99-517: Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-earth is a collection of stories and essays by J. R. R. Tolkien that were never completed during his lifetime, but were edited by his son Christopher Tolkien and published in 1980. Many of the tales within are retold in The Silmarillion , albeit in modified forms; the work also contains a summary of the events of The Lord of the Rings told from
198-661: A capella vocal. Other famous unfinished rock albums include the Who 's rock opera Lifehouse , Bob Dylan 's The Basement Tapes , Jimi Hendrix 's First Rays of the New Rising Sun and Jeff Buckley 's My Sweetheart the Drunk . All have been released, in whole or part, in various posthumous forms in the ensuing years, Lifehouse being another case of using demos to present a completed work. Several artists have found that some of their studio work have been leaked onto
297-559: A commentary to help readers grasp how they fitted in to his father's Middle-earth legendarium. Olson comments that the book's commercial success demonstrated the existence of a market for more of Tolkien's writings, opening up a route to publication of The History of Middle-earth . The Christian philosopher Peter Kreeft wrote in Christianity & Literature that many readers had felt disappointed by Unfinished Tales , as some had felt about The Silmarillion . Perry Bramlett adds that
396-567: A cycle of near-perpetual construction, with work lasting for decades or even centuries. Antoni Gaudí 's Sagrada Família in Barcelona has been under construction since 1882. Work was delayed by the Spanish Civil War , during which part of the original models were destroyed. After the restoration of these models, the works are still in progress and the prevision is that the building will be finished in 2026. Today, even with portions of
495-479: A final version in 1977. In 1980, Christopher Tolkien published another posthumous collection of his father's unfinished work, appropriately entitled Unfinished Tales . Between 1982 and 1996, he published twelve volumes of The History of Middle-earth , a substantial portion of which is unfinished and incomplete drafts. In 2007, Christopher Tolkien published another novel from his father entitled The Children of Húrin . Like The Silmarillion , Christopher assembled
594-402: A less personal perspective. The collection received a cautious welcome from scholars and critics. They noted Christopher Tolkien's warning that a good knowledge of the background was needed to gain much from the stories. Others noted that the stories were among the best of Tolkien's writing; Warren Dunn expressed a wish for the whole of the history in such a format. The book, with its commentary,
693-478: A little more in your face". Richard Carpenter released several tracks decades after his sister Karen died in 1983, leaving a multitude of unfinished work. One track, released on the "Interpretations" compilation album in 1995, included Karen's lead vocal for the song " Tryin' to Get the Feeling Again " which had previously been recorded and released by Barry Manilow . The lead had been lost for years on
792-523: A mislabelled tape. Strings, piano, and backup singers were added to the sound of Karen's lead vocal, while Richard left the sound of her turning the lead sheet over in the finished product. Another track was Karen's cover " The Rainbow Connection ", which had been written by Kenny Ascher and Paul Williams for Jim Henson to sing as Kermit the Frog in The Muppet Movie (1979). Recording it only
891-406: A portrait, it may be halted because of their unavailability. Projects that are too grandiose might never have been finished, while others should be feasible but their creator's continual unhappiness with them leads to abandonment. Unfinished works by popular authors and artists may still be made public, sometimes in the state they were in when work was halted. Alternatively, another artist may finish
990-567: A private guest audience on 27 September 2012 at the Netherlands Film Festival in Utrecht, Netherlands. Some films have been completed despite such problems. A famous example is Bruce Lee 's Game of Death . Lee died during the filming, and the rest of the filming was finished with Tai Chung Kim , a Lee look-alike, acting as a double, and Yuen Biao acting as a stunt double for action scenes. His son, Brandon Lee , suffered
1089-407: A producer or director) can often be replaced, it is much more difficult to change to a different actor if many of the scenes have already been filmed, or if a character is strongly associated with an actor's physique, voice, or demeanor, or special skills. For example, Dark Blood was cancelled 80% of the way through filming due to the death of its star River Phoenix . However, the film premiered to
SECTION 10
#17327758569801188-712: A proposed replacement for a part of the palace, but financial constraints prevented construction. Computer technology has allowed for 3D representations of projects to be shown before they are built. In some cases the construction is never started and the computer model is the nearest that anyone can ever get to seeing the finished piece. For example, in 1999 Kent Larson's exhibition " Unbuilt Ruins: Digital Interpretations of Eight Projects by Louis I. Kahn " showed computer images of designs completed by noted architect Louis Kahn but never built. Computer simulations can also be used to create prototypes of engineering projects and test them before they are actually made; this has allowed
1287-401: A roof, but at Milan, where the painting lies, it shows some Latin that is half done. Robert William Buss left unfinished his most famous painting, Dickens' Dream , just as Charles Dickens himself had left a novel half-complete at his death. Depending on the medium involved, it can be difficult for another artist to complete an unfinished artwork without damaging it. Some artists completed
1386-638: A similar fate when it tried to split its adaptation of the final novel, Allegiant , into two parts, similar to how it was done for the final book of the Harry Potter book series, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows and the final book of the The Hunger Games trilogy, Mockingjay , but the critical and commercial failure of the first part, The Divergent Series: Allegiant , ultimately discouraged efforts to produce and release
1485-538: A starkly contrasting general outlook on Persian influence in the events depicted. Artists leave behind incomplete work for a variety of reasons. A piece may not be completed if the subject becomes unavailable, such as in the changing of a landscape or the death of a person being painted. Elizabeth Shoumatoff 's Unfinished Portrait of 32nd U.S. president Franklin D. Roosevelt was started around noon on 12 April 1945 but left unfinished when Roosevelt died later that day. In other instances, outside circumstances can prevent
1584-516: A template to construct a version of the Beach Boys album from the original Smile Sessions in 2011. Janis Joplin died of a drug overdose during the recording sessions for Pearl . The album was released three months after her death with ten songs, including two apparently incomplete recordings. "Buried Alive in the Blues" was released as an instrumental, and " Mercedes Benz " was released as an
1683-591: A third-person, limited-knowledge narrator, supposedly written from Bilbo's diary after the adventure. Where Bilbo is interested in food and comfort, and sometimes other familiar things such as riddles, she writes, Gandalf is concerned with defending the West against the Shadow ( Sauron ). Further, the Quest actually pretends to be Frodo's memory of a conversation he had with Gandalf, rather than Gandalf actually writing, so there
1782-530: A total of 632 years. It is not only buildings that have failed during the construction phase. In the 1920s, the White Star Line hired the shipbuilders Harland and Wolff to build the first 1,000-foot-long (300 m) ocean liner , with the planned name of Oceanic . However, a dispute between the companies halted the construction, then the Great Depression put an end to it; eventually
1881-476: A year later, Richard claims that Karen just did not like the song and that was why it was omitted from their 1981 album, Made in America . A toy piano, choir, and strings were added against Karen's vocals. The song was released in 2001 on the album As Time Goes By , considered the final studio album of the duo. Films may not be completed for several reasons, with some being shelved during different stages of
1980-423: Is Mozart 's Requiem , famous in part because of the numerous myths and legends that surround its creation and in part because of Mozart's prestige. At the time of his death, Mozart had fully orchestrated only the first movement, leaving nine further movements in varying states of completion. Franz Xaver Süssmayr , an acquaintance of Mozart, finished the nine incomplete movements and wrote four more. In addition to
2079-518: Is a professor of philosophy at Boston College and The King's College . A convert to Catholicism , he is the author of over eighty books on Christian philosophy , theology and apologetics . He also formulated, together with Ronald K. Tacelli , Twenty Arguments for the Existence of God in their Handbook of Christian Apologetics . Kreeft was born March 16, 1937, in Paterson, New Jersey ,
SECTION 20
#17327758569802178-444: Is as well-crafted as any of Tolkien's writings, and that readers who found The Silmarillion "a little too high and distant" would welcome it. The science fiction author Warren Dunn, writing in 1993, described the book as engaging, and that every section contained "something of interest", but he cautioned that it required "an intimate knowledge" of The Silmarillion , The Lord of the Rings , and its appendices "for full enjoyment" of
2277-404: Is distinguishable from "incomplete work", which can be a work that was finished but is no longer in its complete form. There are many reasons that a work is not completed. Works are usually stopped when their creator dies, although some, aware of their failing health, make sure that they set up the project for completion. If the work involves other people, such as a cast of actors or the subject of
2376-488: Is followed by a long series of notes explaining inconsistencies and obscure points. As with The Silmarillion , Tolkien's son Christopher edited and published Unfinished Tales before he had finished his study of the materials in his father's archive. Unfinished Tales provides more detailed information about characters, events and places mentioned only briefly in The Lord of the Rings . Versions of such tales, including
2475-623: Is the longest epic poem in the English language. Honoré de Balzac , the French novelist, completed nearly 100 pieces for his novel sequence La Comédie humaine , but a planned 48 more were never finished. Notes and plot outlines left behind by an author may allow a successor to complete a novel or series of novels. Frank Herbert left behind extensive notes related to his Dune universe , which led to son Brian Herbert and science fiction author Kevin J. Anderson 's completing several prequels to
2574-568: Is the most arrogant, blasphemous and wicked claim imaginable, if it is not true, or else that she is just what she claims to be." According to Kreeft's personal account, his conversion to Catholic Christianity was influenced by, among other things, Gothic architecture and Thomistic philosophy , the writings of St. John of the Cross , the logic of asking saints to pray for us, and a visit to St. Patrick's Cathedral in New York City when he
2673-556: Is the most famous, but Anton Bruckner 's Ninth Symphony is performed without a finale, and in Karl Amadeus Hartmann 's Gesangsszene , the final words of Jean Giraudoux 's text, left unset at the composer's death, are simply spoken by the soloist. Some other well-known examples of unfinished works completed by other hands include: Peter Schickele parodied the concept in his "Unbegun Symphony", which contains only movements III and IV because, as Schickele put it, "I
2772-467: Is uncertainty about how much of what Gandalf said may have been recorded. And when Frodo asks if he has now heard the full story, Gandalf replies "Of course not", so the narration is explicitly incomplete. From the reader's point of view, the point of the story is to explain how The Hobbit fits into the background of The Lord of the Rings , or more precisely, in Barkley's words, "why Bilbo was included in
2871-520: The Solar System (Earth was never included), 82 years after it was originally performed. In August 2006 Pluto was officially demoted to a dwarf planet , meaning that Holst's original work now more accurately represents the Solar System. Some very famous 20th century operas have been left incomplete at their composers' deaths. Giacomo Puccini left the finale of Turandot unfinished and
2970-519: The basilica incomplete, it is still the most popular tourist destination in Barcelona with 1.5 million visitors every year. Gaudí spent 40 years of his life overseeing the project and is buried in the crypt. Also in Barcelona, construction on the Barcelona Cathedral started in 1298, but its dome and central tower were only finished in 1913, 615 years later. Germany's Cologne Cathedral took even longer to complete, from 1248 to 1880,
3069-537: The canvas before work begins, and sculptures are frequently planned using a maquette . These works-in-progress can be as sought after as (or even more sought after than) completed works by highly regarded artists because they help reveal the process of creating a work of art. Gian Lorenzo Bernini , a sculptor from the Baroque period, made his bozzetti (an Italian term for the prototype sculpture) from wax or baked terracotta to show those that had commissioned him how
Unfinished Tales - Misplaced Pages Continue
3168-542: The follies of the late 16th to 18th century. There are many reasons for construction works being halted. Amongst others, they include a changing financial climate, unforeseen structural weaknesses, and a dramatic shift in the politics of a country. Work on the Palace of Soviets , a project to construct the world's largest building in Moscow, was halted when the city was attacked during World War II . Some buildings are in
3267-532: The 2012 film An Unexpected Journey as dialogue, particularly in the meeting held in Bilbo's house. In their view, the Quest "closely and thoroughly connects the action of The Hobbit with the larger, cosmic concerns of its sequel, showing how the Dwarves' struggle to regain their homeland became crucial in frustrating Sauron's plan to attack Lorien and Rivendell ." They explain that the quest had to succeed, or
3366-521: The Beatles led to " Free as a Bird " and " Real Love " being released in the mid-1990s after the band members pieced together incomplete recordings by the deceased John Lennon . Both songs reached the top five in the British singles chart. In 1969, after releasing their self-titled album the year before, the Beatles began working on an album entitled Get Back , which was never completed. Most of
3465-668: The Existence of God". Kreeft converted to Catholicism during his college years. A key turning point came when he was asked by a Calvinist professor to investigate the claims of the Catholic Church that it traced itself to the early Church. He said that, on his own, he "discovered in the early Church such Catholic elements as the centrality of the Eucharist , the real presence , prayers to saints , devotion to Mary , an insistence on visible unity, and apostolic succession ." The "central and deciding" factor for his conversion
3564-497: The Internet before their album has been completed. System of a Down 's 2002 follow-up to Toxicity , untitled at the time, was leaked onto the Internet as MP3 files. When the album was released under the title Steal This Album! the songs were significantly different from the work-in-progress, with different titles, lyrics and even melodies. There were some reports that the changes were a direct result of negative feedback about
3663-490: The Süssmayr version, a number of alternative completions have been developed by composers and musicologists in the 20th and 21st centuries. Gustav Mahler 's Symphony No. 10 was incomplete, with only drafts, sketches, and two mostly orchestrated movements existing at the composer's death. Several people have "completed" it with varying degrees of success, the most notable of these being Deryck Cooke 's "performing version of
3762-670: The actions described in The Lord of the Rings could not have occurred. Jackson used the connections, they state; for instance, making Saruman order Gandalf to stop the quest, and making Gandalf refuse, supported by Galadriel . Unfinished creative work An unfinished creative work is a painting, novel, musical composition, or other creative work , that has not been brought to a completed state. Its creator may have chosen not to finish it, deferred its completion indefinitely, or may have been prevented from doing so by circumstances beyond their control, such as death. Such pieces are often
3861-562: The architectures of modern computer systems. Still in computer science, the seminal work on algorithms, The Art of Computer Programming by Donald Knuth , has had only the first three of its seven planned volumes written. The first genuine historiographical work, the History of the Peloponnesian War by Thucydides , was undergoing a major revision by the author at the time of his death, so different sections of it reflect
3960-513: The arguments in this debate to create the Handbook of Christian Apologetics with then undergraduate student Ronald K. Tacelli. In 1971, Kreeft published an article titled " Zen In Heidegger 's ' Gelassenheit '" in the peer-reviewed journal International Philosophical Quarterly , of Fordham University. In 1994, he was an endorser of the document " Evangelicals and Catholics Together ". He also formulated, with R. Tacelli, "Twenty Arguments for
4059-410: The band members as well as between the band members and the record company executives, the band abandoned the project after completing numerous recordings slated for the project (which were included in later, less ambitious albums). In 2004, Wilson and writing partner Van Dyke Parks went into the studio, and newly recorded the material and released it as a completed solo album. That album was used as
Unfinished Tales - Misplaced Pages Continue
4158-461: The book is not for the reader new to Tolkien, nor even one who has read only The Hobbit "or perhaps some or even all of the Lord of the Rings ." He notes Christopher Tolkien's warning that the stories "constitute no whole" and that much of the content "will be found unrewarding" to those without a good knowledge of Lord of the Rings . More positively, he cites David Bratman 's comment that much of it
4257-427: The book's title, but "a taste of some of the descriptive and historical underpinnings of those heretofore uncharted vistas", and that indeed he suggested he might "dive even deeper into the history of his father's legendarium ", as he eventually did with his 12-volume The History of Middle-earth . The Tolkien scholar Corey Olsen notes that Christopher Tolkien chose to present the incomplete tales as they were, adding
4356-604: The book. He commented that "I really do wish we could have seen the whole history like this, even if it took up twelve volumes to get through the first, second and third ages before the Lord of the Rings !" Christine Barkley, writing in Mythlore , notes that the point of view in The Quest of Erebor is Gandalf's, sharply contrasting with Bilbo's far less well-informed point of view in The Hobbit . That book, she states, uses
4455-462: The chance to complete their work before their death, and the recordings that are made public may be somewhat different from what had originally been intended. From a Basement on the Hill by Elliott Smith was released posthumously in 2004 with comments from the initial album producer saying that "[t]he record he would have delivered would [have] had more songs, would have had different mixes and [been]
4554-483: The composer, are nonetheless augmented for non-musical reasons. In May 2000 composer Colin Matthews premiered his "completion" of Gustav Holst 's The Planets , whereby he composed a new movement for the ninth planet Pluto , giving it the name "Pluto, The Renewer". When Holst had written the original piece Pluto had not been discovered, and this addition therefore updated the suite to represent all known planets of
4653-581: The demise of Rumi . The Persian Bayán , a scripture from Bábism , was left unfinished when the Báb died. There have been some claims that the text has been completed by other people, though the Báb stated that it would be finished by [him] whom God shall make manifest. St. Thomas Aquinas abandoned his great work the Summa Theologica in 1273, citing a mystical experience during Mass. Its arguments for
4752-575: The design process to be more successful and efficient. Even without being constructed, many architectural designs and ideas have had a lasting influence. The Russian constructivism movement started in 1913 and was taught in the Bauhaus and other architecture schools, leading to numerous architects integrating it into their style. Before the advent of recording technology, all musical compositions were sketched on manuscripts. Often these manuscripts are roughly sketched, with drafting work scribbled over
4851-475: The draft." Some compositions are finished "in the style of" the original composer, with someone who is highly familiar with the work adopting the same writing style and continuing the musical tone. Johann Sebastian Bach 's The Art of Fugue , which was broken off abruptly during Contrapunctus XIV , probably shortly before the death of the composer, was first published in the mid 18th century. Many reconstructions have been written, but in 1991 Zoltán Göncz used
4950-468: The dwarves' plans at Gandalf's suggestion." Frank P. Riga and colleagues, also in Mythlore , write that Peter Jackson used the Quest to enrich the story when transforming The Hobbit from novel to film for his 2013 film adaptation, The Desolation of Smaug . Among other things, the film opens with the meeting between Gandalf and Thorin at The Prancing Pony . Elements of Gandalf's motivations and previous discussions with Thorin also find their way into
5049-421: The eventual addition of further material. von Neumann never completed it, as by that time its distribution had already influenced an explosion in postwar computer development. Its elaboration of the stored program concept and formalization of the logical design of computer architecture—ideas not all of which were original to von Neumann but which he first expressed in the mathematical language he favoured—endure in
SECTION 50
#17327758569805148-399: The execution of an otherwise "finished" artwork: Leonardo da Vinci developed sketches and models for the 24-foot-tall (7.3 m) "Gran Cavallo" horse statue but the bronze to cast the sculpture was diverted to make cannons. Five hundred years later, two full-size sculptures were completed based on Leonardo's work. Technically his The Last Supper is unfinished. In most pictures it shows
5247-454: The existence of God continue to exert influence in philosophy and Christian theology more than 700 years later. In Greek philosophy, Plato 's Critias was unfinished when Plato died at age 80. The most influential document in computer science was John von Neumann 's First Draft of a Report on the EDVAC , a 101-page manuscript dating from 1946 and littered with ellipses and spaces for
5346-484: The fifth volume, Redwood , in 2018, when poor sales forced its publisher, Pantheon Books , to drop support for it. Another famous example of an unfinished book series is George R. R. Martin 's dark epic high fantasy series A Song of Ice and Fire , which was planned to last seven books, but only five were published as of 2024 , due to the sixth book, The Winds of Winter , remaining in development hell after numerous delays since he began writing it circa 2010. When
5445-646: The final piece was intended to look. Eleven of these bozzetti were displayed in an exhibition at the Art Institute of Chicago in 2004. Some museums specialise in collections of maquettes, such as the Museo dei Bozzetti in Pietrasanta , Italy. During the Renaissance , Donatello made sculptures that appeared unfinished by only sculpting part of the block, leaving the figure appearing to be stuck within
5544-482: The final scenes, with no clear outline for the last third of the story. The book was still published and the story can be followed despite the incomplete artwork. Many construction or engineering projects have remained unfinished at various stages of development. The work may be finished as a blueprint or whiteprint and never be realised, or be abandoned during construction. There are numerous unfinished buildings that remain partially constructed in countries around
5643-511: The form of a permutation fugue to make a strong argument as to the structure of the Fugue to come. (See external links.) Sir Edward Elgar was composing a Symphony No. 3 at the time of his death and left 130 pages of sketches. These sketches were put into a reasonable order, orchestrated in the style of Elgar, and elaborated by Anthony Payne . Payne's reconstruction has been played numerous times to great acclaim. Some works, deemed complete by
5742-488: The leaked material. Some artists will try to ensure that their work is completed (as much as possible) before their health prevents them from continuing. Johnny Cash , aware of his failing health, made sure that he recorded the vocals for 60 more songs, with the music being completed after his death. These songs were compiled by producer Rick Rubin and released posthumously as American V: A Hundred Highways and American VI: Ain't No Grave . However, not all artists get
5841-494: The material. He called this technique " non finito ", and it has been used by several artists since then. In the age of mass media, incomplete work can reach an audience due to sheer demand for material by the artist. Tintin and Alph-Art , the 24th comic in Hergé 's popular The Adventures of Tintin series, was unfinished at his death. Though he had illustrated a significant part of the book, several sketched panels remained in
5940-576: The missing music had to be provided by Franco Alfano for the premiere in 1926. Recently, Luciano Berio composed an alternative ending. Alban Berg had not yet finished orchestrating the third and final act of his opera Lulu at the time of his death in 1935. Due to objections from his widow, it was not until 1979 that a full version was performed, with the orchestration for Act 3 being completed by Friedrich Cerha using Berg's sketches. Other musical works which are unfinished but performable, are simply given in their incomplete state. Schubert's symphony
6039-481: The narrative fragments were modified to connect them into a consistent and coherent work, the Unfinished Tales are presented as Tolkien left them, with little more than names changed (the author having had a confusing habit of trying out different names for a character while writing a draft). Thus some of these are incomplete stories, while others are collections of information about Middle-earth . Each tale
SECTION 60
#17327758569806138-652: The novel from various incomplete drafts. The size of a project can be such that a piece of literature is never finished. Geoffrey Chaucer never completed The Canterbury Tales to the extensive length that he originally intended. Chaucer had, however, already written much of the work at the time of his death, and the Canterbury Tales are considered to be a seminal work despite the unfinished status. English poet Edmund Spenser originally intended The Faerie Queene to consist of 12 books; even at its unfinished state—6 books were published before Spenser's death—it
6237-443: The original manuscript. Novels can remain unfinished because the author continually rewrites the story. When enough material exists, someone else can compile and combine the work, creating a finished story from several different drafts. Mark Twain 's The Mysterious Stranger was written in three different versions over a period of 20 years, none of which were completed. Twain biographer and literary executor Albert Paine combined
6336-517: The origins of Gandalf and the other Istari (Wizards), the death of Isildur and the loss of the One Ring in the Gladden Fields , and the founding of the kingdom of Rohan , help expand knowledge about Middle-earth. The commercial success of Unfinished Tales demonstrated that the demand for Tolkien's stories several years after his death was not only present but growing. Encouraged by
6435-471: The paintings of their mentors, such as Giulio Romano is believed to have done on Raphael 's Transfiguration , and Titian on Giorgione 's Sleeping Venus . Instead of completing another artist's masterpiece, particularly when many years have passed, unfinished works frequently inspire others to create their own version. Michelangelo left several unfinished sculptures and paintings, with sketches and partially completed paintings inspiring others. If
6534-477: The philosophy faculty of the Department of Philosophy of Boston College in 1965. He has debated several academics in issues related to God's existence. Shortly after he began teaching at Boston College, he was challenged to a debate on the existence of God between himself and Paul Breines , an atheist and history professor, which was attended by a majority of undergraduate students. Kreeft later used many of
6633-405: The piece. In some fields work may appear unfinished, but is actually finished, such as Donatello 's " non finito " technique in sculpture. Many acclaimed authors have left work incomplete. Some such pieces have been published posthumously , either in their incomplete state or after being finished by somebody else. It is the job of literary executors to take charge of the work of a writer after
6732-497: The popular series. Mervyn Peake , author of the Gormenghast novels, meant to write a complete biography of the main character, Titus, but died after only completing three books in the series. The Familiar , a book series written by Mark Z. Danielewski and ambitiously planned to span 27 installments that are each over 800 pages long with interlocking characters and stories, prematurely stopped at less than 20% complete after
6831-741: The portion of the keel already constructed was broken up and used in building two smaller but similar ships, the MV Britannic and MV Georgic . In the 1970s the Hoan Bridge in Milwaukee , Wisconsin was out of use for five years after its construction when the connecting roads were not completed. In the 1980s, during the Iran–Iraq War , Iraqi president Saddam Hussein commissioned the Babylon project . The supergun design by Gerald Bull
6930-561: The possible missing content. Some theologians consider the Gospel of Mark , in its existing form, incomplete; the text after 16:8 is probably not original, thus creating speculation whether the author was arrested or died suddenly, or whether the end of the gospel could have broken away from the rest of the gospel as it was handed to the next person. The Sunni Islamic classic Qur'anic commentary, Mafatihu-l-Ghayb, better known as Tafseer Al-Kabeer ( Tafsir al-Kabir (al-Razi) ) by Fakhr al-Din al-Razi
7029-409: The production. Arrive Alive was scrapped after a week of filming when the comedy was not living up to the screenplay. Shelving a film without it ever being released can be very expensive for the studios, with Arrive Alive costing $ 7 million. With so many people involved in filmmaking it is possible for a film to remain incomplete because of an injury or death. While a member of the crew (even
7128-532: The result, Christopher Tolkien embarked upon the more ambitious twelve-volume work entitled The History of Middle-earth , which encompasses nearly the entire corpus of his father's writings about Middle-earth. The scholar Paul H. Kocher , reviewing Unfinished Tales in Mythlore , noted that all the stories are linked to either The Silmarillion , Akallabeth or The Lord of the Rings , and extensively annotated, mainly by Christopher Tolkien. In Kocher's view,
7227-400: The same fate: he died after filming most of The Crow , but the remaining scenes were played by stunt double Chad Stahelski , with Lee's face digitally composited onto the double. Continued delays can prevent a film from ever being completed. Something's Got to Give was a 1962 film with a difficult production history, which included the firing of leading lady Marilyn Monroe . She
7326-697: The second part or close out the story whatsoever. There is debate whether Stanley Kubrick 's last film Eyes Wide Shut was complete at the time of the director's death , three months before the movie was due to be released, as Kubrick had a history of continuing to edit his films up until the last minute, and in some cases even after initial public screenings. Peter Kreeft Defunct Newspapers Journals TV channels Websites Other Economics Gun rights Identity politics Nativist Religion Watchdog groups Youth/student groups Miscellaneous Other Peter John Kreeft ( / k r eɪ f t / ; born March 16, 1937)
7425-419: The series' television adaptation, Game of Thrones , finished adapting the first five books over the course of five seasons while Winds was incomplete, Martin was able to give the series showrunners an outline on what Winds ' story was meant to be like, so that they could continue the series uninterrupted and mix in some original content instead of disappointing fans with a delay of the final seasons of
7524-469: The series. Some works are presented as separate sections, each written at different times. This can lead to a piece appearing complete while the author actually intended for it to continue, or where other authors try to fake their own writing as part of the work. The first four cantos of Lord Byron 's narrative poem Don Juan were written in 1818 and 1819, with a further twelve completed and published before his death in 1824. Numerous "continuations" of
7623-603: The son of John and Lucy Kreeft. He graduated in 1955 from Eastern Christian High School , where his class hymn was sung at graduation ceremonies. Raised in Wyckoff, New Jersey , he took his BA at Calvin College (1959) and an MA at Fordham University (1961). He completed his doctoral studies in 1965, also at Fordham, where he completed a dissertation under the direction of W. Norris Clarke . He subsequently completed his post-graduate studies at Yale University . Kreeft joined
7722-470: The songs from Get Back were eventually used on the Let It Be album. The Beach Boys ' Smile is considered the most legendary unreleased album in the history of popular music. Recorded in 1966 and 1967, Smile was to be the followup to the album Pet Sounds (1966), but due to a plethora of reasons including project leader Brian Wilson 's deteriorating mental health and increased friction among
7821-420: The stories and published his version six years after Twain's death. Similarly, J. R. R. Tolkien continuously rewrote The Silmarillion throughout his lifetime; a definitive version was still uncompiled at the time of his death, with some sections very fragmented. His son, Christopher Tolkien , invited fantasy fiction writer Guy Gavriel Kay to reconstruct some parts of the book, and they eventually published
7920-414: The stories contain "some of Tolkien's best writing" (and he summarized them in some detail), though he found much of interest in the editorial material also. He noted the revised map with the additional place names used in the tales, and that the book does not address Tolkien's poetry . The independent scholar Douglas C. Kane writes that Christopher Tolkien chose to include not just narrative tales, despite
8019-571: The story from the original book. Multi-part films like the animated The Lord of the Rings and entire film series can also end up being unfinished, in spite of ambitious plans. 20th Century Fox 's attempt to adapt Rick Riordan 's Percy Jackson & the Olympians series stopped after the second book, Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters , when plans to adapt the third book, The Titan's Curse , fell through. Lionsgate Films ' plan to adapt Veronica Roth 's Divergent book trilogy also faced
8118-542: The story had been published by various publishing houses even between issues of the story, along with several fake conclusions. Byron had intended to continue the story, as evidenced by the find of the 17th canto after his death, but it is not clear how long the poem would continue or how it would conclude. It is still regarded as one of his greatest achievements. Charles Dickens was writing The Mystery of Edwin Drood in monthly installments when he died, completing just six of
8217-505: The studios. His death on 10 October 1985 came while he was working on The Other Side of the Wind and The Dreamers ; the former was completed in 2018 by Peter Bogdanovich . Animated films, though less vulnerable to problems such as the death of an actor, can still fail to be completed. The Thief and the Cobbler was a twenty-six-year animated film project by Richard Williams which
8316-408: The subject of speculation as to what the finished piece would have been like had the creator completed the work. Sometimes artworks are finished by others and released posthumously . Unfinished works have had profound influences on their genres and have inspired others in their own projects. The term can also refer to ongoing work which could eventually be finished (i.e. the creator is still living) and
8415-538: The third designer withdrew from the project. The fourth and final plan was completed and some infrastructure was prepared for the site, but Ludwig died before construction work began. The Palace of Whitehall , at the time the largest palace in Europe, was mostly destroyed by a fire in 1698. Sir Christopher Wren , most famous for his role in rebuilding several churches after the Great Fire of London in 1666, sketched
8514-483: The top of the music, and have been found in unordered piles. Many unfinished symphonies have been pieced together from these original manuscripts by other composers, after the original author's death, with some remaining incomplete until many decades later. One of the most famous examples of unfinished musical compositions is Franz Schubert 's Symphony No. 8 in B minor , or as it is more commonly known, The Unfinished Symphony . Another famous unfinished classical piece
8613-430: The twelve intended. The story surrounded the murder of the titular Edwin Drood; because the story was never finished, the murderer was never revealed. The book was still made into a film and a musical , with the latter having the unusual concept that the audience members vote for who they think is the murderer. Other famous unfinished works of literature include Hero and Leander by Christopher Marlowe (a completion
8712-568: The work is to be done on commission but is not finished it is commonly passed on to another artist. Leonardo da Vinci's work on the Adoration of the Magi for the monastery of San Donato was halted when he left Florence for Milan . Still requiring an altarpiece , the monks employed Filippino Lippi to create one. Both paintings now hang in the Uffizi gallery. Paintings are usually sketched on
8811-563: The world, some of which can be used in their incomplete state, while others remain as mere shells. An example of the latter is the Ryugyong Hotel in North Korea. If finished, it would become the tallest hotel in the world and the seventh largest building but is uninhabitable and will not be completed due to the cost and the poor structural integrity. Some projects are intentionally left with an unfinished appearance, particularly
8910-544: The writer's death. They must often decide what to do with incomplete work, using their own judgement if not given explicit instructions. In some cases, this can lead to something happening to the work that was not originally intended, such as the release of Franz Kafka 's unfinished writings by Max Brod when Kafka had wished for them to be destroyed. These works have become iconic in Western literature . The posthumous publication of some of Ernest Hemingway 's unfinished novels
9009-630: Was "the Church's claim to be the one Church historically founded by Christ." He reportedly applied C. S. Lewis's trilemma (that either Jesus is a lunatic, a liar, or the Lord): "I thought, just as Jesus made a claim about His identity that forces us into one of only two camps ... so the Catholic Church’s claim to be the one true Church, the Church Christ founded, forces us to say either that this
9108-425: Was born too late to write the first two movements." Since recording equipment has been an integral part of writing music it has been possible to use the original master tapes and demos to construct a song from the parts that had already been completed. Many demos are released officially if the artist has been unable (or unwilling) to complete it, or made available as a bootleg recording . The continued popularity of
9207-668: Was commercially successful, indicating a market for more of Tolkien's work and leading to the 12-volume The History of Middle-earth . On "The Quest of Erebor" in Part Three, Christine Barkley comments that the perspective is the knowledgeable Gandalf 's, contrasting sharply with the Hobbit Bilbo Baggins 's narrower point of view in The Hobbit . Peter Jackson used the story to enrich the narrative for his 2013 film The Desolation of Smaug . Unlike The Silmarillion , also published posthumously (in 1977), for which
9306-481: Was later rehired but died before filming started; without the delay the film might have been completed. In Orson Welles 's lifetime his unfinished films became legendary. For decades he worked on a version of Don Quixote , and he claimed that the film could be finished despite the deaths of his two leading actors. Citizen Kane remains one of the only films that was released as Welles intended, with most of his other films remaining incomplete or being changed by
9405-649: Was left unfinished and it was finished by either Qadi Shahab-ud-deen bin Khaleel al-Khauli, of Damascus (died 639 AH) or Shaikh Najm-ud-deen Ahmad bin Al-Qamooli (died 777 AH) as mentioned in Kashf-az-Zunoon. The Masnavi , the most famous poem in Sunni Islamic Sufi poetry by Rumi was left unfinished and it was later finished by Mufti Ilahi Baksh Kandhlawi about five hundred years after
9504-454: Was met with controversy. Several books were published, but it has been suggested that it is not within the jurisdiction of Hemingway's relatives or publishers to determine whether these works should be made available to the public. For example, scholars often disapprovingly note that the version of The Garden of Eden published by Charles Scribner's Sons in 1986, though not a revision of Hemingway's original words, nonetheless omits two-thirds of
9603-466: Was never fully constructed after Bull's assassination in March 1990. Many projects do not get to the construction phase and are halted during or after planning. Ludwig II of Bavaria commissioned several designs for Castle Falkenstein , with the fourth plan being vastly different from the first. The first two designs were turned down, one because of costs and one because the design displeased Ludwig, and
9702-1098: Was provided by George Chapman ), Dream of the Red Chamber by Gao E (Chapter 80–120), Dead Souls by Nikolai Gogol , Bouvard et Pécuchet by Gustave Flaubert , Weir of Hermiston by Robert Louis Stevenson , The Living Corpse by Leo Tolstoy , The Good Soldier Švejk by Jaroslav Hašek , Suite française by Irène Némirovsky , Answered Prayers by Truman Capote , The Last Tycoon by F. Scott Fitzgerald , Messias by Väinö Linna , Uncertain Times by Richard Yates , Sanditon by Jane Austen , Mount Analogue by René Daumal , The Pale King by David Foster Wallace , The Final Unfinished Voyage of Jack Aubrey by Patrick O'Brian , Georg Büchner 's Woyzeck , The Castle and Amerika by Franz Kafka, The Life of Klim Samgin by Maxim Gorky , The Man Without Qualities by Robert Musil and Le Premier Homme by Albert Camus . Religious works have also been left incomplete, leading to debates about
9801-410: Was taken away from him and completed by Fred Calvert . The workprint of the original film became available as a bootleg, and there have been several attempts to restore the film, most notably Garrett Gilchrist's "Recobbled" cut. The 1978 animated adaptation of The Lord of the Rings was not viewed by the studio as enough of a commercial success to warrant the funding of a sequel, thus not completing
#979020