85-403: Classically excluded but cladistically included: Australopithecus ( / ˌ ɒ s t r ə l ə ˈ p ɪ θ ɪ k ə s , - l oʊ -/ , OS -trə-lə- PITH -i-kəs, -loh- ; or ( / ɒ s ˌ t r ə l ə p ɪ ˈ θ iː k ə s / , os- TRA -lə-pi- THEE -kəs from Latin australis 'southern' and Ancient Greek πίθηκος (pithekos) 'ape')
170-421: A book published in 1950, cladistics did not flourish until its translation into English in 1966 (Lewin 1997). Today, cladistics is the most popular method for inferring phylogenetic trees from morphological data. In the 1990s, the development of effective polymerase chain reaction techniques allowed the application of cladistic methods to biochemical and molecular genetic traits of organisms, vastly expanding
255-413: A cladistic analysis is a cladogram – a tree -shaped diagram ( dendrogram ) that is interpreted to represent the best hypothesis of phylogenetic relationships. Although traditionally such cladograms were generated largely on the basis of morphological characters and originally calculated by hand, genetic sequencing data and computational phylogenetics are now commonly used in phylogenetic analyses, and
340-422: A coarse impression of the complexity. A more detailed account will give details about fractions of introgressions between groupings, and even geographic variations thereof. This has been used as an argument for the use of paraphyletic groupings, but typically other reasons are quoted. Horizontal gene transfer is the mobility of genetic info between different organisms that can have immediate or delayed effects for
425-429: A constant rate of mutation. However, hominin species dated to earlier than the date could call this into question. Sahelanthropus tchadensis , commonly called " Toumai ", is about seven million years old and Orrorin tugenensis lived at least six million years ago. Since little is known of them, they remain controversial among scientists since the molecular clock in humans has determined that humans and chimpanzees had
510-403: A genetic split at least a million years later. One theory suggests that the human and chimpanzee lineages diverged somewhat at first, then some populations interbred around one million years after diverging. The brains of most species of Australopithecus were roughly 35% of the size of a modern human brain with an endocranial volume average of 466 cc (28.4 cu in). Although this
595-460: A hypothesis, a clade can be rejected only if some groupings were explicitly excluded. It may then be found that the excluded group did actually descend from the last common ancestor of the group, and thus emerged within the group. ("Evolved from" is misleading, because in cladistics all descendants stay in the ancestral group). To keep only valid clades, upon finding that the group is paraphyletic this way, either such excluded groups should be granted to
680-489: A large number and variety of different kinds of characters are viewed as more robust than those based on more limited evidence. Mono-, para- and polyphyletic taxa can be understood based on the shape of the tree (as done above), as well as based on their character states. These are compared in the table below. Cladistics, either generally or in specific applications, has been criticized from its beginnings. Decisions as to whether particular character states are homologous ,
765-492: A level of dimorphism close to modern humans. According to A. Zihlman, Australopithecus body proportions closely resemble those of bonobos ( Pan paniscus ), leading evolutionary biologist Jeremy Griffith to suggest that bonobos may be phenotypically similar to Australopithecus . Furthermore, thermoregulatory models suggest that australopiths were fully hair covered, more like chimpanzees and bonobos, and unlike humans. The fossil record seems to indicate that Australopithecus
850-473: A lot of possible trees. Assigning names to each possible clade may not be prudent. Furthermore, established names are discarded in cladistics, or alternatively carry connotations which may no longer hold, such as when additional groups are found to have emerged in them. Naming changes are the direct result of changes in the recognition of mutual relationships, which often is still in flux, especially for extinct species. Hanging on to older naming and/or connotations
935-541: A noted interest in the Khoisan peoples, which included collecting their remains, including those of the recently deceased, as well as by digging up old graves. Broom first began collecting modern human remains in 1897, shortly after he moved to South Africa. In that year he collected the remains of three elderly " Hottentot " people that had died around Port Nolloth following a drought in the region. Broom stated that he "cut their heads off and boiled them in paraffin tins on
SECTION 10
#17327653830531020-475: A particular method. Datasets are tables consisting of molecular , morphological, ethological and/or other characters and a list of operational taxonomic units (OTUs), which may be genes, individuals, populations, species, or larger taxa that are presumed to be monophyletic and therefore to form, all together, one large clade; phylogenetic analysis infers the branching pattern within that clade. Different datasets and different methods, not to mention violations of
1105-720: A particular set of methods used in phylogenetic analysis, although it is now sometimes used to refer to the whole field. What is now called the cladistic method appeared as early as 1901 with a work by Peter Chalmers Mitchell for birds and subsequently by Robert John Tillyard (for insects) in 1921, and W. Zimmermann (for plants) in 1943. The term " clade " was introduced in 1958 by Julian Huxley after having been coined by Lucien Cuénot in 1940, "cladogenesis" in 1958, "cladistic" by Arthur Cain and Harrison in 1960, "cladist" (for an adherent of Hennig's school) by Ernst Mayr in 1965, and "cladistics" in 1966. Hennig referred to his own approach as "phylogenetic systematics". From
1190-457: A period, many branches may have radiated, and it may take hundreds of millions of years for them to have whittled down to just two. Only then one can theoretically assign proper last common ancestors of groupings which do not inadvertently include earlier branches. The process of true cladistic bifurcation can thus take a much more extended time than one is usually aware of. In practice, for recent radiations, cladistically guided findings only give
1275-444: A phylogenetic tree are used to justify decisions about character states, which are then used as evidence for the shape of the tree. Phylogenetics uses various forms of parsimony to decide such questions; the conclusions reached often depend on the dataset and the methods. Such is the nature of empirical science, and for this reason, most cladists refer to their cladograms as hypotheses of relationship. Cladograms that are supported by
1360-553: A powerful way to test hypotheses about cross-cultural relationships among folktales. Literature : Cladistic methods have been used in the classification of the surviving manuscripts of the Canterbury Tales , and the manuscripts of the Sanskrit Charaka Samhita . Historical linguistics : Cladistic methods have been used to reconstruct the phylogeny of languages using linguistic features. This
1445-400: A precondition of their being synapomorphies, have been challenged as involving circular reasoning and subjective judgements. Of course, the potential unreliability of evidence is a problem for any systematic method, or for that matter, for any empirical scientific endeavor at all. Transformed cladistics arose in the late 1970s in an attempt to resolve some of these problems by removing
1530-406: A priori assumptions about phylogeny from cladistic analysis, but it has remained unpopular. The cladistic method does not identify fossil species as actual ancestors of a clade. Instead, fossil taxa are identified as belonging to separate extinct branches. While a fossil species could be the actual ancestor of a clade, there is no way to know that. Therefore, a more conservative hypothesis is that
1615-671: A reputation as a " splitter " that has resulted in only around 57% of his holotypes still being considered valid as of 2003. In the following years, he and John T. Robinson made a series of spectacular finds, including fragments from six hominins in Sterkfontein , which they named Plesianthropus transvaalensis , popularly called Mrs. Ples , but which was later classified as an adult Australopithecus africanus , as well as more discoveries at sites in Kromdraai and Swartkrans . In 1937, Broom made his most famous discovery , by defining
1700-542: A response to fallback food availability. In leaner times, robust and gracile australopithecines may have turned to different low-quality foods (fibrous plants for the former, and hard food for the latter), but in more bountiful times, they had more variable and overlapping diets. In a 1979 preliminary microwear study of Australopithecus fossil teeth, anthropologist Alan Walker theorized that robust australopiths ate predominantly fruit ( frugivory ). A study in 2018 found non-carious cervical lesions , caused by acid erosion , on
1785-401: A side-branch, not distinguishing whether an actual ancestor of other groupings was found. The techniques and nomenclature of cladistics have been applied to disciplines other than biology. (See phylogenetic nomenclature .) Cladistics findings are posing a difficulty for taxonomy , where the rank and (genus-)naming of established groupings may turn out to be inconsistent. Cladistics is now
SECTION 20
#17327653830531870-907: Is a genus of early hominins that existed in Africa during the Pliocene and Early Pleistocene . The genera Homo (which includes modern humans ), Paranthropus , and Kenyanthropus evolved from some Australopithecus species. Australopithecus is a member of the subtribe Australopithecina , which sometimes also includes Ardipithecus , though the term "australopithecine" is sometimes used to refer only to members of Australopithecus . Species include A. garhi , A. africanus , A. sediba , A. afarensis , A. anamensis , A. bahrelghazali and A. deyiremeda . Debate exists as to whether some Australopithecus species should be reclassified into new genera, or if Paranthropus and Kenyanthropus are synonymous with Australopithecus , in part because of
1955-555: Is a 3.6 MYA fossil trackway in Laetoli , Tanzania, which bears a remarkable similarity to those of modern humans. The footprints have generally been classified as australopith, as they are the only form of prehuman hominins known to have existed in that region at that time. According to the Chimpanzee Genome Project , the human–chimpanzee last common ancestor existed about five to six million years ago, assuming
2040-565: Is a synapomorphy of the earliest taxa to be included within Tetrapoda: did all the earliest members of the Tetrapoda inherit four limbs from a common ancestor, whereas all other vertebrates did not, or at least not homologously? By contrast, for a group within the tetrapods, such as birds, having four limbs is a plesiomorphy. Using these two terms allows a greater precision in the discussion of homology, in particular allowing clear expression of
2125-427: Is ancestral to Homo and modern humans. It was once assumed that large brain size had been a precursor to bipedalism, but the discovery of Australopithecus with a small brain but developed bipedality upset this theory. Nonetheless, it remains a matter of controversy as to how bipedalism first emerged. The advantages of bipedalism were that it left the hands free to grasp objects (e.g., carry food and young), and allowed
2210-440: Is correct, then the last common ancestor of turtles and birds, at the branch near the ▼ lived earlier than the last common ancestor of lizards and birds, near the ♦ . Most molecular evidence , however, produces cladograms more like this: lizards turtles crocodilians birds If this is accurate, then the last common ancestor of turtles and birds lived later than the last common ancestor of lizards and birds. Since
2295-578: Is counter-productive, as they typically do not reflect actual mutual relationships precisely at all. E.g. Archaea, Asgard archaea, protists, slime molds, worms, invertebrata, fishes, reptilia, monkeys, Ardipithecus , Australopithecus , Homo erectus all contain Homo sapiens cladistically, in their sensu lato meaning. For originally extinct stem groups, sensu lato generally means generously keeping previously included groups, which then may come to include even living species. A pruned sensu stricto meaning
2380-466: Is heavily disputed. In 2003, Spanish writer Camilo José Cela Conde and evolutionary biologist Francisco J. Ayala proposed resurrecting the genus Praeanthropus to house Orrorin , A. afarensis , A. anamensis , A. bahrelghazali , and A. garhi , but this genus has been largely dismissed. With the apparent emergence of the genera Homo , Kenyanthropus , and Paranthropus in the genus Australopithecus, taxonomy runs into some difficulty, as
2465-464: Is more than the average endocranial volume of chimpanzee brains at 360 cc (22 cu in) the earliest australopiths ( A. anamensis ) appear to have been within the chimpanzee range, whereas some later australopith specimens have a larger endocranial volume than that of some early Homo fossils. Most species of Australopithecus were diminutive and gracile, usually standing 1.2 to 1.4 m (3 ft 11 in to 4 ft 7 in) tall. It
2550-500: Is often adopted instead, but the group would need to be restricted to a single branch on the stem. Other branches then get their own name and level. This is commensurate to the fact that more senior stem branches are in fact closer related to the resulting group than the more basal stem branches; that those stem branches only may have lived for a short time does not affect that assessment in cladistics. The comparisons used to acquire data on which cladograms can be based are not limited to
2635-492: Is possible that they exhibited a considerable degree of sexual dimorphism , males being larger than females. In modern populations, males are on average a mere 15% larger than females, while in Australopithecus , males could be up to 50% larger than females by some estimates. However, the degree of sexual dimorphism is debated due to the fragmentary nature of australopith remains. One paper finds that A. afarensis had
Australopithecus - Misplaced Pages Continue
2720-504: Is similar to the traditional comparative method of historical linguistics, but is more explicit in its use of parsimony and allows much faster analysis of large datasets ( computational phylogenetics ). Textual criticism or stemmatics : Cladistic methods have been used to reconstruct the phylogeny of manuscripts of the same work (and reconstruct the lost original) using distinctive copying errors as apomorphies. This differs from traditional historical-comparative linguistics in enabling
2805-474: Is typically shared derived characteristics ( synapomorphies ) that are not present in more distant groups and ancestors. However, from an empirical perspective, common ancestors are inferences based on a cladistic hypothesis of relationships of taxa whose character states can be observed. Theoretically, a last common ancestor and all its descendants constitute a (minimal) clade. Importantly, all descendants stay in their overarching ancestral clade. For example, if
2890-526: The South African War . From 1903 to 1910, he was professor of Zoology and Geology at Victoria College, Stellenbosch (later Stellenbosch University ), but was forced out of this position for promoting belief in evolution. He established a medical practice in the Karoo region of South Africa, an area rich in therapsid fossils. Based on his continuing studies of these fossils and mammalian anatomy he
2975-734: The index finger and the trapezium and capitate ). The first Australopithecus specimen, the type specimen , was discovered in 1924 in a lime quarry by workers at Taung , South Africa. The specimen was studied by the Australian anatomist Raymond Dart , who was then working at the University of the Witwatersrand in Johannesburg . The fossil skull was from a three-year-old bipedal primate (nicknamed Taung Child ) that he named Australopithecus africanus . The first report
3060-409: The parsimony criterion has been abandoned by many phylogeneticists in favor of more "sophisticated" but less parsimonious evolutionary models of character state transformation. Cladists contend that these models are unjustified because there is no evidence that they recover more "true" or "correct" results from actual empirical data sets Every cladogram is based on a particular dataset analyzed with
3145-638: The Khoisan peoples as a " degenerate " and "degraded race", speculating in 1907 that they descended from "the race which built the Pyramids" and " Mongoloids ", but had "degenerated" due to South Africa's hot climate. In his later works he divided the Khoisan peoples into three races , the Bushmen, Hottentot and Korana, based on supposed typological differences, with the type specimen of the Korana race being
3230-539: The amount of data available for phylogenetics. At the same time, cladistics rapidly became popular in evolutionary biology, because computers made it possible to process large quantities of data about organisms and their characteristics. The cladistic method interprets each shared character state transformation as a potential piece of evidence for grouping. Synapomorphies (shared, derived character states) are viewed as evidence of grouping, while symplesiomorphies (shared ancestral character states) are not. The outcome of
3315-680: The basis of craniodental evidence, Strait and Grine (2004) suggest that A. anamensis and A. garhi should be assigned to new genera. It is debated whether or not A. bahrelghazali should be considered simply a western variant of A. afarensis instead of a separate species. A. anamensis may have descended from or was closely related to Ardipithecus ramidus . A. anamensis shows some similarities to both Ar. ramidus and Sahelanthropus . Australopiths shared several traits with modern apes and humans, and were widespread throughout Eastern and Northern Africa by 3.5 million years ago (MYA). The earliest evidence of fundamentally bipedal hominins
3400-494: The cheek teeth of A. afarensis and A. anamensis indicate that A. afarensis predominantly ate fruits and leaves, whereas A. anamensis included grasses and seeds (in addition to fruits and leaves). The thickening of enamel in australopiths may have been a response to eating more ground-bound foods such as tubers, nuts, and cereal grains with gritty dirt and other small particulates which would wear away enamel. Gracile australopiths had larger incisors, which indicates tearing food
3485-422: The clade, or the group should be abolished. Branches down to the divergence to the next significant (e.g. extant) sister are considered stem-groupings of the clade, but in principle each level stands on its own, to be assigned a unique name. For a fully bifurcated tree, adding a group to a tree also adds an additional (named) clade, and a new level on that branch. Specifically, also extinct groups are always put on
Australopithecus - Misplaced Pages Continue
3570-443: The cladograms show two mutually exclusive hypotheses to describe the evolutionary history, at most one of them is correct. The cladogram to the right represents the current universally accepted hypothesis that all primates , including strepsirrhines like the lemurs and lorises , had a common ancestor all of whose descendants are or were primates, and so form a clade; the name Primates is therefore recognized for this clade. Within
3655-402: The development of cultures or artifacts using groups of cultural traits or artifact features. Comparative mythology and folktale use cladistic methods to reconstruct the protoversion of many myths. Mythological phylogenies constructed with mythemes clearly support low horizontal transmissions (borrowings), historical (sometimes Palaeolithic) diffusions and punctuated evolution. They also are
3740-650: The editor to evaluate and place in genetic relationship large groups of manuscripts with large numbers of variants that would be impossible to handle manually. It also enables parsimony analysis of contaminated traditions of transmission that would be impossible to evaluate manually in a reasonable period of time. Astrophysics infers the history of relationships between galaxies to create branching diagram hypotheses of galaxy diversification. [REDACTED] Biology portal [REDACTED] Evolutionary biology portal Robert Broom Robert Broom FRS FRSE (30 November 1866 – 6 April 1951)
3825-410: The exact historic relationships between the groups. The following terms, coined by Hennig, are used to identify shared or distinct character states among groups: The terms plesiomorphy and apomorphy are relative; their application depends on the position of a group within a tree. For example, when trying to decide whether the tetrapods form a clade, an important question is whether having four limbs
3910-486: The eyes to look over tall grasses for possible food sources or predators, but it is also argued that these advantages were not significant enough to cause the emergence of bipedalism. Earlier fossils, such as Orrorin tugenensis , indicate bipedalism around six million years ago, around the time of the split between humans and chimpanzees indicated by genetic studies. This suggests that erect, straight-legged walking originated as an adaptation to tree-dwelling. Major changes to
3995-512: The field of biology. Any group of individuals or classes that are hypothesized to have a common ancestor, and to which a set of common characteristics may or may not apply, can be compared pairwise. Cladograms can be used to depict the hypothetical descent relationships within groups of items in many different academic realms. The only requirement is that the items have characteristics that can be identified and measured. Anthropology and archaeology : Cladistic methods have been used to reconstruct
4080-481: The fossil taxon is related to other fossil and extant taxa, as implied by the pattern of shared apomorphic features. An otherwise extinct group with any extant descendants, is not considered (literally) extinct, and for instance does not have a date of extinction. Anything having to do with biology and sex is complicated and messy, and cladistics is no exception. Many species reproduce sexually, and are capable of interbreeding for millions of years. Worse, during such
4165-628: The fossilisation process), the attribution to butchery is dubious. In 2015, the Lomekwi culture was discovered at Lake Turkana dating to 3.3 mya, possibly attributable to Kenyanthropus or A. deyiremeda . Cladistics Cladistics ( / k l ə ˈ d ɪ s t ɪ k s / klə- DIST -iks ; from Ancient Greek κλάδος kládos 'branch') is an approach to biological classification in which organisms are categorized in groups (" clades ") based on hypotheses of most recent common ancestry . The evidence for hypothesized relationships
4250-474: The genus was much more widespread than the fossil record suggests), before eventually becoming pseudo-extinct 1.9 million years ago (or 1.2 to 0.6 million years ago if Paranthropus is included). While none of the groups normally directly assigned to this group survived, Australopithecus gave rise to living descendants, as the genus Homo emerged from an Australopithecus species at some time between 3 and 2 million years ago. Australopithecus possessed two of
4335-407: The hierarchical relationships among different homologous features. It can be difficult to decide whether a character state is in fact the same and thus can be classified as a synapomorphy, which may identify a monophyletic group, or whether it only appears to be the same and is thus a homoplasy, which cannot identify such a group. There is a danger of circular reasoning: assumptions about the shape of
SECTION 50
#17327653830534420-474: The idea that these discoveries were anything but apes, though this changed during the late 1940s. In 1950, evolutionary biologist Ernst Walter Mayr said that all bipedal apes should be classified into the genus Homo , and considered renaming Australopithecus to Homo transvaalensis . However, the contrary view taken by Robinson in 1954, excluding australopiths from Homo , became the prevalent view. The first australopithecine fossil discovered in eastern Africa
4505-560: The kitchen stove". Their skulls were later sent to the medical school of the University of Edinburgh , alongside a 7 month old foetus, from which Broom had removed the brain which he preserved separately. Broom also obtained remains of deceased prisoners, stating: "If a prisoner dies and you want his skeleton, probably two or three regulations stand in the way, but the enthusiast does not worry about such regulations." Broom said that he had buried several corpses in his garden allowing them to decay before later retrieving their bones. These include
4590-487: The latter contains Tarsiiformes and Anthropoidea. Lemurs and tarsiers may have looked closely related to humans, in the sense of being close on the evolutionary tree to humans. However, from the perspective of a tarsier, humans and lemurs would have looked close, in the exact same sense. Cladistics forces a neutral perspective, treating all branches (extant or extinct) in the same manner. It also forces one to try to make statements, and honestly take into account findings, about
4675-419: The mentioned assumptions, often result in different cladograms. Only scientific investigation can show which is more likely to be correct. Until recently, for example, cladograms like the following have generally been accepted as accurate representations of the ancestral relations among turtles, lizards, crocodilians, and birds: turtles lizards crocodilians birds If this phylogenetic hypothesis
4760-604: The more gracile species, who kept their crests. Australopithecus species are thought to have eaten mainly fruit, vegetables, and tubers, and perhaps easy-to-catch animals such as small lizards. Much research has focused on a comparison between the South African species A. africanus and Paranthropus robustus . Early analyses of dental microwear in these two species showed, compared to P. robustus , A. africanus had fewer microwear features and more scratches as opposed to pits on its molar wear facets. Microwear patterns on
4845-455: The most commonly used method to classify organisms. The original methods used in cladistic analysis and the school of taxonomy derived from the work of the German entomologist Willi Hennig , who referred to it as phylogenetic systematics (also the title of his 1966 book); but the terms "cladistics" and "clade" were popularized by other researchers. Cladistics in the original sense refers to
4930-555: The most complete of which was an australopithecine skull, nicknamed Mrs Ples , and a partial skeleton that indicated that australopithecines walked upright. Broom died in Pretoria , South Africa in 1951. Broom was first known for his study of therapsids . After Raymond Dart 's discovery of the Taung Child , an infant australopithecine, Broom's interest in palaeoanthropology was heightened. Broom's career seemed over and he
5015-593: The name of species incorporates their genus. According to cladistics , groups should not be left paraphyletic , where it is kept not consisting of a common ancestor and all of its descendants. Resolving this problem would cause major ramifications in the nomenclature of all descendent species. Possibilities suggested have been to rename Homo sapiens to Australopithecus sapiens (or even Pan sapiens ), or to move some Australopithecus species into new genera. In 2002 and again in 2007, Camilo José Cela Conde et al. suggested that A. africanus be moved to Paranthropus . On
5100-463: The nearby Gona and Ledi-Geraru sites, but the appearance of Homo at Ledi-Geraru ( LD 350-1 ) casts doubt on australopithecine authorship. In 2010, cut marks dating to 3.4 mya on a bovid leg were found at the Dikaka site, which were at first attributed to butchery by A. afarensis , but because the fossil came from a sandstone unit (and were modified by abrasive sand and gravel particles during
5185-421: The origin of Homo sapiens is the ultimate purpose behind evolution. According to Broom "Much of evolution looks as if it had been planned to result in man, and in other animals and plants to make the world a suitable place for him to dwell in." After discovering the skull of Mrs. Ples, Broom was asked if he excavated at random, Broom replied that spirits had told him where to find his discoveries. Broom had
SECTION 60
#17327653830535270-403: The pelvis and feet had already taken place before Australopithecus . It was once thought that humans descended from a knuckle-walking ancestor, but this is not well-supported. Australopithecines have thirty-two teeth, like modern humans. Their molars were parallel, like those of great apes, and they had a slight pre-canine gap (diastema). Their canines were smaller, like modern humans, and with
5355-444: The primates, all anthropoids (monkeys, apes, and humans) are hypothesized to have had a common ancestor all of whose descendants are or were anthropoids, so they form the clade called Anthropoidea. The "prosimians", on the other hand, form a paraphyletic taxon. The name Prosimii is not used in phylogenetic nomenclature , which names only clades; the "prosimians" are instead divided between the clades Strepsirhini and Haplorhini , where
5440-432: The reciprocal host. There are several processes in nature which can cause horizontal gene transfer . This does typically not directly interfere with ancestry of the organism, but can complicate the determination of that ancestry. On another level, one can map the horizontal gene transfer processes, by determining the phylogeny of the individual genes using cladistics. If there is unclarity in mutual relationships, there are
5525-528: The remains of two men who were imprisoned in Douglas jail: Andreas Links, an 18 year old !Ora man, (catalogued as MMK 264), as well an unnamed 18 year old "bushman" from Langeberg (catalogued as MMK 283), who was photographed while alive at the request of Broom, despite this being against policy. The skeletons of both men were added to the collections of the McGregor Museum in 1921. Broom described
5610-694: The robust hominin genus Paranthropus with his discovery of Paranthropus robustus . These discoveries helped support Dart's claims for the Taung species. For his volume, The South Africa Fossil Ape-Men, The Australopithecinae , in which he proposed the Australopithecinae subfamily, Broom was awarded the Daniel Giraud Elliot Medal from the National Academy of Sciences in 1946. The remainder of Broom's career
5695-719: The site of Gona, Ethiopia . This implies meat consumption by at least one of three species of hominins occurring around that time: A. africanus , A. garhi , and/or P. aethiopicus . In 2010, fossils of butchered animal bones dated 3.4 million years old were found in Ethiopia, close to regions where australopith fossils were found. Robust australopithecines ( Paranthropus ) had larger cheek teeth than gracile australopiths, possibly because robust australopithecines had more tough, fibrous plant material in their diets, whereas gracile australopiths ate more hard and brittle foods. However, such divergence in chewing adaptations may instead have been
5780-441: The skeleton of Links. Other contemporary anthropologists questioned this classification scheme, especially the Korana race. Broom later said that he had "invented the Korana". All such typological racial classification schemes are discredited today, due to being based on vague criteria, resulting in the rigid categorization ultimately being arbitrary. Anatomist Goran Štrkalj wrote that: "It is obvious that Broom's anthropological work
5865-655: The taxonomic inconsistency. Furthermore, because e.g. A. africanus is more closely related to for instance humans, or their ancestors at the time, than e.g. A. anamensis and many more Australopithecus branches, Australopithecus cannot be consolidated into a coherent grouping without also including the Homo genus and other genera. The earliest known member of the genus, A. anamensis , existed in eastern Africa around 4.2 million years ago. Australopithecus fossils become more widely dispersed throughout eastern and southern Africa (the Chadian A. bahrelghazali indicates that
5950-590: The teeth less interlocked than in previous hominins. In fact, in some australopithecines, the canines are shaped more like incisors. The molars of Australopithecus fit together in much the same way those of humans do, with low crowns and four low, rounded cusps used for crushing. They have cutting edges on the crests. However, australopiths generally evolved a larger postcanine dentition with thicker enamel. Australopiths in general had thick enamel , like Homo , while other great apes have markedly thinner enamel. Robust australopiths wore their molar surfaces down flat, unlike
6035-426: The teeth of A. africanus , probably caused by consumption of acidic fruit. It is debated if the Australopithecus hand was anatomically capable of producing stone tools. A. garhi was associated with large mammal bones bearing evidence of processing by stone tools, which may indicate australopithecine tool production. Stone tools dating to roughly the same time as A. garhi (about 2.6 mya) were later discovered at
6120-461: The terms worms or fishes were used within a strict cladistic framework, these terms would include humans. Many of these terms are normally used paraphyletically , outside of cladistics, e.g. as a ' grade ', which are fruitless to precisely delineate, especially when including extinct species. Radiation results in the generation of new subclades by bifurcation, but in practice sexual hybridization may blur very closely related groupings. As
6205-411: The three duplicated genes derived from SRGAP2 roughly 3.4 and 2.4 million years ago ( SRGAP2B and SRGAP2C ), the second of which contributed to the increase in number and migration of neurons in the human brain. Significant changes to the hand first appear in the fossil record of later A. afarensis about 3 million years ago (fingers shortened relative to thumb and changes to the joints between
6290-410: The time of his original formulation until the end of the 1970s, cladistics competed as an analytical and philosophical approach to systematics with phenetics and so-called evolutionary taxonomy . Phenetics was championed at this time by the numerical taxonomists Peter Sneath and Robert Sokal , and evolutionary taxonomy by Ernst Mayr . Originally conceived, if only in essence, by Willi Hennig in
6375-469: Was ... influenced by the racist stereotypes and prejudices of the day". Among hundreds of articles contributed by him to scientific journals, the most important include: Books Robert Broom is commemorated in the scientific name of a species of Australian blind snake , Anilios broomi , the Triassic archosauromorph reptile Prolacerta broomi , the rhinesuchid amphibian Broomistega and
6460-488: Was a British- South African medical doctor and palaeontologist . He qualified as a medical practitioner in 1895 and received his DSc in 1905 from the University of Glasgow . From 1903 to 1910, he was professor of zoology and geology at Victoria College , Stellenbosch , South Africa, and subsequently he became keeper of vertebrate palaeontology at the South African Museum , Cape Town . Broom
6545-420: Was a believer in spiritual evolution . In his book The Coming of Man: Was it Accident or Design? (1933) he claimed that "spiritual agencies" had guided evolution as animals and plants were too complex to have arisen by chance. According to Broom, there were at least two different kinds of spiritual forces, and psychics are capable of seeing them. Broom claimed there was a plan and purpose in evolution and that
6630-566: Was an A. boisei skull excavated by Mary Leakey in 1959 in Olduvai Gorge , Tanzania . Since then, the Leakey family has continued to excavate the gorge, uncovering further evidence for australopithecines, as well as for Homo habilis and Homo erectus . The scientific community took 20 more years to widely accept Australopithecus as a member of the human family tree. In 1997, an almost complete Australopithecus skeleton with skull
6715-651: Was born at 66 Back Sneddon Street in Paisley , Renfrewshire , Scotland, the son of John Broom, a designer of calico prints and Paisley shawls , and Agnes Hunter Shearer. In 1893, he married Mary Baird Baillie, his childhood sweetheart. In his medical studies at the University of Glasgow Broom specialised in obstetrics. After graduating in 1895 he travelled to Australia, supporting himself by practising medicine. He settled in South Africa in 1897, just prior to
6800-481: Was devoted to the exploration of these sites and the interpretation of the many early hominin remains discovered there. He continued to write to the last. Shortly before his death he finished a monograph on the Australopithecines and remarked to his nephew: Broom was a nonconformist and was deeply interested in the paranormal and spiritualism ; he was a critic of Darwinism and materialism . Broom
6885-487: Was found in the Sterkfontein caves of Gauteng , South Africa. It is now called " Little Foot " and it is around 3.7 million years old. It was named Australopithecus prometheus which has since been placed within A. africanus . Other fossil remains found in the same cave in 2008 were named Australopithecus sediba , which lived 1.9 million years ago. A. africanus probably evolved into A. sediba , which some scientists think may have evolved into H. erectus , though this
6970-427: Was important, perhaps eating scavenged meat. Nonetheless, the wearing patterns on the teeth support a largely herbivorous diet. In 1992, trace-element studies of the strontium/calcium ratios in robust australopith fossils suggested the possibility of animal consumption, as they did in 1994 using stable carbon isotopic analysis. In 2005, fossil animal bones with butchery marks dating to 2.6 million years old were found at
7055-660: Was made a Fellow of the Royal Society in 1920. Following the discovery of the Taung child he became interested in the search for human ancestors and commenced work on much more recent fossils from the dolomite caves north-west of Johannesburg, particularly Sterkfontein Cave (now part of the Cradle of Humankind World Heritage Site). As well as describing many mammalian fossils from these caves he identified several hominin fossils,
7140-515: Was published in Nature in February 1925. Dart realised that the fossil contained a number of humanoid features, and so he came to the conclusion that this was an early human ancestor. Later, Scottish paleontologist Robert Broom and Dart set out to search for more early hominin specimens, and several more A. africanus remains from various sites. Initially, anthropologists were largely hostile to
7225-621: Was sinking into poverty, when Dart wrote to Jan Smuts about the situation. Smuts, exerting pressure on the South African government, managed to obtain a position for Broom in 1934 with the staff of the Transvaal Museum in Pretoria as an Assistant in Palaeontology . Broom has been described as "one of the great Karoo (and, in particular, therapsid) palaeontologists", having managed to describe 369 therapsid holotypes in his lifetime, which he ascribed to 168 new genera. Broom has
#52947