63-504: The Regiam Majestatem is the earliest surviving work giving a comprehensive digest of the Law of Scotland . The name of the document is derived from its first two words. It consists of four books, treating (1) civil actions and jurisdictions, (2) judgments and executions, (3) contracts, and (4) crimes. Dating from the early fourteenth century, it is largely based on the 1188 Tractatus de legibus et consuetudinibus regni Angliae ( Treatise on
126-565: A hybrid or mixed legal system . The nature of Scots law before the 12th century is largely speculative, but is likely to have been a mixture of different legal traditions representing the different cultures inhabiting the land at the time, including Gaelic , Welsh , Norse and Anglo-Saxon customs. There is evidence to suggest that as late as the 17th century marriage laws in the Highlands and Islands still reflected Gaelic custom, contrary to Catholic religious principles. The formation of
189-701: A legislature with England and Wales . Scotland retained a fundamentally different legal system from that south of the border , but the Union exerted English influence upon Scots law. Since the UK joined the European Union, Scots law has also been affected by European law under the Treaties of the European Union , the requirements of the European Convention on Human Rights (entered into by members of
252-419: A great success. The Scots were certainly aware of this, and it was likely chosen over other codifications because it best suited Scottish interests by providing a framework that had already proved itself to be successful, and one that addressed issues particular to Scottish law, but issues that mostly were common to both Scottish and English law. Where it was close to Scottish interests but not close enough, that
315-755: A large body of legal precedent has been developed, so that many crimes, such as murder, are not codified . Sources of common law in Scotland are the decisions of the Scottish courts and certain rulings of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom (including its predecessor the House of Lords ). The degree to which decisions of the Supreme Court are binding on Scottish courts in civil matters
378-528: A legal basis and its documentation, and the Scots were forced to rebuild their legal provenance quickly. The origin of the contents of the Regiam Majestatem is largely from Glanvill's Tractatus . About two-thirds of the work was adopted without change from it, parts of the remainder are similar to it, and the rest is unrelated to it. This last category includes most of the fourth book, which covers
441-512: A result of judgments) is also given, but Skene thought that these were not authentic. Two of the Laws of the Burghs cite the Regiam Majestatem as their origin. These are: Scottish legal terms found in the Regiam Majestatem include: It is not known whether the Regiam Majestatem was immediately put into effect, or whether it had been intended to be put it into effect at a later date. Whichever
504-405: A textbook for first year law students, but, according to the decree that promulgated them (C. Tanta), they carried the force of law. First year law students used Justinian's Institutes as their textbook for centuries. The Institutes of Justinian is arranged much like Gaius's work, being divided into three subjects in four books covering "persons," "things,", and "actions." The first book considers
567-739: Is Scotland’s supreme criminal court and deals with the most serious crime. The Court of Session is the supreme civil court. The majority of crime is prosecuted by The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service , which provides the independent public prosecution service for Scotland similar to the Crown Prosecution Service in England and Wales and the Public Prosecution Service in Northern Ireland. The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
630-537: Is a matter of controversy. The generally accepted list of institutional works are: Some commentators would also consider the following works to be included: Institutes (Justinian) The Institutes ( Latin : Institutiones ) is a component of the Corpus Juris Civilis , the 6th-century codification of Roman law ordered by the Byzantine emperor Justinian I . It is largely based upon
693-437: Is also the country’s death investigation service, and is responsible for investigating all suspicious, sudden or unexplained deaths. Unlike England and Wales Scotland has no coronial system to investigate deaths. Instead a Fatal Accident Inquiry (FAI), presided over by a judge, may be established to determine the cause of a death and any steps to prevent deaths in similar circumstances. Except in circumstances where an FAI
SECTION 10
#1732773101993756-451: Is controversial, especially where those decisions relate to cases brought from other legal jurisdictions; however, decisions of the Supreme Court in appeals from Scotland are considered binding precedent . In criminal cases the highest appellate court is the Court of Justiciary and so the common law related to criminal law in Scotland has been largely developed only in Scotland. Rulings of
819-554: Is mandatory, such as deaths in prison or in police custody, the Crown Office will determine whether an FAI would be in the public interest. Scots law can be traced to its early beginnings as a number of different custom systems among Scotland's early cultures to its modern role as one of the three legal jurisdictions of the United Kingdom. The various historic sources of Scots law, including custom , feudal law , canon law , civilian ius commune and English law have created
882-473: Is not entirely consistent with the original document, but it held up as the standard version. Later legal references to the document are references to the 1609 publication. The Regiam Majestatem was written perhaps as early as the time of Robert the Bruce (reigned 1306 – 1329), and certainly later than 1318, as a statute from that date was included in it. The details of how this was accomplished are unknown, as
945-602: Is passed by the Scottish Parliament on all areas of devolved responsibility, and the United Kingdom Parliament on reserved matters. Some legislation passed by the pre-1707 Parliament of Scotland is still also valid. Early Scots law before the 12th century consisted of the different legal traditions of the various cultural groups who inhabited the country at the time, the Gaels in most of
1008-467: Is the legal system of Scotland . It is a hybrid or mixed legal system containing civil law and common law elements, that traces its roots to a number of different historical sources. Together with English law and Northern Irish law , it is one of the three legal systems of the United Kingdom . Scots law recognises four sources of law: legislation, legal precedent, specific academic writings, and custom. Legislation affecting Scotland and Scots law
1071-431: Is the identity of the author. In the events leading up to his invasion of Scotland, Edward I of England (reigned 1272–1307) forced himself upon Scotland in the role of feudal overlord, far beyond the guiding and consultative role that the Scots had asked him to play. During this time he signed a writ in 1291 that required the collection of all documents that might concern his own claims of superiority over Scotland, or
1134-572: Is the likely origin of those portions of the Regiam Majestatem that appear only similar to the Tractatus . Nevertheless, the fit was not perfect, and there are artefacts from English law that do not fit well with Scottish customs. When the Regiam Majestatem was discovered in the fifteenth century, it was quickly embraced as a legal authority, the Parliament authorised commissions to examine it and repair defects (1425 c. 54, 1487 c. 115), and it
1197-833: The Institutes of Gaius , a Roman jurist of the second century A.D. The other parts of the Corpus Juris Civilis are the Digest , the Codex Justinianus , and the Novellae Constitutiones ("New Constitutions" or "Novels"). Justinian's Institutes was one part of his effort to codify Roman law and to reform legal education, of which the Digest also was a part. Whereas the Digest was to be used by advanced law students, Justinian's Institutes
1260-741: The Acts of Union 1707 merged the Kingdom of Scotland and the Kingdom of England to form the new Kingdom of Great Britain . Article 19 of the Act confirmed the continuing authority of the College of Justice , Court of Session and Court of Justiciary in Scotland. Article 3, however, merged the Estates of Scotland with the Parliament of England to form the Parliament of Great Britain , with its seat in
1323-644: The Council of Europe ) and the creation of the devolved Scottish Parliament which may pass legislation within all areas not reserved to Westminster , as detailed by the Scotland Act 1998 . The UK Withdrawal from the European Union (Continuity) (Scotland) Act 2020 was passed by the Scottish Parliament in December 2020. It received royal assent on 29 January 2021 and came into operation on
SECTION 20
#17327731019931386-534: The European Court of Human Rights and the Court of Justice of the European Union also contribute to the common law in the interpretation of the European Convention on Human Rights and European law respectively. The common law of Scotland should not be confused with the common law of England , which has different historical roots. The historical roots of the common law of Scotland are the customary laws of
1449-537: The Human Rights Act 1998 and European law , otherwise the Court of Session or High Court of Justiciary have the authority to strike down the legislation as ultra vires . There have been a number of high-profile examples of challenges to Scottish Parliament legislation on these grounds, including against the Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Act 2002 where an interest group unsuccessfully claimed
1512-514: The Palace of Westminster , London . Under the terms of the Act of Union, Scotland retained its own systems of law, education and Church ( Church of Scotland , Presbyterian polity), separately from the rest of the country. The Parliament of Great Britain otherwise was not restricted in altering laws concerning public right, policy and civil government, but concerning private right, only alterations for
1575-407: The Parliament of the United Kingdom is not subject to revocation by the courts as the Parliament is said to have supreme legal authority; however, application of legislation is subject to judicial review and also in practice, the Parliament will tend not to create legislation which contradicts the Human Rights Act 1998 or European law , although it is technically free to do so. The degree to which
1638-548: The Scotland Act 1998 and the European Communities Act 1972 have special status in the law of Scotland. Modern statutes will specify that they apply to Scotland and may also include special wording to take into consideration unique elements of the legal system. Statutes must receive royal assent from the King before becoming law , however this is now only a formal procedure and is automatic. Legislation of
1701-483: The burghs and lesser landowners. In 1399 a General Council established that the King should hold a parliament at least once a year for the next three years so "that his subjects are served by the law". In 1318 a parliament at Scone enacted a code of law that drew upon older practices, but it was also dominated by current events and focused on military matters and the conduct of the war of Scottish Independence . From
1764-417: The church courts , the direct influence of Roman law was slight up until around the mid-15th century. After this time, civilian ius commune was often adopted in argument in court, in an adapted form, where there was no native Scots rule to settle a dispute; and civil law was in this way partially received in subsidium into Scots law. Since the Acts of Union 1707 , Scotland has shared a legislature with
1827-565: The 14th century we have surviving examples of early Scottish legal literature, such as the Regiam Majestatem (on procedure at the royal courts) and the Quoniam Attachiamenta (on procedure at the baron courts). Both of these important texts, as they were copied, had provisions from Roman law and the ius commune inserted or developed, demonstrating the influence which both these sources had on Scots law. From
1890-579: The Kingdom of Scotland and its subjugation of the surrounding cultures, completed by the Battle of Carham , established what are approximately the boundaries of contemporary mainland Scotland. The Outer Hebrides were added after the Battle of Largs in 1263, and the Northern Isles were acquired in 1469, completing what is today the legal jurisdiction of Scotland. From the 12th century feudalism
1953-509: The Parliament began to create unified legal statutes applying in both England and Scotland, particularly when conformity was seen as necessary for pragmatic reasons (such as the Sale of Goods Act 1893 ). Appeal decisions by English judges raised concerns about this appeal to a foreign system, and in the late 19th century Acts allowed for the appointment of Scottish Lords of Appeal in Ordinary . At
Regiam Majestatem - Misplaced Pages Continue
2016-696: The Parliament has surrendered this sovereignty is a matter of controversy with arguments generally concerning what the relationship should be between the United Kingdom and the European Union . Acts of the United Kingdom Parliament also regularly delegate powers to Ministers of the Crown or other bodies to produce legislation in the form of statutory instruments . This delegated legislation has legal effect in Scotland so far as
2079-522: The ban on fox hunting violated their human rights. Legislation passed by the Scottish Parliament also requires royal assent which, like with the Parliament of the United Kingdom , is automatically granted. Legislation passed by the pre-1707 Parliament of Scotland still has legal effect in Scotland, though the number of statutes that have not been repealed is limited. Examples include the Royal Mines Act 1424 , which makes gold and silver mines
2142-531: The basic institutions ("Institutiones") of Roman law from the teaching books created by writers of "authority" (as defined in the Law of Citations ). The bulk of this new Institutes is the Institutes of Gaius , much of it taken verbatim; but it also uses material from the Institutes of Marcian, Florentinus, Ulpian , and perhaps Paulus (the other writers of "authority"). There is some debate over which of
2205-457: The case, it did not matter because Scotland would suffer a Second War of Scottish Independence (1332–1371) when it was invaded by Edward III of England , its king David II was captured by the English, and in the ensuing devastation the Regiam Majestatem became lost, not being rediscovered until the next century. When found, it was hailed as an ancient Scottish relic that had somehow survived
2268-564: The claims of others. The writ was executed, and between that and the depredations during Edward's invasion of Scotland in 1296, virtually every important Scottish legal document was lost forever. The Scots successfully maintained their freedom in the First War of Scottish Independence , which ended de facto with the Battle of Bannockburn in 1314, ending de jure in 1328 with the Treaty of Edinburgh–Northampton . Effective government required
2331-403: The commission members is responsible for what part of the new Institutes. Most recently it has been suggested that Theophilus and Dorotheus created the extracts taken from the older works, while Tribonian revised and added new imperial laws. This new version of the Institutes was published on November 21, 533 and promulgated with the Digest on December 30, 533. These new Institutes were not only
2394-473: The confiscations of Edward I and the depredations and devastation caused by the two invasions. There was little documentation remaining from that tumultuous time to offer either proof or disproof of the origins of the Regiam Majestatem . Consequently, and not without chauvinism , some Scots insisted on a native origin for the Regiam Majestatem , offering it as another product of the dynamic David I (reigned 1124 – 1153). This assertion persisted until well into
2457-633: The country, with the Britons and Anglo-Saxons in some districts south of the Forth and with the Norse in the islands and north of the River Oykel . The introduction of feudalism from the 12th century and the expansion of the Kingdom of Scotland established the modern roots of Scots law, which was gradually influenced by other, especially Anglo-Norman and continental legal traditions . Although there
2520-476: The different cultures which inhabited the region, which were mixed together with feudal concepts by the Scottish Kings to form a distinct common law. The influence that English-trained judges have had on the common law of Scotland through rulings of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom (and formerly the House of Lords ) has been at times considerable, especially in areas of law where conformity
2583-644: The establishment of a specialised group of councillors to the King evolving from the King's Council who dealt solely with the administration of justice. In 1528, it was established that the Lords of Council not appointed to this body were to be excluded from its audiences and it was also this body that four years later in 1532 became the College of Justice. The 1688 Glorious Revolution and the Claim of Right in 1689 established Parliamentary Sovereignty in Scotland, and
Regiam Majestatem - Misplaced Pages Continue
2646-466: The establishment of the Scottish Parliament which may pass legislation within its areas of legislative competence as detailed by the Scotland Act 1998 . The Parliament of the United Kingdom has the power to pass statutes on any issue for Scotland, although under the Sewel convention it will not do so in devolved matters without the Scottish Parliament 's consent. The Human Rights Act 1998 ,
2709-400: The evident utility of the subjects within Scotland were permitted. The Scottish Enlightenment then reinvigorated Scots law as a university-taught discipline. The transfer of legislative power to London and the introduction of appeal in civil but not criminal cases to the House of Lords (now, by appeal to the new Supreme Court of the United Kingdom ) brought further English influence. Acts of
2772-411: The jurisdictions include the age of legal capacity (16 years old in Scotland but 18 years old in England and Wales), and the fact that equity was never a distinct branch of Scots law. Some examples in criminal law include: In Scotland there are justice of the peace courts and sheriff courts , rather than magistrates' courts or Crown Court as in England and Wales. The High Court of Justiciary
2835-710: The laws and customs of the Kingdom of England ) of Ranulf de Glanvill , and incorporates features of thirteenth century canon law , the Summa in Titulos Decretalium of Goffredus of Trano , and the Scottish Celtic Laws of the Brets and Scots . The documentary basis of Scots law had been largely destroyed by the confiscations of Edward I of England in the thirteenth century and by two devastating English invasions led by Edward I and Edward III in
2898-513: The legal status of persons (personae), the second and third deal with things (res), while the fourth discusses Roman civil procedure (actiones). Unlike the Digest, the extracts do not provide inscriptions indicating from whom the original material was taken. Justinian's Institutes was largely unknown in the West. The earliest known manuscript are fragments of a Veronese palimpsest of the ninth century. The first printed edition of Justinian's Institutes
2961-1026: The nineteenth century, though scholarly research had rendered the contention untenable in the eighteenth century, such as by notice of statutes in the document that could not pre-date the thirteenth and fourteenth century. Notes Citations Bibliography Scots law Charles III William , Duke of Rothesay Swinney government The Rt Hon John Swinney MSP The Rt Hon John Swinney MSP Kate Forbes MSP Sixth session Alison Johnstone MSP Angela Constance MSP Dorothy Bain KC The Rt Hon Lord Carloway KC PC United Kingdom Parliament elections European Parliament elections Local elections Referendums Starmer ministry The Rt Hon Keir Starmer MP The Rt Hon Ian Murray MP Scots law ( Scottish Gaelic : Lagh na h-Alba )
3024-467: The property of the King , and the Leases Act 1449 , which is still relied on today in property law cases. Legislation which forms part of the law of Scotland should not be confused with a civil code as it does not attempt to comprehensively detail the law. Legislation forms only one of a number of sources. Common law is an important legal source in Scotland, especially in criminal law where
3087-400: The reformation of the Scottish Parliament . An early Scottish legal compilation, Regiam Majestatem , was based heavily on Glanvill 's English law treatise , although it also contains elements of civil law , feudal law, canon law, customary law and native Scots statutes . Although there was some indirect Roman-law influence on Scots law, via medieval ius commune and canon law used in
3150-407: The reign of King James I to King James V the beginnings of a legal profession began to develop and the administration of criminal and civil justice was centralised. The Parliament of Scotland was normally called on an annual basis during this period and its membership was further defined. The evolution of the modern Court of Session also traces its history to the 15th and early 16th century with
3213-411: The rest of the United Kingdom . Scotland retained a fundamentally different legal system from that of England and Wales , but the Union brought English influence on Scots law. In recent years, Scots law has also been affected by European law under the Treaties of the European Union , the requirements of the European Convention on Human Rights (entered into by members of the Council of Europe ) and
SECTION 50
#17327731019933276-716: The same day. It provides powers for the Scottish Ministers to keep devolved Scots law in alignment with future EU Law . The United Kingdom, judicially, consists of three jurisdictions : England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland. There are important differences among Scots law, English law and Northern Irish law in areas such as property law , criminal law , trust law , inheritance law , evidence law and family law while there are greater similarities in areas of UK-wide interest such as commercial law , consumer rights, taxation, employment law and health and safety regulations. Examples of differences among
3339-541: The same time, a series of cases made it clear that no appeal lay from the High Court of Justiciary to the House of Lords. Today the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom usually has a minimum of two Scottish justices to ensure that some Scottish experience is brought to bear on Scottish appeals. Scots law has continued to change and develop in the 20th century, with the most significant change coming under devolution and
3402-399: The specific provisions of the statutory instrument are duly authorised by the powers of the Act, a question which can be subjected to judicial review. The Scottish Parliament is a devolved unicameral legislature that has the power to pass statutes only affecting Scotland on matters within its legislative competence . Legislation passed by the Scottish Parliament must also comply with
3465-439: The thirteenth and fourteenth centuries. When the Regiam Majestatem was discovered in the early fifteenth century after Scotland's legal provenance had been destroyed, it was immediately embraced as an authoritative source of law, surviving as such into the modern era. Sir John Skene had compiled and edited versions of the document at his own expense, and this was published by the Parliament of Scotland in 1609. Skene's version
3528-414: The treatment of crimes. Of the portions which do not originate with the Tractatus , their origins can be found in canon law , in the Summa in Titulos Decretalium of Goffredus of Trano , in the Laws of the Brets and Scots , and in earlier Scottish statutes. The Tractatus was a work of originality intended to facilitate the implementation an effective judicial system in England, and it had proven to be
3591-584: The work was meritorious and valuable, and it brought fresh understanding to ancient Scottish law. It is Skene's version that became the legal standard from that time forward. The Regiam Majestatem derives its name from the first two words of its first chapter, which serves as the Præfacio (Preface). It begins: This opening is based on that of the Institutes of Justinian : "Imperatoriam majestatem non solum armis decoratam sed legibus . . . oportet esse armatam." A list of assythments (i.e., assessments made as
3654-587: Was Petrus Schoyff's in 1468. Scholars using the Veronese palimpsest suggested changes to the existing text, and these criticisms resulted in the definitive texts by Paul Krüger and Eduard Huschke in 1867 and 1868 respectively. The most frequently used modern version of Justinian's Institutes is that of Krüger, which is in volume one of the Krüger, Mommsen, Kroll and Schoell stereotype edition. There are several translations of Justinian's Institutes into English,
3717-481: Was cited in statutes of the era. It has remained an authoritative source of Scotland's unique law into the modern era. In 1607 the Parliament of Scotland passed an act for the publication of John Skene's compilation of the Regiam Majestatem , to be funded by the government, and Skene's version was published in 1609. The work has been criticised for its many inconsistencies with the original document, for its lack of scholarly rigour, and for other sloppiness. Nevertheless,
3780-457: Was gradually introduced to Scotland and established feudal land tenure over many parts of the south and east, which eventually spread northward. As feudalism began to develop in Scotland early court systems began to develop, including early forms of Sheriff Courts . Under Robert the Bruce the importance of the Parliament of Scotland grew as he called parliaments more frequently, and its composition shifted to include more representation from
3843-425: Was required across the United Kingdom for pragmatic reasons. This has resulted in rulings with strained interpretations of the common law of Scotland, such as Smith v Bank of Scotland . A number of works by academic authors, called institutional writers , have been identified as formal sources of law in Scotland since at least the 19th century. The exact list of authors and works, and whether it can be added to,
SECTION 60
#17327731019933906-456: Was some indirect Roman law influence on Scots law, the direct influence of Roman law was slight up until around the 15th century. After this time, Roman law was often adopted in argument in court, in an adapted form, where there was no native Scots rule to settle a dispute; and Roman law was in this way partially received into Scots law. Since the Union with England Act 1707 , Scotland has shared
3969-503: Was to be a textbook for new students. The need for a new text for first year students was addressed as early as 530 in the constitution "Deo auctore," where reference is made to something "...which may be promulgated to replace the elementary works, so that the raw intelligence of the student, nourished by a simple diet, may proceed more easily to advanced legal studies." Under the supervision of Tribonian , two law professors (Theophilus and Dorotheus) were assigned to extract statements about
#992007