Misplaced Pages

#795204

31-700: The International Narcotics Control Board ( INCB ) is an independent treaty body , one of the four treaty -mandated bodies under international drug control law (alongside the Commission on Narcotic Drugs , UNODC on behalf of the Secretary-General , and the WHO ). The INCB is responsible for monitoring the control of substances pursuant to the three United Nations drug control conventions and for assisting Member States in their efforts to implement those conventions. It plays an important role in monitoring

62-515: A number of treaty bodies, in particular in relation with international human rights law . However, there are also treaty bodies related to non-human rights instruments such as the UPOV or the INCB . The mandates of treaty bodies is generally defined in the treaty that establishes them, and sometimes by General Assembly decisions or resolutions. Treaty bodies sometimes perform additional functions than

93-731: Is an integral part of the Secretariat of the United Nations; while under the full administrative control of the Secretary-General, it is bound to carry out the decisions of the Board; The members of the secretariat are appointed or assigned by the Secretary-General; the head of that secretariat is appointed or assigned in consultation with the Board. The Commentary to the Convention on Psychotropic Substances notes, "Since

124-551: Is established under a treaty and is not an organ of an international organization." A research guide published by the UN library lists key characteristics of human rights treaty-based bodies: Notably, the experts conforming treaty bodies usually serve in their personal capacity (i.e., not representing their country). Treaty bodies are distinct from "international organizations" as such, like United Nations agencies, programs, or other sui generis international organizations . There are

155-494: Is inherited from the previous treaty provision. Board Members elect a president among them for a one-year term. Although the 13 Members of the Board are independent, the Secretariat, officers, and staff of the INCB are entrusted to the United Nations. States parties to the 1961 Convention already expressed their desire to see INCB Secretariat integrated within the United Nations system under Secretary-General : That secretariat

186-728: The 1931 Convention created the Drug Supervisory Body to gather estimates, in complement of the PCOB. After the dissolution of the League of Nations in 1946, the Lake Success Protocol Amending the Agreements, Conventions and Protocols on Narcotic Drugs transferred the powers and mandate of both Permanent Central Opium Board and Drug Supervisory Board to a specially-created joint body to administer

217-540: The Commission on Narcotic Drugs . The commission has power to influence drug control policy by advising other bodies and deciding how various substances will be controlled. Enforcement power lies in the mandate of each State Party to the Conventions. The Board has mostly a monitoring and surveillance role. The INCB has a role generally similar under the 1961 and 1971 Conventions. The substances under scrutiny differ. The 1961 Single Convention , Article 9 provides that

248-591: The United Nations Economic and Social Council entrusted the management of INCB Secretariat to the agency known today as United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime . (Pakistan) (Mexico) (Thailand) (US) (Chile) (Russia) (France) (China) (India) (Peru) (US) (Russia) (Ghana) (Turkey) (China) (South Africa) (Malta) Treaty body The International Law Commission defines an "expert treaty body" as: "a body consisting of experts serving in their personal capacity, which

279-504: The 1971 Convention, and Article 22 of the 1988 Convention, give the Board the authority to investigate the failure of any country or region to carry out the convention's provisions. This includes countries that are not Parties to the Conventions. The Board can ask for explanations from the Government in question, propose that a study of the matter be carried out in its territory, and call upon the Government to adopt remedial measures. If

310-493: The Board finds that the Government has failed to give satisfactory explanations, or has failed to adopt remedial measures that it has been called upon to take, the Board can call the attention of the Parties, the council, and the commission to the matter. The Board can also publish a report on the matter for communication to all Parties. Under some circumstances, it can penalize a violator by reducing its export quota of opium, under

341-502: The Board has that authority except in very grave situations". Decisions under Article 19 require a two-thirds vote of the Board. INCB has been criticized for claiming being a "quasi-judicial" body whereas neither the three drug control Conventions nor ECOSOC resolutions provide it with such a mandate. In September 2022, Virginia Patton Prugh , Attorney Advisor at the United States Department of State , declared on

SECTION 10

#1732776862796

372-632: The Board is not in continuous session and in fact meets only a few weeks each year, it has to delegate to its secretariat the required authority in order to maintain between its sessions 'the mechanism for a continuing dialogue' with Governments". Additionally, in 1990, the Board noted that "by decision of the Secretary-General, the Director-General of the United Nations Office at Vienna serves as Coordinator of all United Nations drug control-related activities." Resolution 1991/46 of

403-433: The Board shall endeavour to: But these refer to monitoring and advice, rather than enforcement. The INCB has no direct enforcement powers. Articles 12 and 19 of the same Convention give the Board the responsibility of reviewing, confirming, or requesting changes to the annual estimates of needs for narcotic drugs among Parties concerning licit cultivation, production, manufacture, export, import, distribution and trade, with

434-629: The Board was the result of lobbying by the pharmaceuticals industry. The provision that three members would be WHO nominees is similar to provision in previous treaties, which had two of the four members of the Drug Supervisory Body to be appointed by the Office International d'Hygiène Publique (OIHP), the predecessor of WHO. The requirement that INCB nominees be appointed by ECOSOC in the Single Convention

465-521: The INCB from playing any role in the settlement of disputes between two or more Parties relating to the interpretation or application of the convention, instead leaving the resolution of these disputes to the Parties concerned through peaceful means of their own choice. Article 9 of the Single Convention specifies that the Board shall be made up of thirteen members elected by the UN Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC), including: The Article requires

496-453: The INCB is not and should not self-define as a "quasi-judicial" body had been defended by civil society organisations and scholars for a number of years. Article 12 of the 1988 Convention Against Illicit Traffic requires the Board to report annually to the Commission on Narcotic Drugs on the implementation of the convention's restrictions on chemical precursors in Table I and Table II,

527-734: The INCB were later complemented with the adoption of the Convention on Psychotropic Substances in 1971 and the UN Convention Against Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances in 1988. The drug control treaties mandates four international bodies: the Board, the World Health Organization , the Secretary-General of the United Nations (nowadays represented by the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime ), and

558-428: The Single Convention. Under the 1971 Convention on Psychotropic Substances , similar powers are given to the Board, in regards to psychotropic substances. In addition, Article 18 of the 1971 Convention requires the Board to issue annual reports on its work. During the negotiations of the Single Convention, governments refused to give the INCB direct enforcement powers. Article 14 of the Single Convention, Article 19 of

589-591: The allotment as a whole quota, that is prescribed to each individual entity. For example, the United States imposes an import quota on cars from Japan . The Japanese government may see fit to impose a quota share program to determine the number of cars each Japanese car manufacturer may export to the United States. Any extra number that a manufacturer wishes to export must be negotiated with another manufacturer that did not or cannot maximize its share of

620-429: The comments submitted by the Parties and the comments and recommendations of the Board, whose assessment shall be determinative as to scientific matters, and also taking into due consideration any other relevant factors". This role of assessment given to the INCB under the 1988 Convention was, under the 1961 and 1971 Convention, was reserved to the World Health Organization . Notably, this Convention explicitly preludes

651-466: The council to make arrangements to ensure the Board's independence. Article 10 specifies that "[t]he members of the Board shall serve for a period of five years, and may be re-elected." The lengthy terms, and the fact that the Board is made up of individuals rather than nation-states, help buffer the Board from political pressure. Historians have argued that the requirement that members with "medical, pharmacological or pharmaceutical experience" be placed on

SECTION 20

#1732776862796

682-620: The estimate system. The functions of both bodies were merged into the current INCB with the adoption of the Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs in 1961, and those bodies were superseded when the INCB began its functions on March 2, 1968. Initially, the composition of the INCB under the Single Convention was strongly influenced by the 1946 Protocol. It inherited mechanisms of nomination from the League of Nations and Office International d'Hygiène Publique . The mandates and functions of

713-406: The objective of preventing diversion of drugs from licit sources into the illicit traffic. The estimates do not represent quotas in the strict sense, because the Parties may at any time request changes to their annual estimates, subject to providing the Board with the explanation of the circumstances necessitating such changes. The Board establishes estimates for all nations, including non-Parties to

744-411: The occasion of an intersessional meeting of the Commission on Narcotic Drugs : Reviewing the many sources discussing INCB mandates, one would assume that the INCB has been designated to sit in judgement of MS in their effort to implement the treaties. If that it the case, it must be found in the treaties. But the treaties do not assign this role: it simply isn't there. The INCB is authorized to administer

775-548: The production and trade of narcotics and psychotropics , as well as their availability for medical and scientific purposes, and in deciding which precursors should be regulated. The Board has predecessors since the League of Nations . Following the 1909 Shanghai International Opium Commission , an International Opium Convention was adopted in 1925 and established the Permanent Central Opium Board (PCOB) which started its work in 1928. Later on,

806-450: The provisions of Article 21 bis. The Board can even "recommend to the Parties that they stop the export, import, or both, of particular psychotropic substances, from or to the country or region concerned, either for a designated period or until the Board shall be satisfied as to the situation in that country or region." The Commentary to the Convention on Narcotic Drugs points out, "This is a very serious measure, and it cannot be assumed that

837-638: The quota. There are also quota share insurance programs, where the liability and the premiums are divided proportionally among the insurers. For example, three companies take out a $ 1,000,000 fire insurance policy on a quota share basis with company A assuming 50% ($ 500,000), company B 30% ($ 300,000), and company C 20% ($ 200,000). If the annual premium was $ 5,000, company A would receive $ 2,500 in premium, B would receive $ 1,500, and C would receive $ 1,000. Company A would pay 50% of any one claim, Company B would pay 30% of any one claim, and Company C would pay 20% of any one claim. This article about

868-426: The sole monitoring of treaty compliance. Import quota An import quota is a type of trade restriction that sets a physical limit on the quantity of a good that can be imported into a country in a given period of time. Quotas, like other trade restrictions, are typically used to benefit the producers of a good in that economy ( protectionism ). The quota share is a specified number or percentage of

899-626: The substance if it finds that: The Convention requires the Board to notify the United Nations Secretary-General whenever it has information which, in its opinion, may justify adding a substance to, deleting a substance from, or transferring a substance between, the Tables. The Secretary-General then transmits that information to the Parties and the commission, and the Commission makes the decision, "taking into account

930-479: The system of estimates and the statistical returns, and to support the Parties in implementing the Conventions. But there is no text suggesting that the INCB is given quasi-judicial functions to interpret the treaties, or adjudicate their conformity or compliance. Read the text; look carefully at the words: we, the Parties to the Conventions, are responsible for implementing our obligations, and we are also responsible for interpreting them in good faith. The position that

961-406: The treaty's two categories of precursor substances in illicit drug manufacture. The INCB "Red List" lists precursors and chemicals frequently used in illicitly manufacturing narcotics and psychotropic substances under international control. In the case of a precursor substance not yet regulated, the convention also requires the Board to communicate to the Commission on Narcotic Drugs an assessment of

International Narcotics Control Board - Misplaced Pages Continue

#795204