Misplaced Pages

#677322

111-682: One of William's themes in the Gesta Pontificum Anglorum , as in his Gesta Regum Anglorum , is that the Normans' invasion and conquest of England saved the English and rescued their civilization from the barbarities of the native English and restored England to the Latin culture of the continent. One aspect of this theme was William's reluctance to give Anglo-Saxon names in their native form, instead Latinizing them. The History of

222-440: A revealed truth, as a rational system. Anselm also studiously analyzed the language used in his subjects, carefully distinguishing the meaning of the terms employed from the verbal forms, which he found at times wholly inadequate. His worldview was broadly Neoplatonic , as it was reconciled with Christianity in the works of St Augustine and Pseudo-Dionysius , with his understanding of Aristotelian logic gathered from

333-868: A shrine and its contents "disposed of" during the Reformation . The ambassador's own investigation was of the opinion that Anselm's body had been confused with Archbishop Theobald 's and likely remained entombed near the altar of the Virgin Mary , but in the uncertainty nothing further seems to have been done then or when inquiries were renewed in 1841. Anselm has been called "the most luminous and penetrating intellect between St Augustine and St Thomas Aquinas " and "the father of scholasticism ", Scotus Erigena having employed more mysticism in his arguments. Anselm's works are considered philosophical as well as theological since they endeavour to render Christian tenets of faith, traditionally taken as

444-440: A being greater than which nothing else can be conceived, Anselm proposes such a being must be "just, truthful, happy, and whatever it is better to be than not to be". Chapter 6 specifically enumerates the additional qualities of awareness, omnipotence, mercifulness, impassibility (inability to suffer), and immateriality; Chapter 11, self-existent, wisdom, goodness, happiness, and permanence; and Chapter 18, unity. Anselm addresses

555-665: A deeper knowledge of God." Once the faith is held fast, however, he argued an attempt must be made to demonstrate its truth by means of reason: "To me, it seems to be negligence if, after confirmation in the faith, we do not study to understand that which we believe." Merely rational proofs are always, however, to be tested by scripture and he employs Biblical passages and "what we believe" ( quod credimus ) at times to raise problems or to present erroneous understandings, whose inconsistencies are then resolved by reason. Stylistically, Anselm's treatises take two basic forms, dialogues and sustained meditations. In both, he strove to state

666-443: A monastery but, failing to obtain his father's consent, he was refused by the abbot. The illness he then suffered has been considered by some a psychosomatic effect of his disappointment, but upon his recovery he gave up his studies and for a time lived a carefree life. Following the death of his mother, probably at the birth of his sister Richera, Anselm's father repented his own earlier lifestyle but professed his new faith with

777-598: A monk from the abbey of Marmoutier in Tours . His book "for the fool" ( Liber pro Insipiente ) argues that we cannot arbitrarily pass from idea to reality ( de posse ad esse not fit illatio ). The most famous of Gaunilo's objections is a parody of Anselm's argument involving an island greater than which nothing can be conceived. Since we can conceive of such an island, it exists in our understanding and so must exist in reality. This is, however, absurd, since its shore might arbitrarily be increased and in any case varies with

888-528: A resolution against the British slave trade . Henry supported Anselm's reforms and his authority over the English Church but continued to assert his own authority over Anselm. Upon their return, the three bishops he had dispatched on his second delegation to the pope claimed—in defiance of Paschal's sealed letter to Anselm, his public acts, and the testimony of the two monks who had accompanied them—that

999-426: A semicircular ambulatory opening into three chapels . Anselm's vision was of a Catholic Church with its own internal authority, which clashed with William II's desire for royal control over both church and State. One of Anselm's first conflicts with William came in the month he was consecrated. William II was preparing to wrest Normandy from his elder brother, Robert II , and needed funds. Anselm

1110-560: A series of dialogues on the nature of truth , free will , and the fall of Satan . When the nominalist Roscelin attempted to appeal to the authority of Lanfranc and Anselm at his trial for the heresy of tritheism at Soissons in 1092, Anselm composed the first draft of De Fide Trinitatis as a rebuttal and as a defence of Trinitarianism and universals . The fame of the monastery grew not only from his intellectual achievements, however, but also from his good example and his loving, kindly method of discipline, particularly with

1221-676: A severity that the boy found likewise unbearable. When Gundulph entered a monastery, Anselm, at age 23, left home with a single attendant, crossed the Alps , and wandered through Burgundy and France for three years. His countryman Lanfranc of Pavia was then prior of the Benedictine abbey of Bec in Normandy. Attracted by Lanfranc's reputation, Anselm reached Normandy in 1059. After spending some time in Avranches , he returned

SECTION 10

#1732781040678

1332-458: A side and maintained his right to prevent the acknowledgement of either pope by an English subject prior to his choice. In the end, a ceremony was held to consecrate Anselm as archbishop on 4 December, without the pallium. As archbishop, Anselm maintained his monastic ideals, including stewardship, prudence, and proper instruction, prayer and contemplation. Anselm advocated for reform and interests of Canterbury. As such, he repeatedly pressed

1443-521: A treatise in mind on the origin of the soul and did not know, once he was gone, if another was likely to compose it. He died on Holy Wednesday , 21 April 1109. His remains were translated to Canterbury Cathedral and laid at the head of Lanfranc at his initial resting place to the south of the Altar of the Holy Trinity (now St Thomas 's Chapel). During the church's reconstruction after

1554-507: A treatment of Latin paradoxes called the Grammarian . Over the next decade, the Rule of Saint Benedict reshaped his thought. Three years later, in 1063, Duke William II summoned Lanfranc to serve as the abbot of his new abbey of St Stephen at Caen and the monks of Bec, despite the initial hesitation of some on account of his youth, elected Anselm prior. A notable opponent

1665-630: A woollen pallium given or sent by the pope himself. Anselm insisted that he journey to Rome for this purpose but William would not permit it. Amid the Investiture Controversy , Pope Gregory VII and Emperor Henry IV had deposed each other twice; bishops loyal to Henry finally elected Guibert, archbishop of Ravenna , as a second pope. In France, Philip I had recognized Gregory and his successors Victor III and Urban II , but Guibert (as "Clement III") held Rome after 1084. William had not chosen

1776-527: Is a purely rational argument for the necessity of the Christian mystery of atonement , the belief that Jesus's crucifixion was necessary to atone for mankind's sin. Anselm argues that, owing to the Fall and mankind's fallen nature ever since, humanity has offended God. Divine justice demands restitution for sin but human beings are incapable of providing it, as all the actions of men are already obligated to

1887-413: Is good through itself. As such, it must be the highest good and, further, "that which is supremely good is also supremely great. There is, therefore, some one thing that is supremely good and supremely great—in other words, supreme among all existing things." Chapter 2 follows a similar argument, while Chapter 3 argues that the "best and greatest and supreme among all existing things" must be responsible for

1998-407: Is greater than everything else that can be thought". Anselm countered that anything which does not actually exist is necessarily excluded from his reasoning and anything which might or probably does not exist is likewise aside the point. The Proslogion had already stated "anything else whatsoever other than [God] can be thought not to exist". The Proslogion' s argument concerns and can only concern

2109-623: Is known. However, in 1094, the Welsh had begun to recover their lands from the Marcher Lords and William's 1095 invasion had accomplished little; two larger forays were made in 1097 against Cadwgan in Powys and Gruffudd in Gwynedd . These were also unsuccessful and William was compelled to erect a series of border fortresses. He charged Anselm with having given him insufficient knights for

2220-593: Is possibly drawn from Tractate XXIX of St Augustine 's Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John : regarding John 7 :14–18, Augustine counseled "Do not seek to understand in order to believe but believe that thou may understand". Anselm rephrased the idea repeatedly and Thomas Williams ( SEP 2007 ) considered that his aptest motto was the original title of the Proslogion , "faith seeking understanding", which intended "an active love of God seeking

2331-716: Is precisely that attribute itself". A letter survives of Anselm responding to Lanfranc's criticism of the work. The elder cleric took exception to its lack of appeals to scripture and authority. The preface of the Proslogion records his own dissatisfaction with the Monologion' s arguments, since they are rooted in a posteriori evidence and inductive reasoning . The Proslogion ( Latin : Proslogium , "Discourse"), originally entitled Faith Seeking Understanding ( Fides Quaerens Intellectum ) and then An Address on God's Existence ( Alloquium de Dei Existentia ),

SECTION 20

#1732781040678

2442-412: Is that it was proper that Mary should be so pure that—apart from God—no purer being could be imagined. The second was his treatment of original sin. Earlier theologians had held that it was transmitted from generation to generation by the sinful nature of sex . As in his earlier works, Anselm instead held that Adam 's sin was borne by his descendants through the change in human nature which occurred during

2553-742: The Chronicle of the Kings of England , drew heavily on the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle for both structure and content, in the History of the English Bishops the author had no ready guide and had to set up a new structure for the work. This he did by arranging his material by diocese and grouping the dioceses by the ancient Anglo-Saxon kingdoms they had belonged to. Within the description and history of each diocese, William wrote about

2664-574: The Cur Deus Homo . Upon William's return, Anselm insisted that he travel to the court of Urban II to secure the pallium that legitimized his office. On 25 February 1095, the Lords Spiritual and Temporal of England met in a council at Rockingham to discuss the issue. The next day, William ordered the bishops not to treat Anselm as their primate or as Canterbury's archbishop, as he openly adhered to Urban. The bishops sided with

2775-486: The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle , episcopal lists and the letters and works of his predecessors and contemporaries. For example William had put together a collection of letters and texts by St Anselm . There is also evidence to suggest William travelled to many of the places he mentions and used local manuscripts and he also provides many detailed topographical observations. Magdalen College, Oxford MS lat. 172

2886-785: The Greek Church . Anselm arrived in Rome by April and, according to his biographer Eadmer , lived beside the pope during the Siege of Capua in May. Count Roger 's Saracen troops supposedly offered him food and other gifts but the count actively resisted the clerics' attempts to convert them to Catholicism. At the Council of Bari in October, Anselm delivered his defence of the Filioque and

2997-566: The Holy Face of Lucca that neither Anselm nor any other would sit at Canterbury while he lived but in March he fell seriously ill at Alveston . Believing his sinful behavior was responsible, he summoned Anselm to hear his confession and administer last rites . He published a proclamation releasing his captives, discharging his debts, and promising to henceforth govern according to the law. On 6 March 1093, he further nominated Anselm to fill

3108-591: The Investiture Controversy . For his resistance to the English kings William II and Henry I , he was exiled twice: once from 1097 to 1100 and then from 1105 to 1107. While in exile, he helped guide the Greek Catholic bishops of southern Italy to adopt Roman rites at the Council of Bari . He worked for the primacy of Canterbury over the archbishop of York and over the bishops of Wales but, though at his death he appeared to have been successful, Pope Paschal II later reversed papal decisions on

3219-485: The Monologion' s prologue. However, he takes pains to present his reasons for belief in God without appeal to scriptural or patristic authority, using new and bold arguments. He attributes this style—and the book's existence—to the requests of his fellow monks that "nothing whatsoever in these matters should be made convincing by the authority of Scripture, but whatsoever... the necessity of reason would concisely prove". In

3330-772: The Treaty of Alton instead, renouncing his claims for an annual payment of 3000  marks . Anselm held a council at Lambeth Palace which found that Henry's beloved Matilda had not technically become a nun and was thus eligible to wed and become queen. On Michaelmas in 1102, Anselm was finally able to convene a general church council at London , establishing the Gregorian Reform within England. The council prohibited marriage, concubinage , and drunkenness to all those in holy orders, condemned sodomy and simony , and regulated clerical dress . Anselm also obtained

3441-412: The question-begging nature of "greatness" in this formula partially by appeal to intuition and partially by independent consideration of the attributes being examined. The incompatibility of, e.g., omnipotence, justness, and mercifulness are addressed in the abstract by reason, although Anselm concedes that specific acts of God are a matter of revelation beyond the scope of reasoning. At one point during

Gesta Pontificum Anglorum - Misplaced Pages Continue

3552-529: The satisfaction theory of atonement . Anselm was born in or around Aosta in Upper Burgundy sometime between April 1033 and April 1034. The area now forms part of the Republic of Italy , but Aosta had been part of the post- Carolingian Kingdom of Burgundy until the death of the childless Rudolph III in 1032. The Emperor Conrad II and Odo II, Count of Blois then went to war over

3663-535: The single greatest entity out of all existing things. That entity both must exist and must be God. All of Anselm's dialogues take the form of a lesson between a gifted and inquisitive student and a knowledgeable teacher. Except for in Cur Deus Homo , the student is not identified but the teacher is always recognizably Anselm himself. Anselm's De Grammatico ("On the Grammarian"), of uncertain date, deals with eliminating various paradoxes arising from

3774-415: The 15th chapter, he reaches the conclusion that God is "not only that than which nothing greater can be thought but something greater than can be thought". In any case, God's unity is such that all of his attributes are to be understood as facets of a single nature: "all of them are one and each of them is entirely what [God is] and what the other[s] are". This is then used to argue for the triune nature of

3885-553: The Bishop of Durham. The king agreed to publicly support Urban's cause in exchange for acknowledgement of his rights to accept no legates without invitation and to block clerics from receiving or obeying papal letters without his approval. William's greatest desire was for Anselm to be removed from office. Walter said that "there was good reason to expect a successful issue in accordance with the king's wishes" but, upon William's open acknowledgement of Urban as pope, Walter refused to depose

3996-488: The Devil's Fall"). De Veritate is concerned not merely with the truth of statements but with correctness in will, action, and essence as well. Correctness in such matters is understood as doing what a thing ought or was designed to do. Anselm employs Aristotelian logic to affirm the existence of an absolute truth of which all other truth forms separate kinds. He identifies this absolute truth with God, who therefore forms

4107-612: The English Bishops enjoyed reasonable success and was known in England during the next century, although its popularity paled besides that of its companion work, the Chronicle of the Kings of England , which within William's lifetime was known not only in England, but in Flanders, France and Normandy. It became the basis of a number of later works dealing with ecclesiastical history, including those written at Durham , Bury St Edmunds and Worcester . Although William's concurrent work,

4218-476: The English monarchy for support of the reform agenda. His principled opposition to royal prerogatives over the Catholic Church, meanwhile, twice led to his exile from England. The traditional view of historians has been to see Anselm as aligned with the papacy against lay authority and Anselm's term in office as the English theatre of the Investiture Controversy begun by Pope Gregory VII and

4329-551: The English"), originally titled De Gestis Regum Anglorum ("On the Deeds of the Kings of the English") and also anglicized as The Chronicles or The History of the Kings of England , is an early-12th-century history of the kings of England by William of Malmesbury . It is a companion work of his Gesta Pontificum Anglorum ( Deeds of the English Bishops ) and was followed by his Historia Novella , which continued its account for several more years. The portions of

4440-481: The God, Jesus , and "the one love common to [God] and [his] Son, that is, the Holy Spirit who proceeds from both". The last three chapters are a digression on what God's goodness might entail. Extracts from the work were later compiled under the name Meditations or The Manual of St Austin . The argument presented in the Proslogion has rarely seemed satisfactory and was swiftly opposed by Gaunilo ,

4551-514: The Reason for Faith ( Monoloquium de Ratione Fidei ) and sometimes also known as An Example of Meditation on the Reason for Faith ( Exemplum Meditandi de Ratione Fidei ), was written in 1075 and 1076. It follows St Augustine to such an extent that Gibson argues neither Boethius nor Anselm state anything which was not already dealt with in greater detail by Augustine's De Trinitate ; Anselm even acknowledges his debt to that work in

Gesta Pontificum Anglorum - Misplaced Pages Continue

4662-456: The Red—refused the appointment of any successor and appropriated the see's lands and revenues for himself. Fearing the difficulties that would attend being named to the position in opposition to the king, Anselm avoided journeying to England during this time. The gravely ill Hugh, Earl of Chester , finally lured him over with three pressing messages in 1092, seeking advice on how best to handle

4773-766: The Trinity and on the Incarnation of the Word Against the Blasphemies of Roscelin"), also known as Epistolae de Incarnatione Verbi ("Letters on the Incarnation of the Word"), was written in two drafts in 1092 and 1094. It defended Lanfranc and Anselm from association with the supposedly tritheist heresy espoused by Roscelin of Compiègne , as well as arguing in favour of Trinitarianism and universals . De Conceptu Virginali et de Originali Peccato ("On

4884-536: The Virgin Conception and Original Sin") was written in 1099. He claimed to have written it out of a desire to expand on an aspect of Cur Deus Homo for his student and friend Boso and takes the form of Anselm's half of a conversation with him. Although Anselm denied belief in Mary 's Immaculate Conception , his thinking laid two principles which formed the groundwork for that dogma's development. The first

4995-421: The archbishop. William then tried to sell the pallium to others, failed, tried to extract a payment from Anselm for the pallium, but was again refused. William then tried to personally bestow the pallium to Anselm, an act connoting the church's subservience to the throne, and was again refused. In the end, the pallium was laid on the altar at Canterbury, whence Anselm took it on 10 June 1095. The First Crusade

5106-640: The bishoprics of York , Lindisfarne and Durham . William admitted to not knowing a great deal about the monasteries in the north of England and only covered those at Wearmouth and Whitby . William also touches on other aspects from history such as the well preserved Roman remains at Carlisle , where he mentions a stone vaulted triclinium . The Kingdom of Mercia : Covers the bishoprics of Worcester , Hereford , Lichfield/Coventry , Dorchester/Lincoln and Ely . More familiar territory to William than Northumbria, he describes nineteen monasteries. The history of Malmesbury Abbey , to which William belonged, and

5217-533: The bishops and monasteries, plus any additional interesting information. The Kingdom of Kent : Beginning with the primatial see of Canterbury and its first archbishop St Augustine , it then leads on to the bishopric of Rochester . The Kingdoms of East Anglia , Essex , Sussex and Wessex : In addition to the bishoprics of London , Norwich , Winchester , Sherborne , Salisbury , Bath , Exeter and Chichester William also details twenty-three religious houses . The Kingdom of Northumbria : Including

5328-484: The bishops' vestments , but Anselm later collected his arguments on the topic as De Processione Spiritus Sancti . Under pressure from their Norman lords , the Italian Greeks seem to have accepted papal supremacy and Anselm's theology. The council also condemned William II. Eadmer credited Anselm with restraining the pope from excommunicating him, although others attribute Urban's politic nature. Anselm

5439-513: The bounds of justice. Humans, meanwhile, retain the theoretical capacity to will justly but, owing to the Fall , they are incapable of doing so in practice except by divine grace. Cur Deus Homo ("Why God was a Man") was written from 1095 to 1098 once Anselm was already archbishop of Canterbury as a response for requests to discuss the Incarnation . It takes the form of a dialogue between Anselm and Boso, one of his students. Its core

5550-576: The campaign and tried to fine him. In the face of William's refusal to fulfill his promise of church reform, Anselm resolved to proceed to Rome—where an army of French crusaders had finally installed Urban—in order to seek the counsel of the pope. William again denied him permission. The negotiations ended with Anselm being "given the choice of exile or total submission": if he left, William declared he would seize Canterbury and never again receive Anselm as archbishop; if he were to stay, William would impose his fine and force him to swear never again to appeal to

5661-544: The conditions under which he would accept the position, which amounted to the agenda of the Gregorian Reform : the king would have to return the Catholic Church lands which had been seized, accept his spiritual counsel, and forswear Antipope Clement III in favour of Urban II . William Rufus was exceedingly reluctant to accept these conditions: he consented only to the first and, a few days afterwards, reneged on that, suspending preparations for Anselm's investiture . Public pressure forced William to return to Anselm and in

SECTION 50

#1732781040678

5772-464: The disastrous fire of the 1170s, his remains were relocated, although it is now uncertain where. On 23 December 1752, Archbishop Herring was contacted by Count Perron , the Sardinian ambassador , on behalf of King Charles Emmanuel , who requested permission to translate Anselm's relics to Italy. (Charles had been duke of Aosta during his minority.) Herring ordered his dean to look into

5883-606: The earlier theory developed by Origen and Gregory of Nyssa that had focused primarily on Satan 's power over fallen man . Cur Deus Homo is often accounted Anselm's greatest work, but the legalist and amoral nature of the argument, along with its neglect of the individuals actually being redeemed, has been criticized both by comparison with the treatment by Abelard and for its subsequent development in Protestant theology. Anselm's De Fide Trinitatis et de Incarnatione Verbi Contra Blasphemias Ruzelini ("On Faith in

5994-553: The emperor Henry IV. By the end of his life, he had proven successful, having freed Canterbury from submission to the English king, received papal recognition of the submission of wayward York and the Welsh bishops , and gained strong authority over the Irish bishops. He died before the Canterbury–York dispute was definitively settled, however, and Pope Honorius II finally found in favour of York instead. Although

6105-427: The end they settled on a partial return of Canterbury's lands as his own concession. Anselm received dispensation from his duties in Normandy, did homage to William, and—on 25 September 1093—was enthroned at Canterbury Cathedral . The same day, William II finally returned the lands of the see. From the mid-8th century, it had become the custom that metropolitan bishops could not be consecrated without

6216-432: The establishment of a new monastery at St Werburgh's . Hugh was recovered by the time of Anselm's arrival, but he was occupied four or five months by his assistance. He then travelled to his former pupil Gilbert Crispin , abbot of Westminster , and waited, apparently delayed by the need to assemble the donors of Bec's new lands in order to obtain royal approval of the grants. At Christmas, William II pledged by

6327-412: The existence of all other things. Chapter 4 argues that there must be the highest level of dignity among existing things and that the highest level must have a single member. "Therefore, there is a certain nature or substance or essence who through himself is good and great and through himself is what he is; through whom exists whatever truly is good or great or anything at all; and who is the supreme good,

6438-454: The family estates. In later life, there are records of three relations who visited Bec: Folceraldus, Haimo, and Rainaldus. The first repeatedly attempted to exploit Anselm's renown, but was rebuffed since he already had his ties to another monastery, whereas Anselm's attempts to persuade the other two to join the Bec community were unsuccessful. At the age of fifteen, Anselm felt the call to enter

6549-459: The figure of Jesus , as a sinless being both fully divine and fully human. Taking it upon himself to offer his own life on our behalf, his crucifixion accrues infinite worth, more than redeeming mankind and permitting it to enjoy a just will in accord with its intended nature. This interpretation is notable for permitting divine justice and mercy to be entirely compatible and has exercised immense influence over church doctrine, largely supplanting

6660-427: The first chapter, Anselm begins with a statement that anyone should be able to convince themselves of the existence of God through reason alone "if he is even moderately intelligent". He argues that many different things are known as "good", in many varying kinds and degrees. These must be understood as being judged relative to a single attribute of goodness. He then argues that goodness is itself very good and, further,

6771-413: The fundamental principle both in the existence of things and the correctness of thought. As a corollary, he affirms that "everything that is, is rightly". De Libertate Arbitrii elaborates Anselm's reasoning on correctness with regard to free will . He does not consider this a capacity to sin but a capacity to do good for its own sake (as opposed to owing to coercion or for self-interest). God and

SECTION 60

#1732781040678

6882-452: The furtherance of God's glory. Further, God's infinite justice demands infinite restitution for the impairment of his infinite dignity. The enormity of the offence led Anselm to reject personal acts of atonement, even Peter Damian 's flagellation , as inadequate and ultimately vain. Instead, full recompense could only be made by God, which His infinite mercy inclines Him to provide. Atonement for humanity, however, could only be made through

6993-979: The good angels therefore have free will despite being incapable of sinning; similarly, the non-coercive aspect of free will enabled man and the rebel angels to sin, despite this not being a necessary element of free will itself. In De Casu Diaboli , Anselm further considers the case of the fallen angels, which serves to discuss the case of rational agents in general. The teacher argues that there are two forms of good—justice ( justicia ) and benefit ( commodum )—and two forms of evil: injustice and harm ( incommodum ). All rational beings seek benefit and shun harm on their own account but independent choice permits them to abandon bounds imposed by justice. Some angels chose their own happiness in preference to justice and were punished by God for their injustice with less happiness. The angels who upheld justice were rewarded with such happiness that they are now incapable of sin, there being no happiness left for them to seek in opposition to

7104-486: The grammar of Latin nouns and adjectives by examining the syllogisms involved to ensure the terms in the premises agree in meaning and not merely expression. The treatment shows a clear debt to Boethius 's treatment of Aristotle . Between 1080 and 1086, while still at Bec, Anselm composed the dialogues De Veritate ("On Truth"), De Libertate Arbitrii ("On the Freedom of Choice"), and De Casu Diaboli ("On

7215-566: The king directly and through his sister Adela expressing his own willingness to excommunicate Henry. This was probably a negotiation tactic but it came at a critical period in Henry's reign and it worked: a meeting was arranged and a compromise concluded at L'Aigle on 22 July 1105. Henry would forsake lay investiture if Anselm obtained Paschal's permission for clerics to do homage for their lands; Henry's bishops' and counsellors' excommunications were to be lifted provided they advise him to obey

7326-466: The king himself. After this ruling, Anselm received a letter forbidding his return and withdrew to Lyon to await Paschal's response. On 26 March 1105, Paschal again excommunicated prelates who had accepted investment from Henry and the advisors responsible, this time including Robert de Beaumont , Henry's chief advisor. He further finally threatened Henry with the same; in April, Anselm sent messages to

7437-513: The king, the Bishop of Durham presenting his case and even advising William to depose and exile Anselm. The nobles siding with Anselm, the conference ended in deadlock and the matter was postponed. Immediately following this, William secretly sent William Warelwast and Gerard to Italy, prevailing on Urban to send a legate bearing Canterbury's pallium. Walter, bishop of Albano , was chosen and negotiated in secret with William's representative,

7548-411: The life of its founding Abbot , St Aldhelm . The History of the English Bishops , in the manner of many chroniclers' continuations, begins where Bede 's Historia Ecclesiastica Gentis Anglorum left off. So William relied heavily on the work of Bede for the early historical information, but also used the work of other medieval historians such as Eadmer . He also used records and documents such as

7659-402: The matter and restored York's earlier status. Beginning at Bec , Anselm composed dialogues and treatises with a rational and philosophical approach, which have sometimes caused him to be credited as the founder of Scholasticism . Despite his lack of recognition in this field in his own time, Anselm is now famous as the originator of the ontological argument for the existence of God and of

7770-573: The matter, saying that while "the parting with the rotten Remains of a Rebel to his King, a Slave to the Popedom, and an Enemy to the married Clergy (all this Anselm was)" would be no great matter, he likewise "should make no Conscience of palming on the Simpletons any other old Bishop with the Name of Anselm". The ambassador insisted on witnessing the excavation, however, and resistance on the part of

7881-522: The monastery's property, to wait upon his sovereign William I of England (formerly Duke William II of Normandy), and to visit Lanfranc, who had been installed as archbishop of Canterbury in 1070. He was respected by William I and the good impression he made while in Canterbury made him the favourite of its cathedral chapter as a future successor to Lanfranc. Instead, upon the archbishop's death in 1089, King William II —William Rufus or William

7992-545: The most important passes in the Western Alps and formed the county of Savoy whose dynasty would later rule the kingdoms of Sardinia and Italy . Records during this period are scanty, but both sides of Anselm's immediate family appear to have been dispossessed by these decisions in favour of their extended relations. His father Gundulph or Gundulf or Gondulphe was a Lombard noble, probably one of Adelaide's Arduinici uncles or cousins; his mother Ermenberge

8103-478: The next year. His father having died, he consulted with Lanfranc as to whether to return to his estates and employ their income in providing alms for the poor or to renounce them, becoming a hermit or a monk at Bec or Cluny . Given what he saw as his own conflict of interest, Lanfranc sent Anselm to Maurilius , the archbishop of Rouen , who convinced him to enter Bec as a novice at the age of 27. Probably in his first year, he wrote his first work on philosophy,

8214-499: The one that followed it. Meanwhile, Anselm publicly supported Henry against the claims and threatened invasion of his brother Robert Curthose . Anselm wooed wavering barons to the king's cause, emphasizing the religious nature of their oaths and duty of loyalty; he supported the deposition of Ranulf Flambard , the disloyal new bishop of Durham ; and he threatened Robert with excommunication. The lack of popular support greeting his invasion near Portsmouth compelled Robert to accept

8325-540: The pallium for the archbishop of York to Canterbury so that future archbishops-elect would have to profess obedience before receiving it. The incumbent archbishop Thomas II had received his own pallium directly and insisted on York 's independence. From his deathbed, Anselm anathematized all who failed to recognize Canterbury's primacy over all the English Church. This ultimately forced Henry to order Thomas to confess his obedience to Anselm's successor. On his deathbed, he announced himself content, except that he had

8436-419: The papacy (Anselm performed this act on his own authority and later had to answer for it to Paschal); the revenues of Canterbury would be returned to the archbishop; and priests would no longer be permitted to marry. Anselm insisted on the agreement's ratification by the pope before he would consent to return to England, but wrote to Paschal in favour of the deal, arguing that Henry's forsaking of lay investiture

8547-538: The papacy. Anselm chose to depart in October 1097. Although Anselm retained his nominal title, William immediately seized the revenues of his bishopric and retained them til death. From Lyon , Anselm wrote to Urban, requesting that he be permitted to resign his office. Urban refused but commissioned him to prepare a defence of the Western doctrine of the procession of the Holy Spirit against representatives from

8658-437: The pontiff had been receptive to Henry's counsel and secretly approved of Anselm's submission to the crown. In 1103, then, Anselm consented to journey himself to Rome, along with the king's envoy William Warelwast . Anselm supposedly travelled in order to argue the king's case for a dispensation but, in response to this third mission, Paschal fully excommunicated the bishops who had accepted investment from Henry, though sparing

8769-432: The prebendaries seems to have quieted the matter. They considered the state of the cathedral's crypts would have offended the sensibilities of a Catholic and that it was probable that Anselm had been removed to near the altar of SS  Peter and Paul , whose side chapel to the right (i.e., south) of the high altar took Anselm's name following his canonization. At that time, his relics would presumably have been placed in

8880-435: The rational grounds for central aspects of Christian doctrines as a pedagogical exercise for his initial audience of fellow monks and correspondents. The subjects of Anselm's works were sometimes dictated by contemporary events, such as his speech at the Council of Bari or the need to refute his association with the thinking of Roscelin , but he intended for his books to form a unity, with his letters and latter works advising

8991-402: The reader to consult his other books for the arguments supporting various points in his reasoning. It seems to have been a recurring problem that early drafts of his works were copied and circulated without his permission. While at Bec, Anselm composed: While archbishop of Canterbury, he composed: The Monologion ( Latin : Monologium , "Monologue"), originally entitled A Monologue on

9102-412: The revisions removing potentially offensive remarks about his contemporaries. Copies were made of the manuscript prior to and after the revisions and subsequently several descendants of these as well. All together there are nineteen medieval versions of the manuscript that provide us with a complex yet large record of the history of the text. The first printed edition of the History of the English Bishops

9213-465: The rights of the church against the king. Anselm returned to England before the new year. In 1107, the Concordat of London formalized the agreements between the king and archbishop, Henry formally renounced the right of English kings to invest the bishops of the church. The remaining two years of Anselm's life were spent in the duties of his archbishopric. He succeeded in getting Paschal to send

9324-569: The succession. Humbert the White-Handed , Count of Maurienne , so distinguished himself that he was granted a new county carved out of the secular holdings of the bishop of Aosta . Humbert's son Otto was subsequently permitted to inherit the extensive March of Susa through his wife Adelaide in preference to her uncle's families, who had supported the effort to establish an independent Kingdom of Italy under William V, Duke of Aquitaine . Otto and Adelaide's unified lands then controlled

9435-456: The supreme great thing, the supreme being or subsistent, that is, supreme among all existing things." The remaining chapters of the book are devoted to consideration of the attributes necessary to such a being. The Euthyphro dilemma , although not addressed by that name, is dealt with as a false dichotomy . God is taken to neither conform to nor invent the moral order but to embody it: in each case of his attributes, "God having that attribute

9546-409: The text over at least the next decade. His edits often removed comments about his contemporaries. Unfortunately, some of William's marginalia are affected by a trimming by a bookbinder in the 17th century. This is the only medieval manuscript in which Book Five survives in full although there are a handful of later copies. William continued to revise the text over the next decade or so, with many of

9657-507: The tide. Anselm's reply ( Responsio ) or apology ( Liber Apologeticus ) does not address this argument directly, which has led Klima , Grzesik, and others to construct replies for him and led Wolterstorff and others to conclude that Gaunilo's attack is definitive. Anselm, however, considered that Gaunilo had misunderstood his argument. In each of Gaunilo's four arguments, he takes Anselm's description of "that than which nothing greater can be thought" to be equivalent to "that which

9768-480: The use of unleavened bread in the Eucharist before 185 bishops. Although this is sometimes portrayed as a failed ecumenical dialogue , it is more likely that the "Greeks" present were the local bishops of Southern Italy, some of whom had been ruled by Constantinople as recently as 1071. The formal acts of the council have been lost and Eadmer's account of Anselm's speech principally consists of descriptions of

9879-470: The vacancy at Canterbury; the clerics gathered at court acclaiming him, forcing the crozier into his hands, and bodily carrying him to a nearby church amid a Te Deum . Anselm tried to refuse on the grounds of age and ill-health for months and the monks of Bec refused to give him permission to leave them. Negotiations were handled by the recently restored Bishop William of Durham and Robert, count of Meulan . On 24 August, Anselm gave King William

9990-620: The work concerning the First Crusade were derived from Gesta Francorum Iherusalem peregrinantium , a chronicle by Fulcher of Chartres . This article related to the history of England is a stub . You can help Misplaced Pages by expanding it . Anselm of Canterbury Anselm of Canterbury OSB ( / ˈ æ n s ɛ l m / ; 1033/4–1109), also called Anselm of Aosta (French: Anselme d'Aoste , Italian: Anselmo d'Aosta ) after his birthplace and Anselm of Bec (French: Anselme du Bec ) after his monastery ,

10101-412: The work was largely handled by Christ Church's priors Ernulf (1096–1107) and Conrad (1108–1126), Anselm's episcopate also saw the expansion of Canterbury Cathedral from Lanfranc's initial plans. The eastern end was demolished and an expanded choir placed over a large and well-decorated crypt , doubling the cathedral's length. The new choir formed a church unto itself with its own transepts and

10212-532: The work. In it, Anselm reasoned that even atheists can imagine the greatest being, having such attributes that nothing greater could exist ( id quo nihil maius cogitari possit ). However, if such a being's attributes did not include existence, a still greater being could be imagined: one with all of the attributes of the first and existence. Therefore, the truly greatest possible being must necessarily exist. Further, this necessarily-existing greatest being must be God, who therefore necessarily exists. This reasoning

10323-605: The works of Boethius . He or the thinkers in northern France who shortly followed him—including Abelard , William of Conches , and Gilbert of Poitiers —inaugurated "one of the most brilliant periods of Western philosophy ", innovating logic , semantics , ethics , metaphysics , and other areas of philosophical theology . Anselm held that faith necessarily precedes reason, but that reason can expand upon faith: "And I do not seek to understand that I may believe but believe that I might understand. For this too I believe since, unless I first believe, I shall not understand." This

10434-545: The younger monks. There was also admiration for his spirited defence of the abbey's independence from lay and archiepiscopal control, especially in the face of Robert de Beaumont, Earl of Leicester and the new Archbishop of Rouen, William Bona Anima . Following the Norman Conquest of England in 1066, devoted lords had given the abbey extensive lands across the Channel . Anselm occasionally visited to oversee

10545-413: Was a greater victory than the matter of homage. On 23 March 1106, Paschal wrote Anselm accepting the terms established at L'Aigle, although both clerics saw this as a temporary compromise and intended to continue pressing for reforms, including the ending of homage to lay authorities. Even after this, Anselm refused to return to England. Henry travelled to Bec and met with him on 15 August 1106. Henry

10656-467: Was a young monk named Osborne. Anselm overcame his hostility first by praising, indulging, and privileging him in all things despite his hostility and then, when his affection and trust were gained, gradually withdrawing all preference until he upheld the strictest obedience. Along similar lines, he remonstrated with a neighbouring abbot who complained that his charges were incorrigible despite being beaten "night and day". After fifteen years, in 1078, Anselm

10767-542: Was almost certainly the granddaughter of Conrad the Peaceful , related both to the Anselmid bishops of Aosta and to the heirs of Henry II who had been passed over in favour of Conrad. The marriage was thus probably arranged for political reasons but proved ineffective in opposing Conrad after his successful annexation of Burgundy on 1 August 1034. ( Bishop Burchard subsequently revolted against imperial control but

10878-434: Was among those expected to pay him. He offered £ 500 but William refused, encouraged by his courtiers to insist on £1000 as a kind of annates for Anselm's elevation to archbishop. Anselm not only refused, he further pressed the king to fill England's other vacant positions, permit bishops to meet freely in councils, and to allow Anselm to resume enforcement of canon law , particularly against incestuous marriages , until he

10989-540: Was an Italian Benedictine monk , abbot , philosopher , and theologian of the Catholic Church , who held the office of Archbishop of Canterbury from 1093 to 1109. After his death, he was canonized as a saint ; his feast day is 21 April. He was proclaimed a Doctor of the Church by a papal bull of Pope Clement XI in 1720. As Archbishop of Canterbury, he defended the church's interests in England amid

11100-534: Was declared at the Council of Clermont in November. Despite his service for the king which earned him rough treatment from Anselm's biographer Eadmer , upon the grave illness of the Bishop of Durham in December, Anselm journeyed to console and bless him on his deathbed. Over the next two years, William opposed several of Anselm's efforts at reform—including his right to convene a council —but no overt dispute

11211-587: Was defeated and was ultimately translated to the diocese of Lyon .) Ermenberge appears to have been the wealthier partner in the marriage. Gundulph moved to his wife's town, where she held a palace, most likely near the cathedral, along with a villa in the valley . Anselm's father is sometimes described as having a harsh and violent temper but contemporary accounts merely portray him as having been overgenerous or careless with his wealth; Meanwhile, Anselm's mother Ermenberge, patient and devoutly religious, made up for her husband's faults by her prudent management of

11322-562: Was forced to make further concessions. He restored to Canterbury all the churches that had been seized by William or during Anselm's exile, promising that nothing more would be taken from them and even providing Anselm with a security payment. Henry had initially taxed married clergy and, when their situation had been outlawed, had made up the lost revenue by controversially extending the tax over all Churchmen. He now agreed that any prelate who had paid this would be exempt from taxation for three years. These compromises on Henry's part strengthened

11433-463: Was known to the Scholastics as "Anselm's argument" ( ratio Anselmi ) but it became known as the ontological argument for the existence of God following Kant 's treatment of it. More probably, Anselm intended his "single argument" to include most of the rest of the work as well, wherein he establishes the attributes of God and their compatibility with one another. Continuing to construct

11544-417: Was ordered by Henry to do homage for his Canterbury estates and to receive his investiture by ring and crozier anew. Despite having done so under William, the bishop now refused to violate canon law . Henry for his part refused to relinquish a right possessed by his predecessors and even sent an embassy to Pope Paschal II to present his case. Paschal reaffirmed Urban's bans to that mission and

11655-496: Was ordered to silence. When a group of bishops subsequently suggested that William might now settle for the original sum, Anselm replied that he had already given the money to the poor and "that he disdained to purchase his master's favour as he would a horse or ass". The king being told this, he replied Anselm's blessing for his invasion would not be needed as "I hated him before, I hate him now, and shall hate him still more hereafter". Withdrawing to Canterbury, Anselm began work on

11766-481: Was present and moved quickly to secure the throne before the return of his elder brother Robert, Duke of Normandy , from the First Crusade . Henry invited Anselm to return, pledging in his letter to submit himself to the archbishop's counsel. The cleric's support of Robert would have caused great trouble but Anselm returned before establishing any other terms than those offered by Henry. Once in England, Anselm

11877-558: Was present in a seat of honour at the Easter Council at St Peter's in Rome the next year. There, amid an outcry to address Anselm's situation, Urban renewed bans on lay investiture and on clerics doing homage. Anselm departed the next day, first for Schiavi —where he completed his work Cur Deus Homo —and then for Lyon . William Rufus was killed hunting in the New Forest on 2 August 1100. His brother Henry

11988-404: Was produced by Sir Henry Savile in 1596. He used Cambridge University Library's MS Ff.1.25.1 as his source and so it contains only the first four books. The source manuscript itself was a descendant of British Library Royal 13 D V, itself a copy of Magdalen College, Oxford MS lat. 172. Gesta Regum Anglorum The Gesta Regum Anglorum ( Latin for "Deeds of the Kings of

12099-524: Was unanimously elected as Bec's abbot following the death of its founder, the warrior-monk Herluin . He was blessed as abbot by Gilbert d'Arques , Bishop of Évreux, on 22 February 1079. Under Anselm's direction, Bec became the foremost seat of learning in Europe, attracting students from France, Italy , and elsewhere. During this time, he wrote the Monologion and Proslogion . He then composed

12210-577: Was written around 1125 in William's own hand, making it the oldest surviving autograph manuscript from England. It takes the form of a pocket-sized book, its parchment leaves measuring 7.1 by 4.8 inches. At the head of folio 1 is the Malmesbury Abbey impressed mark, and a pagination in Arabic numerals in a 14th-century hand indicates that no pages have been lost since then. It contains his subsequent annotations which show he continued to revise

12321-400: Was written over the next two years (1077–1078). It is written in the form of an extended direct address to God. It grew out of his dissatisfaction with the Monologion 's interlinking and contingent arguments. His "single argument that needed nothing but itself alone for proof, that would by itself be enough to show that God really exists" is commonly taken to be merely the second chapter of

#677322