86-685: The Independent Commission Against Corruption ( ICAC ) is an integrity agency of the Government of New South Wales responsible for eliminating and investigating corrupt activities and enhancing the integrity of the state's public administration . The commission was established in 1989, pursuant to the Independent Commission Against Corruption Act, 1988 (NSW), modeled after the ICAC in Hong Kong . It
172-702: A 4:1 majority ruling in relation to an ICAC investigation into alleged conduct of Margaret Cunneen SC , the High Court of Australia found that the ICAC had exceeded its authority based on a misinterpretation of "corrupt conduct" in the Act. Section 8(2) of the Act defined "corrupt conduct" as conduct that "adversely affects, or that could adversely affect ... the exercise of official functions by any public official". The High Court found that, in this context, "adversely affect" means "adversely affect or could adversely affect
258-453: A call (caller’s phone number), time of the call, duration, etc. Call content is namely the stream of data carrying the call. Included in the architecture is the lawful interception management function, which covers interception session set-up and tear-down, scheduling, target identification, etc. Communications between the network operator and LEA are via the handover interfaces (HI). Communications data and content are typically delivered from
344-785: A form of parliamentary government based on the model of the United Kingdom . Legislative power formally rests with the King, acting with the advice and consent of the Legislative Council and Legislative Assembly —together known as the Parliament of New South Wales . Executive power is exercised by the Executive Council, which consists of the Governor and senior ministers. The Governor, as representative of
430-423: A former Labor Senator, opined that the ICAC had caused " collateral damage " to innocent people, citing Eric Roozendaal as an example. After O'Farrell's resignation, Bruce Baird , a former State Deputy Liberal Leader who voted for the ICAC establishing legislation, was quoted on ABC TV describing the commission as a " Star Chamber " that "trashes peoples' reputations". Professor Peter van Onselen also questioned
516-580: A front-end means of supporting most LI real-time handover standards. All of these standards have been challenged as "deficient" by the U.S. Department of Justice pursuant to CALEA. The principal global treaty-based legal instrument relating to LI (including retained data) is the Convention on Cybercrime (Budapest, 23 Nov 2001). The secretariat for the Convention is the Council of Europe. However,
602-411: A legal interception gateway (LIG), along legal interception nodes (LIN), which allow them to intercept in real-time the phone calls, SMS messages, emails and some file transfers or instant messages. These LI measures for governmental surveillance have been in place since the beginning of digital telephony. To prevent investigations' being compromised, LI systems may be designed in a manner that hides
688-418: A matter to the commission. In 2014 it was estimated that less than one per cent out of around 3,000 complaints annually result in a public hearing. The commission has the coercive powers of a royal commission and can compel witnesses to testify. Public hearings are designed to act as a preventative measure against corruption. Where the ICAC rules that an official has acted corruptly, the charges are referred to
774-550: A member of the Legislative Assembly. On 29 June 2023, ICAC found that that Berejiklian had engaged in "serious corrupt conduct" by refusing to report Maguire's corrupt statements to her, but did not recommend criminal charges against her as ICAC evidence is not admissible in criminal court due to the loss of the right to silence within hearings. In September 2023, Berejiklian lodged legal action against ICAC, seeking judicial review of their findings against her. While
860-523: A number of independent agencies that fall under a portfolio but remain at arms-length for political reasons, such as the Independent Commission Against Corruption and Electoral Commission . The state Executive Council , consisting of the governor and senior ministers, exercises the executive authority through the relevant portfolio. The legislative branch includes the bicameral state parliament , which includes
946-600: A parliamentary democracy. Its relationship with the federal government is regulated by the Australian Constitution . The current government is held by the state Labor Party , led by Premier Chris Minns . Minns succeeded Dominic Perrottet from the Liberal Party on 28 March 2023 following the state election . New South Wales is governed according to the principles of the Westminster system ,
SECTION 10
#17327720141121032-767: A period of at least six months, up to two years, and made available to law enforcement upon lawful request. The Directive has been widely emulated in other countries. On 8 April 2014, the Court of Justice of the European Union declared the Directive 2006/24/EC invalid for violating fundamental rights. In the United States , three Federal statutes authorize lawful interception. The 1968 Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act , Title III pertains mainly to lawful interception criminal investigations . The second law,
1118-631: A pledge of loyalty to Australia and to the people of New South Wales instead of swearing allegiance to the Queen her heirs and successors, and to revise the oaths taken by Executive Councillors. The Act was assented to by the Queen on 3 April 2006. On 5 June 2012 the Constitution Amendment (Restoration of Oaths of Allegiance) Act 2012 No 33 was assented to and made a further amendment to the Constitution Act 1902 , by restoring
1204-409: A proposed body "responsible for the implementation of a national pro-integrity framework, with an emphasis on prevention", has been described as a "federal ICAC". Until 2017, the ICAC was led by a single commissioner, who served for a non-renewable term of five years. From 7 August 2017, this system was changed to a board comprising a chief commissioner and two part-time commissioners appointed for
1290-467: A search warrant before accessing information from internet service providers about users’ identities. The context behind this 8-0 ruling is an adolescent Saskatchewan man charged with possessing and distributing child pornography. The police used the man’s IP address to access his personal information from his online service provider— all of which was done without a search warrant. The plaintiff’s attorneys argued that their client’s rights were violated, as he
1376-592: A second, and indeed a third, former Minister for alleged corruption; the former Chief Stipendiary Magistrate gaoled for perverting the course of justice; a former Commissioner of Police in the courts on a criminal charge; the former Deputy Commissioner of Police charged with bribery; a series of investigations and court cases involving judicial figures including a High Court Judge; and a disturbing number of dismissals, retirements and convictions of senior police officers for offences involving corrupt conduct.... No government can maintain its claim to legitimacy while there remains
1462-473: A suspect's phone without a warrant. There are four rules which officers must follow in these instances: To continue a search without a warrant, the situation at-hand would need to meet three of the four guidelines stated above. Nonetheless, the court highly encourages law enforcement to request a warrant before searching a cellphone to promote and protect privacy in Canada. Due to Yarovaya Law , law enforcement
1548-567: A suspect’s cell phone, but they must abide by very strict guidelines. This ruling came about from the argument of Kevin Fearon who was convicted of armed robbery in 2009. After robbing a Toronto Jewelry kiosk, Fearon argued that the police unlawfully violated his charter rights upon searching his cellphone without a warrant. Although divided, the Supreme Court laid out very detailed criteria for law enforcement officers to follow when searching
1634-488: A term of five years. The following individuals have been appointed as commissioner since the commission's establishment: Government of New South Wales The Government of New South Wales , also known as the NSW Government , is the governing body of New South Wales , Australia. The executive government comprises 11 portfolios, led by a ministerial department and supported by several agencies. There are also
1720-515: A warrant. Lawful interception can also be authorized under local laws for state and local police investigations. Police ability to lawfully intercept private communications is governed by Part VI of the Criminal Code of Canada (Invasion Of Privacy). When evaluating Canada’s position on lawful interception, Canadian courts have issued two major rulings on this issue. In June 2014, the Supreme Court ruled that law enforcement officers need
1806-703: A witness and asked if he recalled being sent a gift of a $ 2,978 bottle of wine by the CEO of the company. O'Farrell said he had no recollection of such a gift. When a thank-you note in O'Farrell's handwriting was produced the next day, O'Farrell immediately announced that he would resign as party leader and as Premier. Later during the same case, NSW Police Minister Mike Gallacher voluntarily stood down as minister after counsel assisting alleged that he been involved in obtaining an illegal political donation. However, Premier Mike Baird required him to resign. ICAC ultimately did not proceed with corruption charges. On 15 April 2015 in
SECTION 20
#17327720141121892-471: A witness before the ICAC in proceedings that led to the resignation of O'Farrell, lodged a complaint in 2014 with the NSW Bar Association about Watson's behaviour during the hearings. The Cunneen investigation was criticised, in the light of the eventual High Court decision, as having been heavy-handed from the start. On the other hand, in an editorial in the wake of the O'Farrell resignation,
1978-433: Is also separate from the data retention of metadata that has become a legal requirement in some jurisdictions. Lawful interception is obtaining communications network data pursuant to lawful authority for the purpose of analysis or evidence . Such data generally consist of signaling or network management information or, in fewer instances, the content of the communications. If the data are not obtained in real-time,
2064-788: Is an array of federal and state criminal law, in Commonwealth of Independent States countries as SORM . In the European Union , the European Council Resolution of 17 January 1995 on the Lawful Interception of Telecommunications (Official Journal C 329) mandated similar measures to CALEA on a pan-European basis. Although some EU member countries reluctantly accepted this resolution out of privacy concerns (which are more pronounced in Europe than
2150-622: Is charged with educating public authorities, officials and members of the public about corruption. The Inspector of the Independent Commission Against Corruption is an independent statutory officer whose role and functions is to hold the ICAC accountable in the way it carries out its function. The Inspector's role are set out in Part 5A of the ICAC Act. The inspector is not answerable to ICAC in any way and
2236-489: Is currently John Hatzistergos , former state Labor minister and District Court judge. Helen Murrell SC and Paul Lakatos SC are currently part-time commissioners. The chief commissioner is required to submit a report on the activities of the commission to the Parliament of New South Wales and whilst independent of the politics of government, reports informally to the Premier of New South Wales . The commission
2322-529: Is entitled to stored private communication data. Rule 4 of the IT (Procedure and Safeguards for Interception, Monitoring and Decryption of Information) Rules 2009 provides that ‘the competent authority may authorise an agency of the Government to intercept, monitor or decrypt information generated, transmitted, received or stored in any computer resource for the purpose specified in sub-section (1) of Section 69 of
2408-493: Is led by a chief commissioner appointed for a fixed five-year term; and two part-time commissioners. Then-NSW Premier Mike Baird suggested in November 2016 his desire to move from a sole commissioner to a three-commissioner system, however this was strongly criticised by two former ICAC commissioners as weakening and politicising the organisation, leading to the resignation of then-Commissioner Megan Latham. The chief commissioner
2494-399: Is located in physically separate premises from the ICAC. The inspector's role includes: undertaking audits of the ICAC's operations to ensure compliance with the law; dealing with complaints about the conduct of the ICAC and current and former officers; and assessing the effectiveness and appropriateness of the ICAC's procedures. The inspector has extensive powers to investigate the conduct of
2580-561: Is now applied worldwide (in some cases with slight variations in terminology), including in the United States in the context of CALEA conformance. Three stages are called for in the architecture: The call data (known as intercept related information (IRI) in Europe and call data (CD) in the US) consists of information about the targeted communications, including destination of a voice call (e.g., called party’s telephone number), source of
2666-523: Is to be approved by the competent authority i.e. Union Home secretary. These powers are also available to the competent authority in the State governments as per IT (Procedure and Safeguards for Interception, Monitoring and Decryption of Information) Rules 2009. · As per rule 22 of the IT (Procedure and Safeguards for Interception, Monitoring and Decryption of Information) Rules 2009, all such cases of interception or monitoring or decryption are to be placed before
Independent Commission Against Corruption (New South Wales) - Misplaced Pages Continue
2752-795: The High Court of Australia and other federal courts have overriding jurisdiction on matters which fall under the ambit of the Australian Constitution. In 2006, the Sesquicentenary of Responsible Government in New South Wales, the Constitution Amendment Pledge of Loyalty Act 2006 No. 6 was enacted to amend the Constitution Act 1902 to require Members of the New South Wales Parliament and its Ministers to take
2838-686: The Liberal government in Tasmania and the Nationals administration in Queensland ( Fitzgerald Inquiry ). In 1988, Nick Greiner, a Liberal, ran against Labor in New South Wales on an anti-corruption platform and won. Introducing legislation to establish the ICAC, Greiner told Parliament: In recent years, in New South Wales we have seen: a Minister of the Crown gaoled for bribery; an inquiry into
2924-540: The National Security Administration has been collecting connection metadata for all calls in the United States under the authority of section 215 PATRIOT Act, with the mandatory cooperation of phone companies and with the approval of the FISA court and briefings to Congress. The government claims it does not access the information in its own database on contacts between American citizens without
3010-516: The New South Wales Labor Party . Lawful interception Lawful interception ( LI ) refers to the facilities in telecommunications and telephone networks that allow law enforcement agencies with court orders or other legal authorization to selectively wiretap individual subscribers. Most countries require licensed telecommunications operators to provide their networks with Legal Interception gateways and nodes for
3096-968: The Obeid family's farm. The number of earlier investigations affected has been estimated at between eight and at least 50. Duncan challenged the 2015 amendment act, claiming that it infringed the separation of powers established in the federal constitution, which as settled in Kable flows through to the NSW courts by cross-vesting. On 9 September 2015, the High Court unanimously dismissed that appeal, awarding costs against Duncan. In October 2021, ICAC announced an investigation into whether then-Premier Gladys Berejiklian had breached public trust or encouraged corrupt behaviour during her romantic relationship with MP Daryl Maguire . In response to ICAC's announcement, Berejiklian announced her intention to resign as Premier and as
3182-464: The Parliament of New South Wales website and were sworn on by the Governor with effect from 5 April 2023, while their opposition counterparts are listed to correspond with the government ministers. All Opposition counterparts are members of the Parliament of New South Wales. The full ministry was announced on 4 April 2023 and was sworn in the following day on 5 April. All Ministers are members of
3268-638: The Sydney Morning Herald quoted new NSW Premier Mike Baird that "ICAC is doing exactly what it should do and it is something that I will sign up to 100 per cent"; the newspaper advocated creation of a federal equivalent. Likewise, Australian Greens Senator Lee Rhiannon renewed the Greens' long-standing call for a national equivalent to ICAC. Calls for changes to how the ICAC operates following O'Farrell's resignation were rejected by Professor Anne Twomey, an expert in public and constitutional law at
3354-691: The University of Sydney , because it was O'Farrell who misled the ICAC, breached the parliamentary code of conduct and failed to properly declare pecuniary interests. A more historical defence of the ICAC has been that it was set up by a Liberal government in an expectation, shared fearfully by the Labor opposition, that it would be in effect "a standing royal commission into Labor", and that Coalition members and supporters have been appalled that it has not turned out that way. As of mid-December 2015, disputes continue. The Australian Federal Integrity Commission ,
3440-426: The probity of the exercise of an official function by a public official" and not "adversely affect or could adversely affect the efficacy of the exercise of an official function by a public official in the sense that the official could exercise the function in a different manner or make a different decision from that which would otherwise be the case". The Court ruled that Cunneen's alleged conduct might have affected
3526-473: The "Star Chamber" nature of the commission and its history of "besmirching reputations". Former Victorian Premier Jeff Kennett suggested that the ICAC's actions with regard to O'Farrell had been " entrapment ", while Chris Merritt of The Australian suggested that the investigation had been "ludicrous" and that it was Geoffrey Watson (counsel assisting the ICAC) who should have resigned instead. Nick Di Girolamo,
Independent Commission Against Corruption (New South Wales) - Misplaced Pages Continue
3612-490: The 1978 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act , or FISA, as amended by the Patriot Act , governs wiretapping for intelligence purposes where the subject of the investigation must be a foreign (non-US) national or a person working as an agent on behalf of a foreign country. The Administrator of the U.S. Courts annual reports indicate that the federal cases are related to illegal drug distribution , with cell phones as
3698-518: The Act’. · The Statutory order (S.O.) dated 20.12.2018 has been issued in accordance with rules framed in year 2009 and in vogue since then. · No new powers have been conferred to any of the security or law enforcement agencies by the S.O. dated 20.12.2018. · Notification has been issued to notify the ISPs, TSPs, Intermediaries etc. to codify the existing orders. · Each case of interception, monitoring, decryption
3784-495: The Crown, is the formal repository of power, which is exercised by him or her on the advice of the Premier of New South Wales and the cabinet. The Premier and ministers are appointed by the Governor, and hold office by virtue of their ability to command the support of a majority of members of the Legislative Assembly. Judicial power is exercised by the Supreme Court of New South Wales and a system of subordinate courts, but
3870-538: The ICAC Act maladministration is defined as action or inaction of a serious nature that is contrary to law, or unreasonable, unjust, oppressive or improperly discriminatory, or based wholly or partly on improper motives. The ICAC has jurisdiction over state and local government in New South Wales . This extends to parliamentarians, local councillors, the Governor of New South Wales , public servants, and staff of universities and state-owned corporations. Anyone can refer
3956-543: The ICAC and its officers including obtaining documents from the ICAC and requiring ICAC officers to attend before him and answer questions. The inspector can also sit as a royal commissioner in order to conduct investigations. As a royal commissioner the inspector has extensive powers to compel witnesses to provide evidence. The inspector can deal with complaints about the conduct of the ICAC or its officers which concern abuses of power, impropriety, misconduct of any kind, lengthy delays in investigation and maladministration. Under
4042-474: The ICAC has received support from some sections of the media, it received substantial criticism in the wake of the Greiner and O'Farrell resignations. In 1994, former Premier Neville Wran suggested that the then Government should consider "[ridding] the ICAC legislation of its glaring abuses of civil rights". In the wake of the findings of corruption against Eddie Obeid and Ian Macdonald , Graham Richardson ,
4128-596: The ICAC referred the allegations against Cunneen to the New South Wales Director of Public Prosecutions ; in July 2015 the Solicitor General determined that a prosecution was not warranted. Some of those investigations into governmental corruption had led to ICAC reports that recommended legislation to cancel certain mining licences without compensation and such legislation had been enacted by
4214-596: The ICAC was led by a single commissioner, who, although the agency belongs within the New South Wales Premier's Department , reported directly to the presiding officers of the Parliament of New South Wales. The commissioner served a single five-year term and cannot be dismissed except by the Governor. Following the passage of the Independent Commission Against Corruption Amendment Act 2016 (NSW),
4300-592: The ICAC's general powers. On 6 May 2015, the NSW government rushed through the parliament, with all-party support, a bill to amend the Independent Commission Against Corruption Act; the amendments were brought into effect immediately. The Independent Commission Against Corruption Amendment (Validation) Act 2015 (NSW) does not simply reverse the Cunneen decision. It amends the principal act so as to validate retrospectively
4386-407: The ICAC's powers will be considered by a review, which premier Baird had announced on 5 May, to be headed by former High Court chief justice Murray Gleeson and to report by 10 July. Following the Cunneen decision, the ICAC confirmed that it would agree to court orders that would declare invalid its findings against mine owner Travers Duncan and other businessmen involved in a mining venture over
SECTION 50
#17327720141124472-399: The New South Wales parliament. Simultaneously with the Cunneen decision, the High Court unanimously rejected challenges to the validity of that legislation. The Cunneen decision, while not affecting that legislation itself, raised questions about the validity of the investigations that led to those reports. The ICAC disagreed with the High Court's interpretation of the act, as "contrary to
4558-495: The U.S. Europe continues to maintain its global leadership role in this sector through the adoption by the European Parliament and Council in 2006 of the far reaching Data Retention Directive . The provisions of the Directive apply broadly to almost all public electronic communications and require the capture of most related information, including location, for every communication. The information must be stored for
4644-556: The US ), there appears now to be general agreement with the resolution. Interception mandates in Europe are generally more rigorous than those of the US; for example, both voice and ISP public network operators in the Netherlands have been required to support interception capabilities for years. In addition, publicly available statistics indicate that the number of interceptions in Europe exceed by many hundreds of times those undertaken in
4730-781: The USA, the comparable requirements are enabled by the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act (CALEA), with the specific capabilities promulgated jointly by the Federal Communications Commission and the Department of Justice. In the USA, lawful intercept technology is currently patented by a company named Voip-pal.com under the USPTO Publication #: 20100150138. Governments require phone service providers to install
4816-498: The activity is referred to as access to retained data (RD). There are many bases for this activity that include infrastructure protection and cybersecurity. In general, the operator of public network infrastructure can undertake LI activities for those purposes. Operators of private network infrastructures in the United States have an inherent right to maintain LI capabilities within their own networks unless otherwise prohibited. One of
4902-508: The agencies authorized to exercise these powers and preventing any unauthorized use of these powers by any agency, individual or intermediary. III. The above notification will ensure that provisions of law relating to lawful interception or monitoring of computer resource are followed and if any interception, monitoring or decryption is required for purposes specified in Section 69 of the IT Act,
4988-504: The agency was reconstituted as a three-member commission, comprising a chief commissioner and two other commissioners; and in order for a public hearing to be held as part of any corruption investigation, the chief commissioner and at least one other commissioner must agree. The 1980s saw a number of corruption scandals break around Australia, involving the Labor administrations in New South Wales, Victoria and Western Australia ( WA Inc ),
5074-435: The bases for LI is the interception of telecommunications by law enforcement agencies (LEAs), regulatory or administrative agencies, and intelligence services, in accordance with local law. Under some legal systems, implementations—particularly real-time access to content—may require due process and receiving proper authorization from competent authorities—an activity that was formerly known as "wiretapping" and has existed since
5160-471: The case of email IRI would be similar to the header information on an email message (e.g., destination email address, source email address, time email was transmitted) as well as pertinent header information within the IP packets conveying the message (e.g., source IP address of email server originating the email message). Of course, more in-depth information would be obtained by the interception system so as to avoid
5246-428: The cloud of suspicion and doubt that has hung over government in New South Wales. The ICAC's first task was to investigate activities of the previous Wran and Unsworth governments. No charges were recommended by the commission. In 1992, the ICAC ruled that Premier Greiner's offer of a government job to former minister Terry Metherell was an act of "technical" corruption. Although the charges were later dismissed by
SECTION 60
#17327720141125332-593: The commission and failure to testify (along with misleading the commission) can lead to five-year jail terms. While the ICAC cannot impose custodial sentences (other than for procedural matters), it can recommend that criminal charges be considered by the Department of Public Prosecution. In practice it has achieved very few convictions following its investigations and has had key findings such as that against former Premier Greiner found as going beyond its powers. As well as its inquisitorial powers, ICAC has telephone intercept powers . From its establishment until November 2016,
5418-461: The commission released a report titled Investigation into Corruption Risks Involved in Lobbying . It recommended the implementation of a new lobbying regulatory scheme to provide transparency and to reduce both the risk of corruption and public distrust. In 2014, the ICAC investigated alleged corrupt activities relating to a water infrastructure company. It called Premier Barry O'Farrell as
5504-509: The courts, the four independent MPs on whom the premier relied for a majority in the Legislative Assembly indicated that they would no longer support his leadership. Greiner resigned and was replaced by John Fahey . In 2008, the ICAC documented entrenched corruption within RailCorp . A range of offences were investigated, involving staff at many levels, and A$ 19 million was found to have been improperly allocated. The ICAC began focusing on ministerial level corruption from 2010. In November 2010,
5590-432: The criminal justice system for consideration by the Director of Public Prosecutions to lay criminal charges. There are only limited controls on admissible evidence, which may be obtained by compulsion and coercion or other means that would make it inadmissible in a court of law. Often evidence used in ICAC cases cannot subsequently be used in related criminal proceedings. There is no right to silence for witnesses called to
5676-518: The dominant form of intercepted communication. During the 1990s, as in most countries, to help law enforcement and the FBI more effectively carry out wiretap operations, especially in view of the emerging digital voice and wireless networks at the time, the U.S. Congress passed the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act (CALEA) in 1994. This act provides the Federal statutory framework for network operator assistance to LEAs in providing evidence and tactical information. In 2005, CALEA
5762-417: The earlier J-STD-025A to include packetized voice and CDMA wireless interception. To ensure the quality of evidence, the Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies (CALEA) has outlined standards for electronic surveillance once a Title III surveillance application is approved: Generic global standards have also been developed by Cisco via the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) that provide
5848-466: The inception of electronic communications. The material below primarily treats this narrow segment of LI. Almost all countries have lawful interception capability requirements and have implemented them using global LI requirements and standards developed by the European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI) , Third Generation Partnership Project ( 3GPP ), or CableLabs organizations—for wireline/Internet, wireless, and cable systems, respectively. In
5934-535: The innovative TS102232 standards suite that apply to most contemporary network uses. USA interception standards that help network operators and service providers conform to CALEA are mainly those specified by the Federal Communications Commission (which has both plenary legislative and review authority under CALEA), CableLabs , and the Alliance for Telecommunications Industry Solutions (ATIS). ATIS's standards include new standards for broadband Internet access and VoIP services, as well as legacy J-STD-025B, which updates
6020-515: The interception from the telecommunications operator concerned. This is a requirement in some jurisdictions. Alternatively, LI systems may be designed using technology such as transparent decryption , which ensures that access or interception is necessarily overt in order to disincentivize abuse of authority. To ensure systematic procedures for carrying out interception, while also lowering the costs of interception solutions, industry groups and government agencies worldwide have attempted to standardize
6106-428: The interception of communications. The interfaces of these gateways have been standardized by telecommunication standardization organizations. As with many law enforcement tools, LI systems may be subverted for illicit purposes. With the legacy public switched telephone network (PSTN), wireless, and cable systems, lawful interception (LI) was generally performed by accessing the mechanical or digital switches supporting
6192-412: The investigations that had led to the recent convictions, as well as the convictions themselves so far as affected by the Cunneen interpretation of the ICAC's powers. It also retrospectively validates other investigations by the ICAC up to that decision, and confirms that the ICAC is able to refer those investigations and any evidence gained by them to some other, unspecified person or body. The future of
6278-521: The judgment of the highest court in the land", and warned against "any knee-jerk legislative reaction that will serve to render the ICAC a second police force or crime commission". NSW premier Mike Baird stated that "NSW will continue to have a strong ICAC. And we will take every action necessary to ensure that's the case." Former ICAC Commissioner David Ipp, although criticising the Cunneen investigation, strongly supported retrospective legislation to restore
6364-447: The legislative intention" and to "the ordinary meaning of the words used in the section"; it urged the NSW government to legislate to broaden its powers retrospectively, so as to legalise its earlier actions as well as current investigations. However, the inspector of the ICAC, former Supreme Court judge David Levine QC , criticised the ICAC's response as a "blustering" statement by a "poor loser" and "an improper and dismissive attack on
6450-535: The monarchy as represented by the governor , the Legislative Assembly , and Legislative Council . The judicial branch consists of three general courts ( Local , District and Supreme Court ), and several specialist courts such as the Children's Court or Coroner's Court . New South Wales received statehood upon the federation of Australia in 1901, with the state's Constitution establishing
6536-541: The network operator to the LEA in an encrypted format over an IP-based VPN. The interception of traditional voice calls still often relies on the establishment of an ISDN channel that is set up at the time of the interception. As stated above, the ETSI architecture is equally applicable to IP-based services where IRI/CD is dependent on parameters associated with the traffic from a given application to be intercepted. For example, in
6622-471: The official's choice of action but would not have affected the official's probity in making that choice. The Court accepted that the alleged conduct of Cunneen, a senior public prosecutor , would have been in a private and not an official capacity. The Cunneen decision raised questions about whether ICAC exceeded its powers in some earlier and current high-profile corruption investigations. Nonetheless, in May 2015
6708-448: The option of taking the oath of allegiance to the Queen, her heirs and successors, in addition to the option of taking the pledge of loyalty. The change applies to members of Legislative Council, Legislative Assembly and Executive Council. The following individuals serve as government ministers, at the pleasure of the King, represented by the Governor of New South Wales. The government ministers are listed in order of seniority as listed on
6794-510: The review committee headed by Cabinet Secretary, which shall meet at least once in two months to review such cases. In case of State governments, such cases are reviewed by a committee headed by the Chief Secretary concerned. ·S.O dated 20.12.2018 will help in following ways: I. To ensure that any interception, monitoring or decryption of any information through any computer resource is done as per due process of law. II. Notification about
6880-399: The same is done as per due process of law and approval of competent authority i.e. Union Home Secretary. Most countries worldwide maintain LI requirements similar to those Europe and the U.S., and have moved to the ETSI handover standards. The Convention on Cybercrime requires such capabilities. As with many law enforcement tools, LI systems may be subverted for illicit purposes, producing
6966-422: The targets' calls. The introduction of packet-switched networks, softswitch technology, and server-based applications during the past two decades fundamentally altered how LI is undertaken. Lawful interception differs from the dragnet -type mass surveillance sometimes done by intelligence agencies , where all data passing a fiber-optic splice or other collection point is extracted for storage or filtering. It
7052-580: The technical processes behind lawful interception. One organization, ETSI , has been a major driver in lawful interception standards not only for Europe, but worldwide. This architecture attempts to define a systematic and extensible means by which network operators and law enforcement agents (LEAs) can interact, especially as networks grow in sophistication and scope of services. Note this architecture applies to not only “traditional” wireline and wireless voice calls, but to IP-based services such as voice over IP , email, instant messaging, etc. The architecture
7138-468: The treaty itself has signatories worldwide and provides a global scope. Individual countries have different legal requirements relating to lawful interception. The Global Lawful Interception Industry Forum lists many of these, as does the Council of Europe secretariat. For example, in the United Kingdom the law is known as RIPA (Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act), in the United States there
7224-432: The usual email address spoofing that often takes place (e.g., spoofing of source address). Voice-over-IP likewise has its own IRI, including data derived from Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) messages that are used to set up and tear down a VOIP call. ETSI LI Technical Committee work today is primarily focussed on developing the new Retained Data Handover and next-generation network specifications, as well as perfecting
7310-487: Was applied to public broadband networks Internet access and Voice over IP services that are interconnected to the Public Switched Telephone Network (PSTN). In the 2000s, surveillance focus turned to terrorism. NSA warrantless surveillance outside the supervision of the FISA court caused considerable controversy. It was revealed in 2013 mass surveillance disclosures that since 2007,
7396-512: Was victim to unlawful search and seizure. Despite the court’s ruling, the evidence gathered from the unwarranted search was used as evidence in trial, as the court claimed that the police were acting in good faith. In accordance to the ruling, the court proclaims that a warrant is not needed if: The second court case to refer to is from the same year but in December. Essentially, the Supreme Court of Canada argued that police are allowed access to
#111888