Psychophysics ). This publication was the first work ever in this field, and where Fechner coined the term psychophysics to describe the interdisciplinary study of how humans perceive physical magnitudes. He made the claim that "...psycho-physics is an exact doctrine of the relation of function or dependence between body and soul." Ernst Heinrich Weber (1795–1878)

3180-514: The work of S. S. Stevens, many researchers came to believe in the 1960s that the Stevens's power law was a more general psychophysical principle than Fechner's logarithmic law. Weber's law does not quite hold for loudness . It is a fair approximation for higher intensities, but not for lower amplitudes. Weber's law does not hold at perception of higher intensities. Intensity discrimination improves at higher intensities. The first demonstration of

3240-411: Was a German physician who is considered one of the founders of experimental psychology . He was an influential and important figure in the areas of physiology and psychology during his lifetime and beyond. His studies on sensation and touch, along with his emphasis on good experimental techniques led to new directions and areas of study for future psychologists, physiologists, and anatomists. Ernst Weber

3300-477: Was a logarithmic relation between stimulus intensity and perceived intensity. Fechner’s Law was more advanced than Weber's Law, partly because Fechner had developed new methods for measuring just-noticeable differences in different sense modalities, making the measured results more accurate. For most of his career, Weber worked with his brothers, Wilhelm and Eduard, and partner Gustav Theodor Fechner. Throughout these working relationships, Weber completed research on

3360-465: Was born into an academic background, with his father serving as a professor at the University of Wittenberg. Weber became a doctor, specializing in anatomy and physiology. Two of his younger brothers, Wilhelm and Eduard, were also influential in academia, both as scientists with one specializing in physics and the other in anatomy. Ernst became a lecturer and a professor at the University of Leipzig and stayed there until his retirement. Ernst Heinrich Weber

3420-466: Was born on 24 June 1795 in Wittenberg, Saxony, Holy Roman Empire. He was son to Michael Weber, a professor of theology at the University of Wittenberg. At a young age, Weber became interested in physics and the sciences after being heavily influenced by Ernst Chladni , a physicist often referred to as the “father of acoustics”. Weber completed secondary school at Meissen and began studying medicine at

3480-516: Was in 1875 by Ludimar Hermann in Elements of Human Physiology . Fechner's law is a mathematical derivation of Weber contrast. d p = k d S S {\displaystyle dp=k{\frac {dS}{S}}} Integrating the mathematical expression for Weber contrast gives: p = k ln ⁡ S + C {\displaystyle p=k\ln {S}+C} where C {\displaystyle C}

3540-429: Was one of the first persons to approach the study of the human response to a physical stimulus in a quantitative fashion. Fechner was a student of Weber and named his first law in honor of his mentor, since it was Weber who had conducted the experiments needed to formulate the law. Fechner formulated several versions of the law, all communicating the same idea. One formulation states: Simple differential sensitivity

3600-525: Was when they differed by 8–10%. For example, if you were holding a 100 g block, the second block would need to weigh at least 108 g in order to be distinguishable. Weber also suspected that a constant fraction applied for all senses, but is different for each sense. When comparing the differences in line length, there must be at least 0.01 difference in order to distinguish the two. When comparing music pitch, there must be at least 0.006 vibrations per second difference. So for every sense, some increase in intensity

#717282